City on a Hilltop isolates the phenomenon of disproportionate American participation in the Israeli settler movement, providing a perspective on Israeli settlement that crosscuts many of its internal factions and debates. According to author Sara Yael Hirschhorn, Americans comprise some 15 percent of settlers in the West Bank (notably excluding East Jerusalem). The premise of her book is that they brought with them a uniquely American liberal ideology, informed by a history of struggle for civil rights along with a high bar of suburban comfort and luxury. But the importance of City on a Hilltop may be found less in the argument about American liberalism than in the broader picture Hirschhorn paints of the post-1967 settler movement, one that found its legs in the seemingly unlikely combination of divine promise and suburban real estate. The text's detailed oral histories, focused heavily on the settlers’ ideological formation, challenge monolithic understandings of the movement as settlers ruminate upon and often reject various strands of settlement ideology and their place within it.
The core of City on a Hill focuses on what might be understood as some of the more “moderate,” suburban Israeli settlements. Rather than plot a linear historiography, Hirschhorn dedicates a chapter each to Yamit, Efrat, and Tekoa, whose histories are largely told in the voices of the settlements’ founders and earliest residents. Although the chapters are organized roughly chronologically, the histories of these settlements overlap, echoing one another even as they diverge according to their leaders’ commitments to varying levels of religious practice, bourgeois sensibilities, and cooperation with (or dependence on) the state. But these liberal, professedly nonviolent settlers are haunted at every turn by the violence of their more famous counterparts—in the press, in their own self-reckoning, as well as in the book itself. Hirschhorn may have set out to write a history of nonviolent American liberalism in the Israeli settlements, but these three chapters are bookended by accounts of horrific violence: Baruch Goldstein's 1994 massacre of twenty-nine Palestinians praying at the Ibrahimi Mosque in Hebron, the 2007 bombing near the Beit Jamal monastery, the 2015 arson attack in Duma, killing a toddler and his parents, among others. These, too, were the actions of settlers coming from the United States, but they don't receive a thorough treatment in City on a Hilltop.
Hirschhorn situates these attacks within “a prolonged internal ideological dialogue over liberal values and tactics in Israel/Palestine” (p. 184). This is what she sets up as the book's central problematic: the tension between “liberal [American] values and settler realities” (p. 130). Returning to this clash, chapter after chapter, City on a Hilltop is nothing if not faithful to the settlers’ self-accounting of their struggles to reconcile their values with their lived experiences. It's both the strength and the downfall of the book. Hirschhorn's ability to inhabit the complicated world of the settlers allows the reader, too, to step in, and yet she seems to take the settlers’ words at face value, not least a commonplace notion of liberalism as somehow at odds with the settler colonial project.
Thus, while City on a Hilltop is filled with rich, compelling data that will no doubt be of use to scholars of Israel/Palestine and of settler colonialism more broadly, the analysis of this data falters when it comes to even the most widely accepted premises across both history and Middle East studies. The reader may join Hirschhorn in being surprised that so many of her informants claim to have marched alongside Martin Luther King, Jr., or at least in the 1960s civil rights movement in the United States. But the association of liberalism with settler colonialism has long been established. In fact, the kind of language used by these American settlers to describe their mission in moving to the Occupied Territories will be familiar to scholars of colonialism on any continent: “agents of ‘progress,’ ‘development,’ ‘rationality,’ and ‘change.’ . . .a bulwark against the encroaching ‘Levantization’ of Israeli civilization [bearing a] ‘white man's burden’” (p. 19). And yet, this is offered as evidence of the uniquely American outlook brought by these settlers. What Hirschhorn's account has in common with the American narrative is, perhaps, her own insistence on privileging a more recent history of civil rights struggles over a longer history of settler colonial expansion.
This brand of American exceptionalism not only removes Israel's post-1967 settlements from a larger conversation on settler colonialism, but serves to naturalize the difference between these “American-Israelis” and what Hirschhorn calls “native Israelis,” an odd characterization for a country so young and so full of immigrants, particularly in the earlier years covered by the book. What it means to be a “native Israeli” is never explained and is, seemingly, beyond the scope of City on a Hilltop. This is perhaps related to the book's classification of these American settlers as a type of “ethnic return migration” (p. 18), an argument that will no doubt irk advocates of the Palestinian right of return.
This may be no surprise given Hirschhorn's openness about her commitment to Zionism (p. 12). More surprising, however, is that in the same breath, she declares the book “objective,” a claim that lost its cachet decades ago, particularly within the field of Middle East studies. This is not to call into question the data that is the backbone of this book. The research is not skewed, but framed. Hirschhorn's disclosure of Zionism turns out to be superfluous; the politics of the text are clear according to what falls into and out of this frame. For a book covering such a broad swath of settlements, City on a Hilltop neatly avoids the issue of Jerusalem, which doesn't even merit an entry in the index. Those familiar with the statistics of settlement will recognize that the book's settlement numbers exclude East Jerusalem, and passing references to Gilo fail to mention that this, too, is a settlement, and not simply a Jerusalem neighborhood. Hirschhorn frets about the corrosive effect of settlements on the liberal Zionist project (less so about their effects on Palestinians), while eschewing any consideration of connections between the pre-1967 and post-1967 settlement of historic Palestine. The problem is not with the book's Zionism, per se, but with the presumption that Zionism can itself be without politics, and that it is even possible to undertake an “objective” study of the phenomenon of settlement.
Nonetheless, City on a Hilltop is a valuable entry into a growing body of scholarship on settlers’ turn to normalization over the last thirty-five years. The chapters on Efrat and Tekoa are particularly strong illustrations of the way that settlers and developers intertwined the commercial with the transcendental, and how these in turn were mediated by the changing concerns of the Israeli state. In contrast with previous studies focusing on Gush Emunim or the hilltop youth alone, City on a Hilltop looks behind the spectacular violence to the more mundane struggles of “liberal” settlers, resulting in a complicated and ultimately more interesting picture of the growing Israeli settler project.
