The issue of the purchase of land in one country, in this case Iran, by other countries, in this case Britain and Russia, is one of great significance because of light it may throw on the strength or weakness of national sovereignty, and the ways and degree to which it may be undermined.Footnote 1 It can also show the strategies deployed by the country challenged to protect its territorial integrity, as here in the case of Iran. The intricacies of foreign landownership patterns thus have implications for international relations, on which they can provide telling detail in terms of contemporary power politics. The details of land purchase also demonstrate considerable differences as between the two outside powers involved in terms of their objectives in Iran, and thus challenge a tendency in the literature to see them as similar.
At the same time, from this particular study, Qajar Iran, which is so often represented as weak, naïve and ineffectual in the face of the challenge of great power intervention, emerges as having dealt skilfully with this particular form of intrusion with a variety of stratagems that were not without success for much of the nineteenth century. Finally, the whole issue can be demonstrated as having become inextricably entwined with internal policies of reform which sought to strengthen the government of Iran by centralisation and growing taxation on those who were hitherto exempt. This movement, however, which occurs late in the period, that is to say in the early twentieth century, was to stall during its very weak second decade.
Despite the significance of the subject of foreign land ownership and tenancies in Iran in the Qajar period, no detailed study of it exists. Issawi notes that there was a considerable amount of land purchase in Astarabad, Gilan and Azerbaijan by Russian subjects, who became settled there during the second half of the nineteenth century.Footnote 2 In 1864 Eastwick observed that Gilan was the residence of a large number of Russian protégées.Footnote 3 They were especially dominant in Rasht, where they held entire villages by right of mortgage. However, as will be shown, the picture was more complex than it appeared, it varied from region to region, and in particular there was a contrast between the north and the British-dominated south. The nature of the claims of foreigners on land also evolved over time, much depending on the impact of the central government and of foreign trade. Within this framework the present study sets out to examine broadly the ways in which land was acquired between the signing of the Treaty of Turkmanchai in 1828 and the breakdown of Iranian government central control by 1911. It will consider not only claims and ownership themselves, but also the ways in which land was acquired and by what rights, including the legal arguments deployed for and against foreign ownership and leaseholds. It is hoped that the article will thereby trace changes in Iran both in terms of foreign relationships and influence, and in internal development.
Iranian Government Policy on Land Transactions
The starting point of this discussion is the Treaty of Turkmanchai in 1828, and especially Article V which stated that: In awareness that following the existing customs in Persia, it is difficult for foreign subjects to rent houses, shops or appropriate places for storing their merchandise, it is permitted to Russian subjects in Persia not only to rent but to acquire by every right of ownership houses to live in, shops and storage space.Footnote 4 These rights were extended to British subjects by the Anglo-Russian Commercial Treaty of 1841, and later to other foreign subjects.
Three points should be noted about this article. Firstly, it refers to buildings, but not to land.Footnote 5 This was to be a major source of confusion in the interpretation of the Article in the decades to follow. It posed the difficult problem of how it was possible to own a building without owning the land on which it stood, a conundrum that was to find some ingenious solutions by the end of the nineteenth century. Secondly, though the Article is not very precise in wording, it implies that the ownership in question should be for individual use; in other words the amount of property which foreigners could ‘own’ was supposedly limited. However, the wording of the article was to be subject to a range of varied interpretations, and to be debated throughout the period in question. Thirdly, it would seem that the Treaty thus introduced foreign property ownership into Iran, but this was not the case for such ownership, without limitations, already existed. In particular, grants of land had been made by Fath ‘Ali Shah to both Indians, who either were or afterwards became British subjects,Footnote 6 and to Russians of similar status, an issue which will be explored further below. Therefore the Treaty actually limited foreign control of land.
In fact, foreign ownership of property does not seem to have been a subject of wide dispute in Iran until the last quarter of the nineteenth century, and the rapid growth of foreign trade. Until this later period there were actually very few foreigners in Iran. Arrangements over property seem to have been informal, and knowledge and understanding of the exact wording of Article V of the Treaty not in anyway widespread. This is demonstrated in the earliest example we have so far found of a dispute over land use in southern Iran, which dates from 1845. At that time Samuel Hennell, the British Resident in Bushehr, built a small house in the country to escape from the oppressive summer weather.Footnote 7 The Iranian government protested on the grounds that he had no permission, without indicating to what exactly the permission referred. This was a wild and under-inhabited part of the country, and no mention of an owner of the land is made by the parties involved. The Iranian government seem to have been concerned at what they perceived as his having constructed a dwelling (i.e. thereby potentially claiming the land) as opposed to hiring or leasing one. The outcome is not altogether clear, but the difference died down seemingly on the understanding that the British occupation of the building was for a temporary period, establishing the fact that they did not own the land.
