No Alternative demonstrates that the study of childbirth is a lens through which one can unearth social realities and analyse the dynamics of inequities under the guise of postmodern, well-intentioned liberation movements. It adds a needed layer to a growing body of scholarship in the social sciences on childbirth and reproduction, transnational feminisms, neoliberalism and the medicalisation of society. Proponents of humanised and respectful birth around the world have been pushing back on technocratic, authoritarian, highly interventionist forms of birth models, which have become hegemonic in most regions of the world. Most births in Mexico are highly medicalised and denounced by international midwifery and alternative health communities as obstetric violence and anti-woman. Despite this trend of medicalisation, Mexico is home to a growing international movement advocating alternative models of humanised births and a site where many midwives in the western hemisphere obtain training and certification. Rosalynn A. Vega, a US anthropologist of Mexican descent who spent over three years in Mexico amongst midwives, birthing centres and traditional healers in rural and urban communities, presents her ethnographic research on transnational bio-consumerism and biopiracy in her recently published monograph, No Alternative. In it, she argues that the global North and those who partake in the humanised birthing movement use their cultural capital and affluence to consume and market what they see as desirable indigenous culture, all the while excluding indigenous healers, midwives and rural women, thereby re-inscribing social, racial and economic inequalities and marginalisation. For Vega, the ways in which women birth and access reproductive health expose how some women are able to break from institutional and state impositions and national boundaries while others have little choice but to live at the margins and resort to public programmes, such as Oportunidades, which intrude on poor women's lives, extract obedience and create dependency in Mexico.
No Alternative deftly unpacks the ways in which medical knowledge and consumption circulate in a neoliberal context, expanding the citizenship and global mobility of those with access to privilege while constricting ‘immobile counterparts who are socially situated in ways that encourage them to seek government-provisioned service’ (p. 161) and are all too often pushed out of the very professional circles that bear their names. It is the indigenous, rural and impoverished sectors, whose ‘traditions’ are being fetishised by the global North, that end up living on the edges of citizenship. A clear illustration of this is the Mexican Midwifery Association, ‘composed almost entirely of foreign midwives … from the United States and Europe’ (p. 166). This book is replete with examples of how foreign and affluent sectors inadvertently objectify and disenfranchise (other) Mexicans as they leverage their cultural capital to seek greater agency and choice in subject-making for themselves. In many instances proponents of the humanised birthing movement present themselves as a ‘cosmopolitan … countercultural alternative to materialism and consumption’ who value intercultural social liberation but fail to realise the ways in which they re-inscribe racial hierarchies, heighten moralisation and commodify new-age, elite motherhood in the process (p. 96). Neoliberal notions of choice and freedom clash with ‘capitalist realities of deep socioeconomic inequality’ and limitation (p. 182). To be clear, Vega, on more than one occasion, states that she is in favour of de-medicalising birth and putting women in charge of their birthing experiences.
This book has an introduction, five chapters and a conclusion. Each chapter contains relatively short excerpts of Vega's experiences while doing her ethnographic research in Mexico in order to illustrate and support her claims. Though each chapter has a particular theme it wishes to privilege, like commodification of culture or race, it is apparent that these themes are interrelated and difficult to separate out from one another. Transitions between sections in each chapter sometimes seem disjointed, but they are rich in information. No Alternative is heavier on theory (and perhaps overstates what it is aiming to do) than on ethnographic storytelling. Vega's theoretical analysis is responsible and steeped in secondary-source support. Throughout the book, Vega enters into dialogue with cultural theorists and underpins her work with an impressive array of scholarship. For instance, Vega borrows from Latin American social scientists like Renée de la Torre, Cristina Gutiérrez Zúñiga and Nahayeilli Juárez Huet in their critique of New Age appropriation of ‘ethnic others’ as spiritual alternatives to materialism and consumption that result in the essentialisation and commodification of ethnic identities around the world (p. 95). In her narrative, Vega relies on Kimberlé Crenshaw's work on intersectionality, Khiara Bridges’ notions of pregnancy as a process of racialisation, Pierre Bourdieu's work regarding the relationship between cultural and economic capital, Marisol de la Cadena's discussion on indigenismo, and many influential medical anthropologists, amongst others.
Although most of Vega's critique of the ironies and limitations of humanised birth revolves around the commodification of indigenous knowledge and practices, she goes on to problematise other unintended consequences of the movement. For example, humanised birth emerged from feminist intentions of empowering women, but often results in creating new constraints and burdens on the mothers. The ideology of this movement inspires parents to place higher demands on themselves, such as choosing pain (labour and breastfeeding, which can be painful for some) and paying higher prices in private sectors, in order to give their children the best possible start in life (p. 71). By empowering women to be at the centre of birthing and parenting, the burdens and blame of rearing less-than-perfect children also become the responsibility of the parents.
This project accomplishes its goals of demonstrating how women's bodies and their reproductive options (or lack thereof) are sites where race, class and gender are created and transnational economies play out. It makes crucial intellectual interventions in the evolving fields of medical anthropology and transnational feminist studies.
