During the recent American Civil War Sesquicentennial there was an effort to expand the story of America's bloodiest war beyond its geographical boundaries. Works by this reviewer and Simon Lewis (eds., The Civil War as a Global Conflict (2013)) and Don Doyle (The Cause of All Nations (2015)) have helped expand the idea that the Civil War had profound effects on the rest of the world, and especially Europe, beyond the field of 1860 international diplomacy. Nimrod Tal's effort is an admirable addition to this expansion. Focussing on Britain, and on five particular case studies, he sets out to find out “why twentieth-century Britons were fascinated with the American Civil War” (3).
Tal begins by highlighting the nineteenth-century roots of this twentieth-century fascination. The sheer size of the conflict in terms of the numbers of Americans involved, as well as the war's implications for international trade and the world economy, meant that contemporary Britons kept a close eye on it. In its aftermath they were so familiar with its origins, prosecution and effects that they looked to it to understand their own domestic issues. The most pressing issue in the war's immediate aftermath for Britain was Ireland. The late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries saw the dominance of the Home Rule movement in Irish politics and some of its critics were apt to compare it to southern secession. As Home Rule gave way to violent Irish republicanism after 1916, the analogy seemed even clearer with Lloyd George, for example, comparing Éamon De Valera to Jefferson Davis, in an attempt to dampen any American enthusiasm for Irish independence. He implied, of course, that he himself was the twentieth-century equivalent of Abraham Lincoln. This British appeal to the American Civil War experience seems, Tal believes, to have played some role in discouraging American recognition of the Irish Republic.
Interest in Abraham Lincoln went beyond the Irish issue. Political thinkers of all stripes saw value in studying, and on occasion claiming the legacy of, the “Great Emancipator.” The more conservative view of Lincoln as a national consolidator took hold over a minority view of Lincoln the radical, the latter particularly connected to his support from some of the Lancashire cotton districts. As in America, however, Tal clearly shows that works on Lincoln and the Civil War reflected the time in which they were written. Denis Brogan's biography, written in 1935, for example, tried to highlight Lincoln as a leader who tried to avert war at all cost; in others words, an appeaser.
Beyond politics, the other early main area of British interest in the American Civil War was military thought. As such a large modern war, British strategists sought to learn its lessons. The sheer scale of it, carried out in a country with a political system somewhat similar to the UK's parliamentary democracy, meant that the Civil War remained interesting as a case study for many in Britain. Thus while many of the lessons of the battlefield – for example the growing ineffectuality of frontal assaults – were ignored, how major wars brought about important social and economic changes was absorbed through to the end of the First World War.
More deeply, however, it was the cultural influence of the war that retained the strongest hold on British minds. From the release of D. W. Griffith's The Birth of a Nation in 1915, the British public were fascinated by movies about the war. Gone with the Wind, released in 1939, was particularly popular and infused many Britons with the ideas of the Lost Cause. This mid-twentieth-century period also saw a rise in more specialist interest in the conflict with the growth of what became the American Civil War Roundtable of the UK. Still in existence, its roots lay in a group called the Confederate Research Club, founded in Portsmouth in 1953. The Confederate High Command appeared in the early 1960s, which incorporated dressing up in Confederate uniforms at meetings – reenacting, if you will. The American civil rights movement, and its prominence in the British press, challenged this fascination with the Confederacy and thus the Confederate Research Club became the Civil War Roundtable. The High Command lasted until the 1990s but it had long been surpassed by the American Civil War Society, founded in 1975, to provide a more balanced view of the conflict in reenacting. Through a series of interviews with contemporary Civil War enthusiasts, Tal highlights how these “buffs” strongly believe that their fascination is purely historical, and unlike many in the United States (see Tony Horwitz's Confederates in the Attic (1998)), not political. Yet commemorating this conflict cannot escape politics. Tal covers in particular the controversy which halted the re-creation of the Confederate raider the CSS Alabama in Birkenhead (where it had been constructed in 1862) as a tourist attraction in the late 1980s. It seems that, on occasion, the memory of the Civil War can be as contested outside the United States as inside it. Tal is therefore to be commended for making us have to examine far more seriously the impact of America's bloodiest war beyond its borders and its resonance far beyond the 1860s.
