Playwrights and Literary Games in Seventeenth-Century China approaches the works of five late Ming and early Qing dramatists through the lens of intertextuality. The book contends that the composition and consumption of chuanqi plays should be partly understood as a literary game insofar as the playwrights were part of a cultural elite who, more often than not, self-consciously refashioned earlier literature for the benefit of other cultural cognoscenti. At the same time, Playwrights suggests that that the aesthetic and ideological effects of such acts of appropriation varied, ranging from a reinforcement of Confucian codes in some plays to ironic parodies of conventional values in others. In total, Playwrights offers close readings of the appropriative strategies and readerly effects of six important chuanqi plays, thus providing the most extensive English-language discussion to date of representative works of the genre.
In three introductory chapters, Playwrights summarizes previous scholarship in order to locate the rise of the chuanqi genre as an elite form in the literary and social realm of the late Ming and early Qing periods. Thereafter, in the second, third, and fourth parts of the book, Playwrights organizes its analysis around three recurrent literary features of chuanqi plays: (1) the reworking of Tang dynasty tale fiction; (2) the use of shi poetry within plays; and (3) the occurrence of a play within the play. For each section, Jing Shen provides an overall introduction to the section, biographical sketches for the playwrights, and close readings of select plays. While three of the playwrights under discussion, Tang Xianzu (1550–1616), Li Yu (1610–80), and Kong Shangren (1648–1718) have been the subject of other articles and monographs, the book not only expands the discussion to include less well-known playwrights such as Mei Dingzuo (1549–1615) and Wu Bing (1595–1648), but broadens our understanding of the genre of chuanqi by identifying both commonalities and variations in the handling of dramatic subject matter and form by a diverse cross-section of dramatic practitioners of successive generations.
In chapters 4 and 5, Playwrights addresses the question of why Ming chuanqi heavily relied on Tang chuanqi stories for plot inspiration. Shen identifies two major factors. First, renewed Ming interest and publication of Tang chuanqi made them widely available in the late Ming; second, the dilemmas between public commitment and private integrity found in the Tang tales resonated with Ming writers caught between Confucian ideals and bureaucratic realities. The pairs of tales and plays that Shen examines in detail in order to make a case for this adaptive mirroring include Tang Xianzu's use of “The Story of Huo Xiaoyu” in the play The Purple Hairpin (Zichaiji) and Mei Dingzuo's rewriting of “The Story of Miss Liu” in The Jade Box (Yuhe ji). However, for all the inspiration, Tang Xianzu modified the tale's concern with pedigree to reflect the Ming concern with the individual's dependence on bureaucratic and court institutions, and Mei Dingzuo transplanted the story from a courtesan to a gentry milieu, while also underscoring the all-encompassing ambit of officialdom. Accordingly, in turning public service into a key source of dramatic conflicts, the plays grant the writers and their audiences the reconciliation of individual desires with institutional values often absent in real life.
In chapters 6 and 7, Playwrights turns its attention to the role that poetry plays in negotiating gendered subjectivities in chuanqi love comedies. The two plays under consideration are Wu Bing's Green Peony (Lü mudan) and Li Yu's The Kite's Mistake (Fengzheng wu). In Shen's reading, Green Peony affirms the notion that self-cultivation leads to status advancement for worthy male contenders; male interlopers as well as female poets, on the other hand, are exposed as such. In exploiting the misuse of poetic conventions as the major source of dramatic conflict, the play serves to consolidate a sense of elite identity at the expense of dramatic fools. If Green Peony unabashedly celebrates elite sensibilities, the popular Kite's Mistake gently pokes fun at elite values, but at the same time affirms the notion of literary sophistication in its tongue-in-cheek treatment of scholar-beauty romances, most notably the Story of the Western Wing.
In chapters 8 and 9, Playwrights explores the phenomenon of the play-within-the-play as part of a growing self-reflexivity regarding the theatrical possibilities of drama. The plays under investigation here are Li Yu's The Flounders (Bimuyu) and Kong Shangren's Peach Blossom Fan (Taohua shan). In Li Yu's play, the play within the play allows for an exploration of the author's ingenuity and novelty in the fashioning of Confucian tropes; by contrast, Peach Blossom Fan incorporates multiple chuanqi plays (The Peony Pavilion by Tang Xianzu, The Swallow Letter by Ruan Dacheng, and The Crying Phoenix attributed to Wang Shizhen) to pursue a meditation on the power of drama itself. Importantly, Peach Blossom Fan seeks to guard against seductive, but potentially destructive plays like Peony Pavilion and Swallow Letter and instead aspires to vouch for the moral suasion of theater through a renewed Confucian grounding in ritual, music, and historicity.