The attitude of the Iranian Government towards land purchase by foreigners appears to have remained consistent, but evidently such purchases were being made for in 1868 the Government issued an instruction to several mujtahids in Bushehr warning them against sealing documents of the sale of land to foreigners.Footnote 8 As a result, local Iranians were afraid to sell because of the Government view. However, one problem was not that foreigners particularly desired land, but that the existing housing stock was not suitable for their needs, and they found themselves being forced to pay for repairs to the property they rented. The British protested to the Iranians that their ruling contravened the Treaty of Turkmanchai, using the interpretation advanced by the British Minister Alison, that “property might be purchased and suitable buildings erected”Footnote 9 according to Article V. The Iranian authorities expressed their view in no uncertain terms in a letter from the Governor of Bushehr dated Ramazan 1284/24 January 1868, which announced on orders from Tehran that “the law court authorities should not seal (or authorise) any deeds for the sale of land, property, permanent dwellings or plain grounds in town or country”.Footnote 10 This left the Resident with no option but to inform one British subject that it was not possible to purchase a house, despite Alison's interpretation of the Article V of the Treaty of Turkmanchai.
If, despite aggrandising pressure from the Government of India, British diplomats in Iran appear on the whole to have kept to the Iranian Government's interpretation of the Treaty of Turkmanchai, the same cannot be said of the Russians in the north. In 1873, the Russian Consul in Tabriz informed his British and French counterparts that not only did Russian subjects have the complete right to own property, but they could even own a whole village. Further their ownership of that village transformed it into Russian territory.Footnote 11 In addition, in one case then under discussion, the ownership of the property had not only been legalised by the Russian Consulate and the divankhana (principle court) at Tabriz in 1852, but had been ratified by a mujtahid in 1859. This evidence of the advance of Russian ownership in the north is born out by the fact Russian subjects owned considerable numbers of houses at Enzeli and Rasht, some of them substantial in terms of both building and land.Footnote 12 In addition, much more modest dwellings were owned by local Russian boatmen engaged in landing passengers and goods from the Caspian steamers. These dwellings were acquired by both purchase and marriage. However, although one such “Russian subject, was the munshi of the Russian consulate in Rasht, they were mainly Muslims originating mainly from the Caucasus, a point which will be discussed further below.
Between 1838 and 1885 there exist at least eighteen documents referring to the purchase of land by Russian subjects, including villages, farms, houses, shops and bath houses.Footnote 13 In 1886, however, by which time it has to be said, the horse had evidently bolted, the Russian Consul in Tabriz was offering a new view on the acquisition of property in Iran. He stated that it was true that “foreigners could acquire a house for their habitation and if need be a depot for their merchandise. But it was a very open question whether they could possess landed property”.Footnote 14 He added that, given the abiding opposition of the Russian government to foreign possession of land, he continually told Russian subjects that as a rule he could not support their claims with regard to landed property.
The British had in fact again raised the question of foreign rights to own land with the Iranian Government in 1882, drawing attention to what in their view was discriminatory treatment as between them and the Russians.Footnote 15 The response of the Iranian Ministry of Foreign Affairs maintained the line they had held hitherto, that foreigners had no right to own property in Iran. However, for the first time they gave their interpretation of the vital clause in Article V:
In part owing to carelessness which took place on the part of ill-informed subjects of both states, the purport of the fifth article of the Treaty of Turkmanchai, . . . . . . in which the rights of foreign subjects as regards to holding landed property in Persia are fully defined, has been overstepped thereby causing an infraction of the sovereign rights of this country.
They went on to demand that both states make sure their subjects keep within the defined rights and limits assigned to them, adding:
The Persian Government will by Treaty be fully entitled to treat any irregularity which may have been committed in this respect, without its special sanction, as contrary to Treaty rights.
In response to further British protests, which interpreted ‘special sanctions’ as applying to the Russians only, the Minister of Foreign Affairs wrote:Footnote 16
You appear to be under the impression that (ownership of land) is a privilege which the Persian Government consents to grant to certain foreigners, but denies to British subjects.
