In this book, Laurens Tacoma sets out to study the political culture of the Roman senate and of Italian city councils from the first to the sixth centuries c.e. The method is kaleidoscopic. Each of the seven chapters offers a close reading of an ancient text and is concerned with different problems in the history of deliberative bodies on the Apennine Peninsula.
Ch. 1 (25–60) examines the problems posed by the maintenance of a culture of open debate under conditions of monarchy through the lens of the mock debate on deification of Claudius in Seneca's Apocolocyntosis. Ch. 2 (61–95) carefully analyses the meaning of graffiti written in support of candidates for high office in Pompeii and makes a good case that the broader population played a more important role in electoral competition than has often been acknowledged. Ch. 3 (97–124) on the re-introduction of secret ballots in elections for senatorial magistracies (as discussed in Plin., Ep. 4.25) and ch. 4 (125–58) on the meaning of the acclamations after Commodus’ assassination (reported in SHA, Pert. 4.8–5.1) highlight the difficulties faced by senators in preserving ritual decorum in moments of extreme tension. A close reading of Constantine's letter to Hispellum in Umbria neatly situates this famous inscription in the context of local power politics (159–93). Ch. 6 (195–228) illuminates the continued relevance in the Ostrogothic Kingdom of traditional Roman mechanisms of consensus; it confronts the two letters in which Theoderic praises his high official Decius for a drainage project on the Via Appia (Cass., Var. 2.32–33) with a contemporary building inscription (CIL X 6850) in which Decius returns credit for this achievement to the king. A final chapter (229–64) on the Ravenna papyri explores the role played by local city councils in authenticating transfers of property in the fifth and sixth centuries c.e.
T. writes clearly and wittily. He is also an exemplarily careful reader of ancient sources; as a result, most chapters will offer something new to specialists of the texts he discusses. A particular strength of this book is that it pays close attention to the ways in which his sources engage with earlier texts. T.'s exploration (44–51) of the ways in which Seneca's Apocolocyntosis creatively engages with the self-presentation of Claudius in the Lyon Tablet is perceptive. Similarly, his demonstration (105–12) that Pliny's criticism of senatorial elections reworks Cicero's denunciation of the evils of the secret ballot in De Leg. 3.16.35 adds a new dimension to our understanding of Ep. 4.25.
In the introduction (1–23) and conclusion (265–88), T. seeks to weave his close readings of individual texts into a broader theory of the nature of council politics in early imperial and late antique Italy. He isolates different characteristics (21–3, 266–70) that in his view made political culture in these institutions distinctive, such as a tension between free debate and the pressure to follow the dominant discourse; a contradiction between the strength of patronage ties and an ability of subordinate groups to evade them; a recognition of the limits of élite power and the necessity to maintain decorum in the face of these limits. But none of these features are distinctive for the Roman senate and Italian city councils. They were (and are) equally present in other deliberative bodies.
Nevertheless, this is a useful book. It offers excellent close readings of key texts on the history of the senate and city councils in Italy. It integrates a host of usually neglected sources into debates on Roman political culture. Above all, it reveals the deep continuity in institutional culture among Italian deliberative bodies over more than half a millennium.
