White etal. (Reference White, Ravid, Siderits and Behrend2022) call for researchers to be timelier in studying new technologies and offer several means by which to accomplish this. We wish to contribute to the conversation with a cautionary note and alternative call. Although we agree that it is necessary to conduct timelier research on new technologies, we argue that we also need to pay closer attention to understudied aspects of technology and work, and specifically issues related to inequality in access to technologies. Focusing on very new technologies that have not permeated the market, although worthwhile, may also run the risk that current issues with representativeness will be magnified and that findings will lack generalizability.
White etal. (Reference White, Ravid, Siderits and Behrend2022) mention the mass movement to virtual work for many organizations and workers due to the COVID-19 pandemic. As another result of the pandemic, research projects were forced to shift to fully virtual data collection. Consequently, samples were further limited to those with internet access—meaning that those who are disadvantaged were even more likely to be underrepresented. A2021 Pew Research Center poll of the United States suggests that roughly 40% of people in households that made under $30,000 a year did not have access to broadband service or a laptop/desktop computer at home (Vogels, Reference Vogels2021). According to figures from the United Nations, developing countries and the least developed countries have an estimated offline population of 53% and 80%, respectively, and even in developed countries, an estimated 13% of the population is offline (Li, Reference Li2021). This disparate access to technology and the resulting technological knowledge and skill deficit has been dubbed the “digital divide.” People with disabilities, women, and those who are older, inhabit isolated regions, and/or have a lower socioeconomic status are all more likely to experience the digital divide (Elena-Bucea etal., Reference Elena-Bucea, Cruz-Jesus, Oliveira and Coelho2021; Lai & Widmar, Reference Lai and Widmar2021). As restrictions mandating virtual research decrease, it is also especially timely for scholars to consider the ways in which the pandemic likely has exacerbated issues of representativeness in research on technology and work.
From this perspective of access and inclusion, we offer three suggestions for research to further the literature on technology and work: (a) consider the effects of disparate technology access, (b) target understudied populations, and (c) increase intradisciplinary collaboration. We advocate for several steps that may be more readily adoptable for scholars compared to the difficulties of gaining access to cutting-edge technologies that are not widely adopted and the noted challenges of interdisciplinary collaborations.
1. Consider how unequal access to technology affects our understanding of technology at work
Steeper initial prices mean that access to the newest technologies is even more inequitable compared to more established technologies. For example, at present virtual reality (VR) headsets (e.g., Oculus Rift, HTC Vive, and PlayStation VR) alone, not including accessories or applications, range $300–$500. Organizations and individuals who are early adopters tend to have sizeable resources to acquire and learn how to use these new technologies and can often afford early failures. Studying very new technologies among early adopters thus does not give a representative picture of the effectiveness of these technologies in the workplace. Until a technology has more traction in the marketplace, we may not see how it affects those who burdened by the digital divide. For instance, many people with disabilities use adaptive tools (e.g., screen readers for workers with vision impairments, adaptive mice or eye tracking devices for workers with fine motor impairments) to interact with digital technologies referenced by White etal. (Reference White, Ravid, Siderits and Behrend2022). Yet, new technologies are often not designed to conform to digital standards for accessibility and use with adaptive tools (Harper & Yesilada, Reference Harper and Yesilada2012).
Inequality surrounding technology access, including the extreme wealth disparity for access to new technologies, is an underexplored yet practically relevant area of technology and work. For one example, technostress is frequently studied as an outcome of technology use. The creators of technostress are conceptualized as overload, invasion, complexity, insecurity, and uncertainty (Tarafdar etal., Reference Tarafdar, Tu, Ragu-Nathan and Ragu-Nathan2007). How might technology inequality (within an industry, between competitors; or within an organization, between individuals, including members of virtual teams) promote feelings of stress and affect performance? We also highlighted the effect of the COVID-19 pandemic on research designs; has the digital divide further perpetuated inequities given the shift to virtual recruitment strategies for some jobs and organizations as a result of the pandemic? Disparities in wealth and access are fundamentally interwoven with technologies. It is necessary that we consider how workers are affected by this inequality to fully understand the effects of technologies.
2. Be more diverse in methods and target understudied populations
Based on data from the U.S. Census Bureau (2021), in 2016 organizations with fewer than 100 workers employed 33.4% of the employees in the private sector, and organizations with under 20 workers employed 16.8% of these employees. Focusing greater attention onto new technologies, which may be more likely to be adopted in larger and wealthier organizations, runs the risk that our samples will be even less representative. In addition to increased timeliness, we should also endeavor to study the effect of technology on the populations of workers and organizations that have already been left out.
