As the United States's most prolific living composer of art songs, Rorem has an extensive list of over 50 recordings of his works available to date. Produced by an all-British ensemble, this disc's appealing combination of repertoire and performing artists offers a delightful example of Anglo-American cross-fertilization. The poetic texts, included in the liner notes, greatly contribute to the understanding of each singer's diction and the poets’ intentions.
Born in Richmond, Indiana on 23 October 1923, Rorem occupies influential positions in the United States as both a composer and critic. The recipient of numerous awards, he now lists more than 400 songs for solo voice with piano or small ensemble. In addition, he has written eighteen books—primarily diaries of his experiences as a young composer—as well as essays on musical taste, conventions, and artists of his time.
Wystand Hugh Auden (1907–73), born in York, England, was educated at Christ Church, Oxford where his precocity as a poet became immediately apparent. He moved to the United States in 1939 and became a citizen. His writings frequently recount, literally or metaphorically, a journey or quest. Some of the central themes of Auden's poetry are love, dreams, death, politics and citizenship, religion and morals, and the relationship between human beings and the anonymous, impersonal world of nature. Also reflected in his poetry are the often-mimicked writing styles of other poets such as W. B. Yeats, Henry James, and Emily Dickinson. With his exceptional wit, he incorporates into his work elements of popular culture, current events, and vernacular speech.
Rorem, quoted in Russell Platt's liner notes, describes the seven poems of Auden, heard here as The Auden Songs (1989), but listed by the publisher as “The Auden Poems,” as “an admixture of cynicism and vulnerability, of force and hopelessness, of hot sadness and cold joy, of an objectivity which nevertheless surges.” Reading Auden's words, one is struck by the bold and constantly changing imagery that characterizes each poem. In his setting, Rorem endeavors to be true to the form and character of the poetry, in some instances going so far as to write different music for each stanza within a piece, with added variations and embellishments as suggested by the texts.
Rorem's vocal writing style in The Auden Songs is primarily syllabic, though there are inevitably some melismatic passages. The elements of the accompaniment writing also vary from melodic and lyric to percussive and declamatory, as in “But I can't,” and often include recitative-like passages and abrupt dynamic contrasts as in “Yes, we are going to suffer.” The demands he makes on the vocalist are considerable, requiring a broad tessitura, agile technique, and great stamina to negotiate the changes in tempo, style, and dynamic range, which appear often in this cycle.
Christopher Lemmings, who performs The Auden Songs on this CD, is best known for his work in twentieth-century and contemporary music. He studied at the Guildhall School of Music and Drama in London and seems the perfect choice for this cycle. With his delicate lyric tenor voice, he renders thoughtful and effective interpretations of Auden's varying moods and manages to meet the demands made on his instrument by the composer. His diction is clear and understandable, with an even tone throughout his range. His performance is exciting, energetic and sensitive.
Harold Witter Bynner (1881–1968), author of the texts of the second cycle on this recording, was born in Brooklyn, New York. He graduated from Harvard University in 1902 and initially pursued a career in journalism. Later residing in Cornish, New Hampshire until 1915, he turned to writing poetry and drama, which he continued to do throughout his life. He later moved to Santa Fe, New Mexico where he resided for some 30 years. Rorem selected twelve of Bynner's poems, issued separately in a variety of publications, and grouped them together in a cycle he entitled The Santa Fe Songs (1980). The poems of this cycle were written during Bynner's time in Santa Fe and could not be more different in character and writing style from the Auden texts. Idyllic and charming, the central themes of these poems offer contemplations on nature, small-town life, music and musicians, death, and time. This cycle is presented on this recording in its entirety for the first time. In each of the settings, Rorem has created the appropriate atmosphere or musical landscape—whichever corresponds to the needs of each poem. His use of a similar musical figure in two different songs demonstrates how varied results can be obtained from the same device. For example, in “El Musico,” the descending scales recall the opening figure in “The Shield of Achilles” from the Auden cycle. Having made this observation, however, I must add that the similarity ends there as the character of each poem is quite unique: Auden's “The Shield of Achilles” is about disappointment and expectations vs. reality, whereas Bynner's “El Musico” depicts a singer who sometimes sings a bit flat, or sharp, or thin, yet always does his very best. Rorem's setting of “El Musico” is characterized by more melodic lines and less percussive accompaniment than that of “The Shield of Achilles.”
Another highlight of The Santa Fe Songs is “The Wintry Mind.” In this poetic gem, Bynner evokes a vast, frosty landscape. Responding musically, Rorem paints a correspondingly cold, desolate, snow-covered scene by means of a progression of slow-moving dissonant chords over a descending bass line. The warm, lyrical vocal line stands in marked contrast, as though offering refuge from the cold. An evenly and unhurriedly rendered text results in an eerily quiet setting. The overall effect is hypnotic.
British mezzo-soprano Sara Fulgoni, the performer of The Santa Fe Songs on this recording, is primarily known for her operatic singing. A graduate of the Royal Northern College of Music, she made her debut at Covent Garden in 2003 in Verdi's Luisa Miller. Her rich and lustrous mezzo-soprano soars through the highs and lows of Rorem's demanding tessitura with apparent ease. Although her diction is a bit less clear than Lemmings's, her rendition of Bynner's poems is sensitive and effective and her interpretations are always warm, compelling, and exciting.
The London-based ensemble, Chamber Domaine is at the cutting edge of music making today. Committed to performing and recording contemporary instrumental chamber music and song, the group often gives world premieres of new music by leading composers. The ensemble maintains a core of thirteen players with a flexible instrumentation consisting of woodwinds, brass, strings, percussion, and piano. Known for its brilliant tone, precision of execution, and soulfulness of interpretation, Chamber Domaine plays with great verve, covering a range of emotions from eerily quiet to fever-pitched intensity. They negotiate Rorem's often fast-paced and percussive accompaniments in both cycles with a committed energy and sensitivity that verges on electrifying.
In sum, these two song cycles, with their extraordinarily varied content and character, offer a wealth of opportunities for interpretive expression. Through their sensitive, sympathetic projections of the poetic texts, Lemmings and Fulgoni open for us a window into the music and the mind of Ned Rorem, one of today's consummate musical dramatists.
