This is dedicated to East Havana / where we party in the alleys / Micro 10,322, the wide street, Zona 11 / The capital of rap will always and forever be.
Soandry, Hermanos de CausaAbout six miles east of Havana, just beyond the aquamarine blue of the Caribbean Sea and the low-density shrubs of the flat plains, stand the tall, rectangular buildings of the Alamar housing projects. The five- and six-story buildings were designed by Soviet architects and built by microbrigades (ordinary people organized into work teams) as a solution to housing shortages in Havana in the 1970s. As part of slum clearance programs, black communities from slum areas such as Llega y Pon, Las Yaguas, and Palo Cagao were relocated to Alamar. The 1970s were a grim era of Cuban history, known euphemistically as the quinquenio gris (gray five years) but that actually lasted closer to fifteen years, when the orthodoxy of Soviet socialism overshadowed cultural and social life on the island. The heavy and somber buildings immortalized the spirit of those years. With a population of 300,000 in over 2,000 buildings, Alamar is the largest housing project in the world. It's no wonder that Alamar has been called Cuba's South Bronx.
East of Havana is a tribute to the housing projects of Alamar that gave rise to Cuba's hip-hop movement. Among the plethora of documentaries that have recently been produced on Cuban hip-hop, including La Fabrika (Lisandro Pérez-Rey, 2004), Desde el Principio (Vanessa Díaz, 2006), Inventos (Eli Jacobs Fantuzzi, 2003), and The Cuban Hip-Hop All Stars (Joshua Bee Alafia, 2004), none addresses Alamar as deeply as this film.
From the beginning of the film, the viewer is exposed to the sounds of the unique and diverse genre of Cuban hip-hop. Because of the difficulties of having access to recording equipment for making beats, Cuban rappers have been highly inventive. Some have relied on “pause tapes,” on which they record the break beat from an American rap CD on a cassette, and then manually loop it over and over until they have a complete song. Others bring in live instruments—whether those from pop and jazz such as guitar, keyboards, and drum kit; or traditional African drums such as the ritual bata and the mellow low-pitched bombo andino; the berimbau, a stringed instrument traditionally associated with Afro-Brazilian capoeira; and the woven basket rattle known as caxixi—and rappers will chant and sing in African languages such as Yoruba. Given the deep musical and spiritual influence of Africa in Cuban cultural production, it is not surprising that this influence is also being reflected within hip-hop culture.
The film opens with the reggae-inflected rap “Guapo como Mandela” by Anonimo Consejo (Anonymous Advice). We see Miki Flow recording a song with Cuban hip-hop producer Pablo Herrera rapping, “The underground train that won't stop,” alongside an upbeat salsa background track and punctuated by his cries of “esto mi'jo” and “aaaiii.” Toward the end, Hermanos de Causa (Brothers of the Cause) perform their rap “Tengo” (I Have), a contemporary take on the poem by Afro-Cuban poet Nicolás Guillén that celebrates the changes that the revolution brought for blacks. By contrast, for Hermanos de Causa, “I have a dark and discriminated race / I have a workday that demands and gives nothing / I have so many things that I can't even touch them / I have facilities I can't even set foot in / I have liberty between parentheses of iron.” The song, performed in Pablo's recording studio, uses live jazz guitars and keyboards with a funky female vocalist in the background.
The narrative of East of Havana follows the life of three Alamar-based artists, Soandry from the group Hermanos de Causa, Magyori from EPG&B, and Miki Flow from Explosión Suprema (Supreme Explosion), who are part of a project known as El Cartel. These groups are some of the best known and most lyrically innovative in the Cuban rap scene. However, their prestige comes mostly from their followings in small local peñas or concerts: because of their hard-hitting lyrics and themes, these artists were not represented among the ten or so groups in the official Cuban rap agency started in 2001. The Cuban-American filmmakers enter the lives of the rappers one month before the annual Cuban rap festival in 2004, due to begin on 20 August. On 13 August 2004, however, the island is hit by Hurricane Charley, and a day before the festival, the rappers are told by an official that the festival they have been anticipating all year will be canceled. The film traces the groups' disappointment and their return to the boredom and frustrations of their lives.
The film offers unexpected turns of plot and insights into the Cuban cultural bureaucracy, but ultimately the narrative is not what sustains it. Rather, the small moments of everyday life give the film its poignancy and humor. Soandry and Magyori struggle to hoist a wooden bird cage onto the roof of their building, scaling rickety ladders. Magyori tries to sell her used clothing on the street to earn a few extra dollars so that she can pay her rent. The rappers make music with an ancient stereo that they describe as a museum artifact and a microphone shielded by a homemade pop screen made of pantyhose. Just like young people in the Bronx, who developed sound systems from thrown-away stereos and abandoned car radios and who made turntable mixers from microphone mixers, the film shows Cuban rappers improvising with the materials they have available to them in an era of scarcity.
Still, East of Havana manages to convey little of the background and history of hip-hop culture in Cuba or its evolving relationship with the state. During one scene, the filmmakers say that “artists operate outside of Cuba's government-controlled music industry.” In the next scene, the rappers from El Cartel are being interviewed on state radio by DJ and promoter Ariel Fernandez. What does it mean to be “outside”? How do rappers such as El Cartel locate themselves in relation to state institutions? What position do Cuba's prominent DJs and producers inhabit within Cuba's cultural bureaucracy? These questions are not answered by the film, which sticks to a rather basic dichotomy of inside/outside. Given the brief period that the filmmakers spent with the rappers, this lack of depth is perhaps to be expected. It is perhaps also timely that Cubans themselves, especially those with intimate knowledge of how rappers have negotiated with the state over many years, are beginning to make their own hip-hop documentaries. The film “A Short Radiography of Hip-Hop in Cuba” by Cuban filmmaker Ricardo Bacallao follows the experiences of an independent group of artists, Grupo Uno, who founded the hip-hop festival and ran it until it was taken over by the Youth League, or Asociación Hermanos Saíz (Hermanos Saíz Association). Made on a fraction of the budget of East of Havana, Bacallao's film is yet another example of the new creative avenues into which Cuban hip-hop is venturing. It also shows that the field of Cuban hip-hop documentary production is becoming almost as diverse as Cuban hip-hop itself. Yet despite its shortcomings, East of Havana brings much needed attention to the Alamar housing project, its sonic and visual landscapes, and its rappers, who are often given short shrift in hip-hop documentaries.
