The house lights come up. I stand up with my fellow audience members, gather my coat and bag. I leave the theatre, chatting eagerly to my companion about the play just performed, about the movie just screened, about the performance event witnessed. Beyond a facile thumbs-up, thumbs-down to my friend, what are my obligations to communicate my observations to a larger audience? What criteria should I apply? Why does what I think matter? Jill Dolan's new book The Feminist Spectator in Action radically invites the mobilization of a cadre of mindful citizen critics who will speak and write publicly about what is made apparent to us and what remains invisible.
An offshoot of Dolan's lauded blog “The Feminist Spectator” (launched in 2005 and awarded the George Jean Nathan award for criticism in 2011), the book consists primarily of reprinted blog posts, offering a “best of” collection with a smattering of new material written specifically for the book. Loosely organized into four parts—Advocacy, Activism, Argument, Artistry—Dolan's posts encompass the most popular of pop culture products, including The Hunger Games and The Social Network, mainstream theatrical productions like The Normal Heart and the musical Once, as well as more localized performance events like Jomama Jones: Radiate and Peggy Shaw and Lois Weaver's Lost Lounge. Dolan's self-appointed task is to examine mainstream culture through a feminist lens, assessing the representation of women and other marginalized identity positions in contemporary storytelling. This interest extends beyond narrative representations of gender, race, and sexuality to a consideration of how female, racialized, and LGBTQ characters are framed in our visual field on the stage and screen. By bringing feminist values to bear on these cultural products, Dolan reminds us that we are not merely viewers but active consumers of these stories, enmeshed in the systems that create and disseminate them. Dolan's example encourages us to be more critical and to leverage our influence as audience members to reshape cultural offerings if they do not reflect the world as we see it, or even at a higher standard—the world as we hope it might be.
The interactivity of Web 2.0 along with the corollary networking portals of social media have empowered public opinion like never before. User reviews on sites such as Urbanspoon, Amazon, and Airbnb advise us where to eat, what to read, where to lodge. Support structures for the dissemination of citizen criticism are already well developed. We need only be bold. In this activist vein, Dolan envisions what might be: “[H]ow might such an expanded cadre of arts writers be a boon to feminist and other art production marginalized by identity or politics?” (12).
Dolan maintains that the multiplication of a diversity of views can displace traditional centers of critical power. In theatre and film, the power of arbitration of value has been concentrated in just a few sanctioned voices. More than esoteric evaluation of artistic work, these reviewers become de facto gatekeepers, influencing the economics of production, enabling certain values and practices to proliferate while others are stunted. Considering the perch of these critical elites, Dolan also challenges their retreat behind a false mask of objectivity. As critics, we need to assert our own ideological positions, which form the foundation of our judgments.
To some Dolan's reliance on thick description to elucidate the basic narrative, characters, setting, and central themes of the particular play/movie/television show under consideration might seem retrograde or lightweight. However, it is important to talk about something as seemingly old-fashioned as what the work is about. It is through these descriptions that the reader can be introduced to unfamiliar work, inspired perhaps to check out that heretofore unwatched film or TV show, or to read that script, and with Dolan as our guide, to add a soupçon of that experience to our repertoire. This is an effective strategy for bringing more people into the conversation, into a shared cultural community, and for promoting work that stimulates and inspires.
Another possible critique is that in featuring mostly reprints, the main body of the book is a duplication of Dolan's blog. In terms of medium, the book arguably makes a backward technological move, from online to print. And so we might ask, “Who is the audience for the book?” and “How is this group different from the existing blog audience?” I will confess that although I knew Dolan's work and was aware of her blog prior to reading The Feminist Spectator in Action, I was not a follower. Now I am. The change of medium is an effective move to draw new participants into the conversation, notably general-interest readers and undergraduate students in the fields of theatre, film, and media studies as well as gender studies. Also the selectivity of the book, which contains only thirty-four entries, presents a curated experience that is quite different than sifting through hundreds of archived blog posts.
Arguably it is Part V, the book's “‘How-To’ Guide,” that is of most interest. In it Dolan gives concrete advice on how to put a feminist critical perspective into practice. In addition to prompt questions that signal feminist content, Dolan also points potential critics toward reviewing the reviewers, interrogating but also learning from other critics. She encourages description without judgment and remembering to place the work in its context. Overall, this final part is a useful guide for inculcating students into critical writing about performance. For the rest of us, The Feminist Spectator in Action is a call to action—to change the nature of the critical canon, professing not only what we do or do not see, but what we hope to see someday.