With reference also to my statement that any irregularity committed in this respect without the special sanction of the Persian Government will be regarded as null and void, in using the term “special sanction” I meant to refer only to the rights and limits defined by the Treaty; that is to the purchase of what is required for personal accommodation and for the storing of goods, notwithstanding the possibility of the renting of the same; and not to property in the nature of goods, estates, etc., the acquisition of which the Persian Government has never authorised. The prohibition against overstepping their defined rights and limits which I communicated in my letter of 29th January is applicable to all foreigners, not exclusively to British subjects.
In other words, the British and Russians considered that Article V allowed them to own property in terms of house, office, etc. and land, whereas the Iranian Government argued somewhat incongruously, but adamantly, that it applied only to buildings.Footnote 17
As the pressure of the international economy and the consequent presence of foreign firms in the country mounted from the 1880s onwards, so did the need to acquire suitable, viable and secure property for facilities, storage and dwellings. In this context in 1885 the karguzar of Shiraz reiterated the argument of the Iranian Government in 1882 in response to a query about the purchase of property,Footnote 18 as did the Ministry of Foreign Affairs itself in 1890.Footnote 19 In May 1888 Nasir al-Din Shah issued a special hukm forbidding the sale of land to foreigners by Iranians, specifically mentioning property and qanats.Footnote 20 Any land so sold would be confiscated by the government. However, it is clear from the regularity of these prohibitions that foreign subjects were acquiring properties.
It was perhaps in recognition of the scale of the problem and the difficulty of controlling it, that the Iranian government began to adopt new tactics. The Government order of 1890 mentions (somewhat illogically) that foreigners owning land had either to sell it or to pay the government taxes on it.Footnote 21 In other words the Iranian Government was beginning to see the advantages of actually encouraging foreigners to rent buildings, providing they paid taxes on them. However, the problem of who owned the land needed to be addressed.
This realisation produced, firstly, a new ruling in 1892 whereby all contracts regarding the hiring of buildings to foreigners had to be concluded with the cognisance of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs or the karguzar, and must be sealed by them.Footnote 22 The measure was thus not only representative of a desire to control foreign claims to land, it was also a step towards greater state central control.
Another new feature also entered the matter at this stage, and that concerned the period of the lease. Whereas previously there had been little or no mention of the how long leases could be, the karguzar began to question the validity of leases on the bases that they were too long. In an example from Mohammareh dated 1896, the karguzar accepted a lease, but stated that its length of fifteen years did not have the agreement of the Iranian Government.Footnote 23 When the British protested at what seemed to them a unilateral innovation, the karguzar simply retorted that a lease of five to seven years was acceptable, one of fifteen needed special permission from Tehran.Footnote 24
The process of growing state control over land purchase gradually advanced until by 1906 it was recognised that any transactions between foreigners and Iranians over land had to be registered with the karguzar.Footnote 25 In what represents not only an advance in Government control over property transactions with foreigners, but also of state law over religious law, documents of such a nature not stamped with a Government seal would be null and void, this measure being also retrogressive (i.e. existing acquisitions had to have the Government seal of approval to be considered valid).
The Law and Property Rights
Although some claims to land by custom and tradition seem to have had informal recognition, only the shari'a could confer legitimate ownership. It fully recognises the principle of private property, and procedures for enforcement of rights, where they were resisted, were well-developed, at least in theory.Footnote 26 Property rights for Iranians, and it thus follows also for foreigners, were therefore not absolute nor very secure, a problem reinforced by the inadequacy of the land registration system, the prevalence of forgery and the arbitrary nature of power. The coming of the international economy and the growth of cash crops put increasing wealth into the hands of Iranian merchants. The comparatively opulent lifestyle of the notables meant that they were frequently obliged to borrow, using land as collateral. Where they could not pay the interest on their mortgages, the land passed into the hands of the merchants.Footnote 27 Landownership thus changed, but not to a great extent, especially away from the towns. One of the questions addressed here is how far foreign as opposed to Iranian merchants were able to acquire actual ownership of land, as opposed to a claim to the assets it represented, through mortgage. Further, under the Treaty of Turkmanchai foreign merchants had the privilege of the support of their consuls and in having their cases tried with the consul present.Footnote 28 The question, however, is whether it made any difference when it came to ownership of land.
