Is there a better recommendation for a book than to admit to have started using it even before finishing the review? The sweep of McCallum's is broad – Australian playwriting in the twentieth century; its detail deep – a description of every significant drama in the period (the play-list alone numbers fifty-one pages.) Though grand narratives are out of fashion, there is a need for a through-line to prevent Australian drama dissolving into a tapestry of local efforts. In a nifty historical insight McCallum makes the end the means: it is the very search for identity which overdetermines the process of canon creation in a colonial, later postcolonial, land.
The book breaks into three. The first section, which runs from Steele Rudd's 1912 On Our Selection into the 1960s, is a revelation. Charting the transformation of outback sagas and station melodrama into their metropolitan and contemporary equivalents, McCallum unearths a wealth of detail about playwrights dismissed or largely forgotten. He is particularly insightful on the ‘genre play’, once the grist for weekly repertory, later the enemy of high modern experimenters. The second section mimics existing studies of ‘new wave’ drama of the 1970s. Here the tone is confirmatory, a nod to a pecking order long established. There are surprises, though, particularly when McCallum switches from summarizing plays to analysing their authors, as he does with David Williamson (aside from Patrick White the only playwright to get a full chapter). After that, the playwright-centric approach shows limits. Identity gives way to identities, singular narrative to a ‘complex negotiation of difference’ (p. 280). If the final section feels patchy, even perfunctory, the cultural landscape McCallum seeks to describe may be to blame.
Early on, the author asserts that Australian theatre cycles between ‘strident nationalism and . . . outward-looking internationalism’ (p. 5). He does not say, but effectively demonstrates, that it also alternates between emotionally driven naturalism and imaginatively precocious theatricalism. This division cuts across the first. Yet in his determination to show that the realist playwrights of the 1950s (Ray Lawler and successors) were ‘the end of an era’ (p. 77) and that White's expressionism was the way of the future, he skews the historical record. White's influence is inflated, realism's understated. Indeed, McCallum avoids even the word ‘realism’ (Williamson is a ‘genre writer’ whose work falls ‘between recognition comedy and satire’) (p. 169). His skew is understandable. In the past, McCallum has been critical of Leslie Rees's History of Australian Drama (1978), which weights the account the other way: for realism and against theatricalism. Taken together, the two articulate the great agon informing Australian drama as a whole.
A theatre critic as well as a historian, McCallum's writing has the raciness of a first-person account, an adventure through art. Enthusiasm is the predominant affect of the book, which is full of personal asides and frank recommendations. Like Rees, McCallum combines history, advocacy and critical awareness, creating a mnemonic for a body of work that, unless it is regularly revived, stands to be lost. Those looking to grasp modern Australian drama in one cognitive hit have come to the right place.