Organizational size, resources, and industry could be important moderators of workers’ acceptance of and experiences using technologies. For instance, electronic performance monitoring may be generally accepted and even viewed positively by staff when monitoring use is transparent and employees feel control over the monitoring process (Ravid etal., Reference Ravid, Tomczk, White and Behrend2020). Yet, privacy concerns could potentially be more salient if this technology is introduced within a small organization and employees are aware that the business owner with whom they may interact every day and who is directly responsible for hiring and firing decisions is aware of their behaviors that were previously private.
One thoughtful suggestion that White etal. (Reference White, Ravid, Siderits and Behrend2022) provide is to research new technologies when they are first adopted to understand their initial, unique effects, an approach that they liken to an A–B intervention research design. We are of like mind about the value of understanding the process of adapting to a new technology within an organization. However, it is likely to be especially challenging to gain access to collect data on very new technologies, particularly within larger organizations that are likely to be the early adopters. Apotentially more feasible option is to study the introduction of older and more established technologies, but within the context of the numerous smaller and less wealthy organizations, including those located in industrializing nations, that are just now adopting them. This approach may be useful to develop generalizable knowledge about the processes of adopting and adjusting to a new technology within a firm. Moreover, studying multiple cultures and drawing from long-standing frameworks may also be useful for building theory about the meaningful features of technologies (rather than the effects of isolated different technologies), not to mention better serve underrepresented populations.
Another potential avenue for studying emerging technologies is to use vignette studies that expose research participants to compelling descriptions of new technologies. This approach has been applied in the emerging literature on artificial intelligence decision making in human resource management (Fisher & Howardson, Reference Fisher, Howardson and Strohmeier2022), and although it is not without limitations, it has allowed researchers to work with broader populations.
As discussed, ownership of very new technologies falls along a socioeconomic divide. The literature on technology use in the workplace often tends to center on knowledge workers (e.g., Attaran etal., Reference Attaran, Attaran and Kirkland2019). However, blue-collar workers should also receive research attention, in order to understand whether and how the effects of technology differ for workers with a wider range of educational attainment and work design characteristics, as well as how to support workers who are more vulnerable. For example, might some blue-collar workers have more negative reactions to the introduction of automation, not only out of concerns about being displaced but also because if technology replaces their tasks, this undercuts the rugged, masculine identities of these professions (e.g., Balkmar & Mellström, Reference Balkmar and Mellström2018)?
There are meaningful opportunities for research to broaden understanding of the effects of technology on work by targeting understudied populations including smaller organizations, blue-collar workers, and those on the other side of the digital divide.
3. Collaborate with I-O psychologists in different focal areas to study a wider range of outcomes
In one of their recommendations, White etal. (Reference White, Ravid, Siderits and Behrend2022) also call for increased interdisciplinary collaborations to study new technologies, a sentiment with which we very much agree. However, we also see opportunities closer afield. We encourage scholars studying technology to collaborate not only with researchers in other disciplines but also with industrial-organizational (I-O) psychologists who are experts in other established topics. Increasing intradisciplinary collaboration even further can be valuable to developing knowledge of the effects of technologies on a wider array of work outcomes (rather than concentrating on technology acceptance).
This suggestion may also be easier to implement and is worthwhile for the goal of expanding the nomological network for the use of new and established technologies. Aresearcher on organizational justice may have plenty of insights to contribute regarding how to study the consequences of technology inequality, for example. It would similarly be valuable to investigate how the technology used within an organization may contribute to its reputation and other job seeker perceptions, especially as subgroup differences in attraction may relate to increased likelihood of adverse impact later (Jones etal., Reference Jones, Newman, Su and Rounds2022). Alternately, given pervasive stereotypes (Ng & Feldman, Reference Ng and Feldman2012), do older workers feel deterred from applying to organizations that are seen as technologically advanced?
In summary, as a complement to White etal.’s (Reference White, Ravid, Siderits and Behrend2022) call for more research on novel technologies at work, we urge scholars to consider inequality in access to technology, target understudied and underserved populations, and collaborate with other experts to expand knowledge of the work outcomes associated with technology use. Studying technologies before they are available to a representative group of organizations and workers creates the risk of drawing ungeneralizable conclusions, and I-O psychologists must be careful to address this.