Property and Foreign Missions and Consulates
On the whole foreign missions in Iran, as elsewhere, owned the land they occupied and that used by their consulates, so they do constitute an exception to the Iranian rule on land ownership.Footnote 29 Over the years, as foreign government representations in Iran grew, the amount of property which they owned both for their dwellings and for their business undoubtedly expanded, usually, though not always, with the permission of the Iranian Government. However conflict could arise with the Iranians if additions were made to existing buildings. The British view was that extensions could be made if they were built on British land. The Iranian view was that they had to have Iranian Government permission anyway. Occasionally, when thwarted, the British simply by-passed the local authorities. In 1883 the British Residency in Bushehr obtained a dwelling for the Assistant Resident, in reality through a sale, though it was termed in the transaction document as “a transfer for the time being”, and the Resident asked if it could be ratified by the Minister for Foreign Affairs in Tehran.Footnote 30 In a case from 1896 the karguzar of Bushehr wrote repeatedly to Tehran about extensions to the Birtish Residency (on British land) which he considered were going ahead without permission, but apparently he did not receive any response.Footnote 31 Elsewhere land was bought by consulates without any evident problem, for example in the case of the British in Kermanshah in 1904,Footnote 32 and the Russians in Shiraz in 1906.Footnote 33 Both British and Russians, competing for prestigious premises, expanded their holdings by purchase in Bushehr in 1905.Footnote 34
Sometimes, however, the foreign government consular land was rented, an example being that of the consulate in Rasht.Footnote 35 In 1876 the British consul felt that more land was needed to build accommodation for travellers, and identified suitable land for sale with an owner willing to sell.Footnote 36 He then proposed that the Iranian Government buy the land and refurbish the house to the required state. The British Consulate would then reimburse them for the repairs through rent. Likewise, the Consulate in Mohammareh was leased with the agreement of the Governor, Shaikh Mizal, and according to articles drawn up by the karguzar.Footnote 37 In these latter cases where renting was preferred, the decision to use it seems to have depended partly on local conditions and partly on comparative cost.Footnote 38
By 1903, following the line of innovation towards foreigners and property mentioned above, the Iranian government demanded land tax on a plot of land purchased by the Government of India for a new British Persian Gulf residency house in Shiraz.Footnote 39 This view was roundly resisted by the British, though it was part of a growing trend whereby the Iranians sought to make money by extending taxes to those previously exempt, especially as the price of land was going up rapidly in some urban areas like Shiraz.Footnote 40
The picture for diplomatic land is thus mixed, with a growth in land owned outright, some land leased, and the emergence of encroaching taxes, which however, were not to come into real force until after the First World War.
The Long-Standing Rights of British Indians and Russian Subjects
As already indicated, the issue of foreigners owning land did not begin with the British and Russian penetration of Iran in the nineteenth century. As a result of long established trading patterns in the Caspian Sea and along the southern shores of Iran, groups of foreigners (meaning persons not subject to the Shah of Iran) were well established long before the Great Power era. To some extent, therefore, the foreign property owners referred to in the sources did not arrive as British, Russian or other subjects, but were resident as a result of inheritance and trade, and not necessarily of foreign aggrandisement. It was recognised that persons who possessed property in Iran before the Treaty of Turkmanchai in 1828 were both entitled to their property and recognised by both Iranian and British Governments as bone fide British subjects entitled to such property.Footnote 41 It is important to note that the expression ‘Russian subjects’ or ‘British subjects’ conveys the impression that these were Europeans. In fact most were Muslims from the region. Thus in the British examples they came from families originating in India. In the example mentioned above of large numbers of ‘Russian subjects’ owning land in the north, they were Muslims mainly from the Caucasus, whose ancestors would have long-formed part of the trade networks in the region. No distinction as to religion in the matter was ever made by the Iranian Government, nor did the foreign governments ever raise it. This suggests that it was not the produce of government policy but of social practice and long-standing custom, predating the appearance of European powers. It would be interesting to know the fate of the ‘foreign subjects’ who owned land in Iran after the First World War; whether, for example, they returned to the Caucasus, whether they went to Russia, or whether they simply continued in possession of their property, but were transformed into Iranians.
