The question of authenticity continues to haunt the study of African art. Storerooms in museums the world over are filled with ‘fakes’, objects deemed unworthy of public display or interrogation. But who or what determines the boundaries of the authentic? Which objects merit study, and which histories are silenced in the process? Such queries motivate a broad range of scholarly study of Africa. In one of her seminal essays, ‘African Art and Authenticity: A Text with a Shadow’, art historian Sidney Kasfir defined authentic African art, in one sense, as that ‘untainted’ by Western society. Kasfir writes, ‘We need first of all to recognize that the precolonial past, seen from the present, is an idealization for Europeans and Africans alike.’Footnote 9 The importance that Western collectors of historical African art place on ‘authenticity’ often denies African artists their agency as well as their right to historicity, or change over time. Yet, we must also take care not to underestimate the power of the idea of authenticity among Africans themselves.
In her impressively researched historical analysis, Authentically African: Arts and the Transnational Politics of Congolese Culture, historian Sarah Van Beurden takes up the topic of transnational politics and the authenticity of African art. Van Beurden focuses on the museum as the primary site of debate about cultural authenticity in colonial and postcolonial Congo. More specifically, she charts the development of two central institutions: The Royal Museum for Central Africa (originally the Museum of the Belgian Congo) in Tervuren, Belgium, which was founded by King Leopold II; and the Institut des Musées Nationaux du Zaire (IMNZ) in Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of Congo, which was created by Mobutu Sese Seko. The Royal Museum for Central Africa (commonly known as Tervuren) contributed in particular to the transformation of African artifacts into art objects, to be collected and valued for their formal properties. But both institutions organized international exhibitions in the postcolonial period that fueled interest in the African art market.
Van Beurden's investigation hinges on the concept of cultural guardianship, the ‘set of strategies that legitimate political power through the stewardship of cultural heritage’, which justified Belgium's continued colonial presence in Congo before its appropriation by Mobutu in his campaign for authenticité, or authenticity (1). In its broadest sense, Authentically African ‘analyzes the reinvention of traditional cultures as national heritage, as well as world heritage, in order to explore guardianship in the construction of hegemony – nationally, but also internationally’ (2). The book lays bare the cultural and political economies in which authenticity and its art object proxies circulate as currency for the profit of different political actors. The six chapters of Authentically African follow chronologically from Belgium's first colonial involvement in Congo in the late nineteenth century through the postcolonial pressures of the 1980s.
The first two chapters focus on the development of collecting institutions during the colonial period. Chapter One situates Tervuren as an institution based on the (colonial) impulse to control through the collection, description, and classification of objects. Interested, above all, in representing and reinventing Congo for a Belgian audience, Tervuren was a museum dedicated to the promotion of colonialism itself, a legacy with which it continues to grapple. Van Beurden notes, ‘Belgium came to see itself as the guardian not only of the colony's mineral resources but also of the cultural authenticity of its “traditional” cultures, the protection of which was embodied by the museum’ (29). In the process of salvaging Congolese cultural traditions from the impact of modernity, select objects from the past were transformed from artifact to art, to objects with academic and monetary value. Chapter Two focuses on modern cultural production in late colonial Congo and discusses the development of an aesthetic politics, or politique aesthetique, designed to combat anxieties about modernity's alleged deleterious effect on arts and crafts in the colony.
The following chapters bring the history of collecting in Congo into the early Independence period. Chapter Three follows Mobutu's call for the restitution of objects seized during the colonial era as part of his campaign to reinvent diverse artistic traditions as national heritage. Recognizing the importance of cultural guardianship to Belgium's legitimation of colonialism, Mobutu saw cultural authenticity as crucial to consolidating postcolonial political power. While cultural objects were prized by Mobutu for their national importance, they consequently became pawns in an international debate over universal cultural heritage that allowed Tervuren to keep its most valuable objects. Tervuren ‘gifted’ rather than repatriated objects of lesser value to avoid confronting the process by which its holdings were originally obtained.
Chapters Four and Five turn a critical eye on Mobutu's IMNZ. The institution began operations in 1970, with support from Belgian scholars and Tervuren. While IMNZ sought to decolonize museum institutional practices, collections, and research, it failed to confront how colonialism constructed African cultures or to grapple with the meanings and forms of modern and contemporary artistic production. Aiming to compete on equal ground with the standards maintained by European collections, the IMNZ ultimately was unsuccessful in its attempts to develop its own identity or local audience. Ironically, the institution's nationalistic claims of cultural guardianship over art produced by Congo's diverse culture groups closely followed colonial practices. Van Beurden writes that this policy ‘exposes the roots of “culture as property” in a system of exploitation that goes back to the reinvention of artifacts as art in the colonial era’ (206).
In the final chapter, Van Beurden explores the transnational reinvention of art objects from Congo through an examination of exhibitions of Congolese art that traveled to the United States from the late 1960s through the early 1980s. These exhibitions aimed to promote different frameworks for control over the production of meaning and knowledge about Congolese art and catered to the importance of African art in diasporic and African American communities. The chapter makes clear that the remaking of postcolonial cultural representation in Congo was not limited to national actors or audiences but also included the involvement of transnational networks.
Authentically African is an indispensable contribution to a growing body of African art scholarship focused on institutional and collecting histories. It serves audiences interested in material culture, museum studies, African history, and art history. Bringing together French and Flemish language sources for the first time, in addition to extensive fieldwork and interviews, Van Beurden gives a comprehensive and forthright account of the development of museums in Belgium and Congo that has no precedent. The dense text makes clear the role played by the circulation and recontextualization of art objects in the political economies of colonial and postcolonial Congo. However, among the transnational network of actors invested in the politics of Congolese culture, one important set of figures remains missing from most of Van Beurden's study: the artists themselves. The volume could benefit from placing specific objects and their artists at the center of the contexts that Van Beurden so meticulously recounts. As Kasfir reminds us, ‘it is crucial to relocate the notion of authenticity in the minds of those who make art and not those on the other side of the Atlantic Ocean who collect it’.Footnote 10
