This book follows a series of lectures delivered by Michael Putnam in 2009 at the University of Amsterdam. The six lectures, which explored the ending of the Aeneid, were billed as ‘recapitulating a life-time of outstanding scholarship’. The subsequent publication offers another recapitulation of P.'s scholarly life to date: the main chapters showcase some of P.'s most significant contributions to our understanding of the Aeneid, while the preface and afterword illustrate the esteem in which P. is deservedly held by members of his field. The book focuses on the ‘humanness’ of Aeneas as the hero's anger swells in the final books of the Aeneid, a portrayal of emotional realism that, according to P., fits the traditional codes of Homeric heroic epic behaviour rather better than the morals of clementia championed elsewhere in the Aeneid. P.'s reading of the Aeneid maps the epic as a journey from neat abstraction to messy human experience, from an objective to a subjective perspective; P. construes this as a gradual enriching and complicating of the epic's central themes of divine and mortal vengeance, erotic ties, cities (founding, falling, or embroiled in civil discord), and imperial ambition.
The thematic focus of this book thus clearly follows on from P.'s earlier work, and it is also methodologically familiar terrain. The tactics of New Criticism dominate the book, which begins by appealing to readers' appreciation of ‘man's essentially unchanging character’. P. writes of a poet who is ‘telling the truth … realistic … honest …’, an approach that will convince some more than others. Thenceforth, P. relies for the most part on his intimate knowledge of the poem, teasing as much as possible out of the poem's formal features: he exposes structures, frames, allusions, ekphraseis, symbolic representations, moments when heroes play each others' rôles (both within the epic and in dialogue with other texts, chiefly the Iliad), with some particularly excellent readings in the epic's negotiation of the gap between the figurative and the literal through its similes, allegories and personifications.
The result is that for admirers of P.'s work there is much to enjoy, but not without an occasional feeling of déjà vu. P. is such a well-known figure in Virgilian scholarship that his observations tend to have slipped deep into Latinists' collective unconscious. While many will benefit from a reminder of P.'s distinctive lines of argument, the material often runs close to earlier work by the same author in which issues are cashed out more fully: P. is picking a thread through his own previous literature, distilling and simplifying as he goes. The book is not unaware of this phenomenon; indeed it is well articulated by David Rijser in his lucid afterword. Rijser points out that ‘both his methods and his conclusions have become a fundamental part of the Virgilian tradition itself … he develops and epitomizes here themes with which his readers are to a certain extent familiar’. In the spirit of self-reflexive scholarly positioning Rijser notes that the conjectural tone of P.'s text is an echo of the Aeneid's ambivalent ending, even as Rijser himself re-enacts the deferred closure of Aeneid 12 in his résumé of P.'s scholarship at the book's end.
There is an exciting change of gear in the book's tantalisingly brief epilogue. Here P. discusses alternative literary representations of merciful and merciless treatments of an enemy, using Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin and Twain's Adventures of Huckleberry Finn to offer insights into Aeneas' slaughter of Turnus in the Aeneid. Both illustrate heroes or antiheroes wavering in their actions, torn between individual moral reasoning and external social or religious pressures. P.'s readings produce some fascinating thoughts on ‘possession’ as a notion that encompasses emotional incontinence as well as the tragic reality of one man's power over another in conditions of war or slavery. Though merely suggestive and offering many more avenues for exploration, P.'s search for psychological cogency in these texts to reflect on the emotions of the Aeneid offers a compelling and refreshing counterpoint to the formalist approach of the earlier chapters.
The question remains: at whom is this book aimed? It is a limpid expression of P.'s thoughts on the end of the Aeneid, unburdened by polemics or exhaustive footnoting, and helpfully equipped with translations of all the Latin (and with no Greek quoted in the original). As such it would be ideal for students: accessible, thought-provoking, and less challenging than the earlier work in which some of these thoughts were first hammered out. Meanwhile it invites the rest of us to take a breezy, conversational walk in the company of a distinguished scholar as steeped in the text of Virgil as anyone working today.