British Indians and Inherited Land Rights
Cases involving disputes over property claims of British Indians are not numerous. There is a sense that their status was apparently recognised and tacitly accepted by the Iranian Government and most Iranians, that is as long as they did not expand. Thus in 1874 a British Indian subject owning land in Bandar Abbas and wanting to build on it, had his project blocked by the Iranian Government.Footnote 42 Two cases from the early twentieth century illustrate the complexities of the position of such persons. One, dating from 1900, concerned the confiscation and sale by the Governor of Bushehr of a piece of land in Lingah belonging to a British Indian subject. This particular individual had inherited land attached to a coffee house and go-downs bought by his grandfather at the time when Lingah was under the rule of an Arab Shaikh,Footnote 43 (though albeit claimed by Iran). He did not have all the title deeds, but submitted an istishadnama (a testament) signed by nine merchants and notables. His claim was also considered valid by the British Residency. Representations to the Governor of Bushehr only produced the reply that foreigners were not allowed to own land in Persian (ignoring the understanding on inheritance). The second case, dating from 1904, concerned a British Indian subject, Nur al-Din, whose forebear had been given exemption from taxes in the time of Fath ‘Ali Shah on land he had purchased.Footnote 44 There was a proviso that should the land become alienated from the family, the maliyat tax would be due. Nur al-Din had leased the land on the understanding that the lessee would pay this maliyat. Unfortunately, the latter failed to do so, and despite representations from the British, Nur al-Din found himself liable.
Finally, it should be noted that from the early twentieth century British Indian subjects, like British diplomatic representations, were becoming increasingly subject to property taxes from which they had in the past been exempt.Footnote 45 By 1914 the Iranian Government's sporadic but still persistent attempts at financial reform led to British Indian foreign subjects in Seistan being judged liable to amounts of between ten and eighty tomans depending on the size of their shops, which were deemed to be on crown land (khalasa). However, they rejected liability for the payment on the grounds that they had bought the land outright and a battle with the Iranian Government ensued.Footnote 46
Missionaries and the Renting of Property
The position of missionaries was to some extent anomalous as compared to that of diplomats and entrepreneurs, therefore it is worth considering it briefly and separately. The evidence on their acquisition of property suggests that the Iranian Government treated them in accordance with the broad policy already indicated. For example, the American missionaries in Tabriz in 1882 were stopped from building two houses and a school until permission had come from Tehran.Footnote 47 The missionaries did not own the land outright, having purchased it, in accordance with a common means of circumventing the problems of Article V, in the name of an Iranian (in this case an Armenian). The central Government having been consulted, they were eventually allowed to build the houses, on the understanding that both land and houses belonged to an Iranian subject.Footnote 48 It is important to note that whatever the understanding or the custom, legally the property belonged to an Iranian. The rights of the foreign subjects were only secure as long as they had the support of the foreign representation, and they did not have security in law.
Further, support given to missionaries by diplomatic representations could be at best lukewarm. In 1893 in Isfahan, where foreigners, especially CMS (Church Missionary Society) missionaries, faced the opposition of powerful clergy, in particular the mujtahid Aqa Najafi, even attempts to acquire property in a manner that complied with all the rules, including renting from a local subject on a limited lease, met with considerable obstacles.Footnote 49 Preece, the British Consul, regarded the activities of CMS as detrimental to Anglo-Iranian relations, and did his best to discourage their initiative, which was to establish a dispensary in the centre of Isfahan, as opposed to confining themselves to Julfa. In this case victory went to the clergy and populace of Isfahan, and the dispensary, having briefly opened, was obliged to close.Footnote 50
The Acquisition of Property by Mortgage
It is true that much property was acquired in Iran at this time by default on debts to foreign firms and banks. The question that needs addressing, however, is whether these acquisitions had any legal recognition or security, as opposed to acknowledgement by custom. As already noted, no mujtahid in the south would ratify foreign ownership of land arrived at through debt and default. In addition, the British authorities did not support claims to ownership, they only supported the demand that the creditor's property be sold (to another Iranian) to enable him to pay his debts to a British subject. It has already been observed for the north that the Russian view varied over time. However, in 1886, the Russian Consul told his British counterpart that it was no doubt a fact the foreigners did possess property, despite the fact that it was a right continually contested by the Iranian Government.Footnote 51 He regularly informed Russian subjects that as a general rule he had to decline to support their claims with regard to landed property. He added that in many cases Russian subjects held landed property as security for debts. However, they were not the absolute owners, but they enjoyed the usufruct.
In 1905, the Resident in Bushehr returned a similar response to a query on the rights of foreigners to acquire property through foreclosure on a mortgage, or by attachment in satisfaction of a debt.Footnote 52 His response was that the Iranian Government did not recognise mortgage on landed property as legal when it concerned a foreign subject. Sometimes the local authorities permitted property to be acquired by such means through ignorance or negligence. However, in such cases, the Iranian Government insisted that the property be sold to an Iranian and the proceeds be paid to the lender. He further explained that the Imperial Bank of Persia was also precluded from accepting landed property as mortgage. With regard to the British, there was thus a consistency of view on the part of the Iranians on the issue over a long period.
