This volume functions well as an introduction to the life of Arthur Tansley (1871–1955) and to the emergence of ecology as a science, a career and an institution. Tansley was a key figure in the development of ecology in Britain over many decades. Ayres skilfully weaves the various strategies Tansley used to influence its development into his biographical narrative. In no particular order of importance, these strategies were, first, from early in his career, Tansley's championing of ecology's development conceptually, insisting in particular on it being defined as a study of dynamic systems (with the concomitant necessity of field studies), and, later, in the 1930s, his arguing against idealistic holistic conceptions of ecosystems with his own materialistic version. Second, there was his founding and editorial control of two key journals in the subject for several decades (New Phytologist from 1902 and Journal of Ecology from 1913), through which he encouraged others to use his methodology (although he did not unduly censure others for disagreeing with him; he had a reputation for fairness). Third, especially as head of the Department of Botany at Oxford (1927–1937), he was able to promote his concepts and methodology of ecology to students (i.e. a younger generation that he encouraged to work in ecology). Fourth, after a few years struggling to obtain money for this department, he finally acquired extra space and funding to increase the research space available. Fifth, whilst he did not have a prolific output in research papers, those he did publish were often deliberately (and successfully) intended as exemplars for his methodology (as were his books). Sixth, later in his life, and at a time when he was sitting on committees deciding on the approach and structure of post-war conservation and natural reserves, is what Ayres calls Tansley's use of ‘cronyism’ (p. 168).
Typically of a good biography, Shaping Ecology has useful sections threaded into the story that both give valuable context as regards relevant factors affecting Tansley's and ecology's development and breathe life into the story. Examples include the significance for Tansley personally of the origins and development of UCL, it still being considered a radical and young institution when, as a young man, he spent five terms there taking intermediate science lectures (1889–1890). After a chapter detailing what reads as the remarkable rise of both Tansley and the newly emerging science of ecology (1902–1913), there is a chapter contextualizing why Tansley still felt so insecure in his chosen career path at the end of this period. From the early 1910s through to 1927 he seriously considered moving into psychology, a subject in which he was increasingly gaining a good reputation amongst professionals (including Freud), and he had a successful popular book on psychology published, The New Psychology and Its Relation to Life (1920). (Perhaps there is a slight weakness in the book's exposition here. Although this chapter documents Tansley's involvement in psychology well, it does not give much detail on his ecology during the same period. Perhaps because of his doubts at this time he was not involved much in ecology, but neither is this suggested, nor is any other reason given for the lack of detail here.)
There is a good introductory chapter on the intellectual origins of ecology as a science that were important in Tansley's personal development, in particular the rise of plant geography in the 1800s through the work of Alexander von Humboldt and Alphonse de Candolle, and the ‘New Botany’ from the 1850s onwards of Andreas Schimper, Eugenius Warming and others, that accepted the challenge presented by Darwin's and Haeckel's theories explaining the organism's fitness to survive and reproduce in its environment. In a later chapter, ‘The years of fulfilment, 1937–1953’, Ayres concentrates almost exclusively on Tansley's involvement on committees (both governmental and of other organizations) that helped define the direction of post-war conservation and the new nature reserves. Reading this as an isolated chapter, it would be difficult to appreciate why and how Tansley's involvement could be so significant. This is not a problem when read in conjunction with the rest of the book. As I hope I have shown, Ayres successfully embeds Tansley's life and work within the historical development of ecology as a discipline. Earlier chapters show Tansley's impact on this developing discipline from scientific, philosophical and institutional perspectives. (Even so, if the reader simply wants a summary of the details of these committees and how the policies for conservation and nature reserves developed then this chapter can usefully stand alone.)
In conclusion, this book is well written and it is easy to locate specific information on Tansley and the broader contexts of his work throughout the book. I have tried to give a taste of how multilayered this relatively slim volume is. As such it can be put to many uses (by students, professionals and the lay public). Parts of the whole book are useful as an introduction to Tansley himself, as an introduction to the founding of ecology and the movement for conservation/natural reserves, as summaries of historical context for institutions and broader socio-economic conditions affecting the development of a science, and for interactions between philosophy and biology and how these can impact on methodology (especially in the idealism-versus-materialism debates of the 1930s).