However, the picture for the early years of the twentieth century is different for the Russian-dominated area in the north. According to Wilhelm Litten, who lived in Iran from 1902–1918, and was German Consul in Tabriz during the First World War, the Russian Discount Bank, founded in 1891 with strong support from the Russian Government, became an outright owner of large tracts of land. Until the First World War, there were four branches of this bank in Iran: Tehran, Rasht, Mashhad and Tabriz and four agencies in Qazvin, Hamadan, Isfahan and Sabzevar.Footnote 53 The bank gained control but not proven ownership of the land by granting large loans to Iranian subjects from a variety of social classes. By 1913 it had acquired 48 million roubles worth of land by this means.
Commercial Practice and Property
In the case of entrepreneurs of all kinds who were described as ‘owning’ property, it is not always clear what their rights were, as the word ‘own’ was used for leaseholds. Given the foregoing evidence it is possible that some property was held by informal, de facto ownership, and most was probably rented. Up till the latter part of century at least disputes in Bushehr concerning the rights to immovable property were dealt with by the chief mujtahid even when the plaintiff and defendant were bone fide British subjects.Footnote 54 This was no doubt because he had the expertise and knowledge of local conditions, as well as of the trading community to which the British subjects in a sense belonged.
It was, however, the opening up of the Karun River to trade from 1888-9 which led in the south to regular and ever more complicated disputes over property rights. It should, however, be noted that on the part of foreigners, the claim was never to ownership, but only to leasehold and rights of usage. Given the vast possibilities for profit from commercial enterprise which this initiative promised, negotiations over the renting of property became subject to rivalries for opportunities to rent and control of land as between the central government, the provincial governor and local powers. Much rented property was needed, and new style buildings had to be erected for such use as storage space, landing areas, offices, dwellings, and so forth.
The prime instigator of the Karun project was the firm of Lynch Brothers. Having secured the concession, they faced considerable problems in establishing the infrastructure for their project. Serious resistance came from a leading local power, Shaikh Mizal at Mohammareh, to the growth of trade on the Karun, arising from the justified fear that the central government would use it to expand their control.Footnote 55 The issue was complicated and compounded by the interest in the project of Husain Quli Khan Nizam al-Saltana, Governor of Khuzestan, who hoped to profit thereby. Lynch Bros also had to contend with the most influential merchant in southern Iran, Haji Aqa Muhammad Mu'in al-Tujjar, and with the Iranian central government itself, which had various plans to benefit from the project financially. Therefore the establishment of each warehouse, landing place or dwelling involved a complicated and protracted struggle. Finally complexity was further confounded by the stipulations of the Treaty of Turkmanchai regarding foreign ownership of land. Thus March 1991 finds Lynch Bros writing to Col Ross concerning the building of houses and stores at Ahwaz and Mohammareh:
The Nizam was to make us his agents for building houses and stores for ourselves at Ahwaz and Mahomerah. He was to advance us money and we were to build any description of house . . . as we pleased, and the rent was to be 10% per annum on the cost.Footnote 56
Unfortunately, this arrangement did not last, as Nizam al-Saltana came to a mutually beneficial arrangement with Shaikh Mizal:
After his interviewing Shaikh Mizal his ideas changed entirely. He said that the Shaikh was going to be his partner in building the houses and that as the Shaikh could build much cheaper than we could, he would give the building into his hands, that they would build entirely according to their own plans that we could take the places or not as we liked after they were finished. Then he began to talk about ground rent and his ideas on the subject were very high. This question of ground rent was not mooted before.
Finally, the firm's house and office was to be at some distance from its stores and wharf. However, most significantly it is to be noted that the firm was not permitted to buy the land.
Some years later, Lynch Bros came to a different arrangement with Nizam al-Saltana concerning a house and warehouse at Bander Nasiri in Ahwaz. With the permission of the Iranian Government he undertook to cause the necessary buildings to be erected according to plans provided by the firm, and would then let the premises to them at a rate of 15% per annum on the capital expended in constructing the buildings. The term of the lease, along with other detailed articles, was ten years, and renewable.Footnote 57 Thus once again the arrangement was kept within the stipulations of the Iranian government.
An example from the north demonstrates the contrast of the approach of the Iranian authorities to land ownership as compared with the south. A concession covering the years 1888–1900 for the development and benefit of fisheries along the Caspian shore was given to a Russian merchant from Astrakhan, Stephen Martynovich Lianazoff, and later to his son, Georgi. It also covered fisheries in all the rivers between Astara on the west and Atrak on the east of the Caspian. The concession was later renewed several times and with different conditions between 1900 and 1925.Footnote 58 On the basis of the concession, Lianazoff established an administrative system for fisheries at several places along the Caspian shore. With the acquiescence of the Iranian government, the company was allowed both to lease and purchase land. This implied right of purchase was then used by the company to expand into ownership of agricultural land which was irrelevant to the original purpose of the concession. As a result, numerous disputes arose, lasting right into the 1920s, as between the Ministry of Finance, the Treasurer General and Russian authorities in both Tehran and in Gilan.Footnote 59
Notables and Land Tax
The whole situation was complicated by a growing trend on the part of the Iranian Government to make money by extending taxes to those previously exempt, which in reality was a symptom of the ongoing process of centralisation in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. In the first decade of the twentieth century Iranian notable landholders came to an understanding with the Russian consulates in northern Iran that, in return for tax paid to Russia, they would be granted Russian protection, which they would then use to claim a reduction in land tax. This arrangement reached the point in 1909 where, a section having been established in the main Russian consulates for this purpose, the Russian Consulates General of Azarbaijan and Gilan asked these ‘protected’ persons to pay their regular taxes to the consulate, and warned them that if they did not do so, they would be subject to the legal action. Those who did not pay would be subject to the legal pursuit.Footnote 60
In 1909 the Ministry of the Interior reported to the Foreign Ministry that almost all of the landowners in Gilan were foreign subjects, particularly Russian. It was concerned over the problems that the situation created for tax collection as these land owners were denying their obligation to pay taxes on the grounds that they were foreign subjects. The big land owners of the region, such as Sardar Mansur, Amin al-Daula and Amjad al-Daula, were absent and living in Tehran. Much of the remaining arable land was cultivated by foreign subjects. Therefore this situation created ambiguous circumstances for the collection of tax revenues in the province.Footnote 61
The problem of the foreign landownership and land-taxes led to numerous lawsuits in the period after Shuster's reforms in 1911, when responsibility for the matter fell to Mr Mornard (Treasurer General of Iran). In 1913 the Ministry of Finance asked the Foreign Ministry for a list of foreigners and protected persons in the country. In Azerbaijan the tax collectors complained about the ambiguous situation of these people and the areas that were now actually under foreign land ownership. The Treasurer of Azerbaijan provided a list of big landowners and influential people such as Ali Quli Khan Qudrat al-Mulk, Allah Rahim Aqa Mir Panj, Ra'is al-Ulama, and Ali Quli Khan Samsam al-Mamalik who refused to pay their taxes on the grounds that they had the privilege of Russian Consulate protection. The Russian Consul General also provided a list of the people and the areas of land under their protection to the Financial Ministry, which included Savaj Bulagh, Qaraja Dagh, Ahar, Garm Rud, Urumieh and Kho'i, and asserted that those mentioned had Russian protection and that they paid their taxes to the Consulate. Therefore the tax collectors had no right to intervene in their affairs, an argument which, needless to say, was not accepted by the Iranian Government.Footnote 62
Outright purchases of land by the Russians from c. 1904
The picture of foreign land holdings in Iran did not appreciably change in the south in the last few years of the period in question. However, the north began to see significant changes in land ownership by Russian subjects, particularly as the weakening of central authority gathered pace.
Russian commercial organisations began to purchase land outright, despite the stipulations of the Treaty of Turkmanchai. For example, in 1900, in the Mashhad vicinity, a Russian company, Nobel Brothers (later, after the Russian Revolution, Sovietca-Iran co.) instigated a purchased of about 6,550 square yards of land to build an oil store. The Russian Consulate, the Karguzar of Khorasan and Sistan and the ‘ulama confirmed its documents in 1904. In 1903, the Russian Bank bought 10,000 square yards of land outside the city to construct a protected enclave for its staff. By 1909, with the escalating weakness of the central government, the Ministry of the Interior reported to the Foreign Ministry that, almost all of the lands and landowners in Gilan were foreign subjects particularly Russian, and were refusing to pay land tax.
In a further example, the Russian Bank in Mashhad, after some negotiation, successfully purchased 10,000 square yards of land outside the city in the Taqiabad district near to the Nughan gate, to build an enclave quarter for its director and staff.Footnote 63 The British reported that the “intention [was] to collect all their Russian subjects, as well as the Consulate and Bank; in fact to found there a regular Russian colony, with a hospital, church, school and park”.Footnote 64 The idea of establishing a quarter outside the walls had first occurred to the Russians a year before, when they had opened up a club, regardless of the religious character of Mashhad, to which they did not always pay proper respect. This had turned the people against themFootnote 65 to such an extent that the karguzar immediately gave them a notice to close it down.Footnote 66
The new quarter that the Russians established beyond the city walls in Taqiabad area came about as a result of the Russian policy to provide security for the personnel in their own quarter. The Russian Consulate designed the idea in association with the Russian Bank in Mashhad. The main motive was security against the religious riots to which Mashhad was constantly prone.Footnote 67 It is noteworthy that, adjacent to the large plot of land they had bought in Taqiabad, they constructed a gate for their traffic, although it is not known precisely where on the wall this was placed.
The pressure of market forces and the weakness and corruption of the local government, in particular the Karguzars, meant that even crown lands fell into the hands of Russian subjects. In Gilan, they acquired large stretches of forest, which in the years following the Revolution of 1906 were gradually sold outright and illegally to the Russian-owned Khoshtaria Company.Footnote 68 In another case in Tabriz, a significant piece of khalasa land in the city was sold to a Russian subject with the support of their consulate around the time of the Constitutional Revolution. The General Governor of Tabriz Shuja al-Daula arranged the deal through the Ministry of the Interior. When in 1912 Mr Mornard inquired how the sale had come about he was told that the property was situated far from the bazaar and therefore not suited for commercial purposes. Meanwhile the Russian Consulate General in Tabriz claimed that the property had been acquired legally and produced its register. The Iranian Government protested that the sale was unlawful land sold to foreigners when foreigners had no right to own land in Iran. However, with the deteriorating political crisis, there was little they could do.Footnote 69
Conclusion
Firstly, with regard to the subject of land purchase itself, the picture which emerges over the long period in question is complicated, there being considerable differences as between the north and the south of Iran, and different stages in the policies of the countries concerned. In the south much property was rented, but the Iranian Government managed on the whole to restrain British subjects from actually buying, by adept and persistent though varied use of the articles of the Treaty of Turkmenchai. In part this was due to greater British legalism, in part to the reluctance of the British Government to become embroiled in disputes over land purchases, which it did not perceive as being in its interest. Therefore the Iranian policy was on the whole consistently maintained. In other words, the view that the British had different objectives and interests to the Russians in Iran is reinforced by the way they dealt with the issue of land purchase.
In the north the picture is quite different. Large numbers of individuals from the Caucasus became Russian subjects through conquest in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth century. Under centuries’ old patterns of trading and occupation they owned land in Iran, which they were allowed to retain. However, where the sources, in particular up to the mid-century, refer to Russians holding land, it is not possible to ascertain whether these were the result of long-standing rights or of new purchase. The Russian government does not appear to have paid much attention to the stipulations of Turkmenchai for most of the century, though around the 1880s British influence on the Iranian government, as well as Iranian concerns, seems to have led the Russians to rein in land purchases at least for a while. The growing demands of the world economy were taking their toll by the later 1880s and the 1890s, which made it more difficult for the Iranian Government to hold back the creeping Russian encroachment in the north. By the period of the Constitutional Revolution up to 1911 the dire financial situation and outright occupation of the country in 1911 meant that the Russian encroachment became more or less irresistible.
Finally, therefore, on the subject of national sovereignty, the study of foreign land purchase in Iran over the period in question supports the view, as far as the north is concerned, that there was creeping, though at times intermittent, undermining of Iranian national sovereignty by the Russians in the nineteenth century. In the early part of the twentieth century, as the Iranian state collapsed, Russian acquisition of land accelerated to the point where the Iranian government suffered serious loss of sovereignty in the north. With regard to the south, however, despite the growth of the British commercial presence, Iran did not suffer loss of sovereignty through land purchase because the British, for the reasons indicated, did not consider it in their interest. From the time of the First World War, Britain was of course to undermine Iranian sovereignty by other means, namely its security arrangements and its oil interest.
