Modern scientists continue to make spectacular advances: they can decode the genome and enable us to peer into the farthest reaches of the universe. However, an area that remains puzzling and resistant to study is what Orwell called ‘the few cubic centimetres inside your skull’. The distinguished neurologist Oliver Sacks has taken the brain as his subject and made its enigmas accessible to the general reader. His previous books, The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat and Awakenings explored the strange twilight world experienced by brain-damaged people and their carers.
Sacks has enjoyed a lifelong involvement with music, and his new book explores the ways in which the brain processes sounds and how music helps humans to connect. Only when disease and trauma disrupt normal perception and consciousness can we begin to realise what extraordinary work the brain does. Functions that we take for granted, like memory, language and other forms of communication can deteriorate in bizarre and disturbing ways. By the same token, loss of some functions can lead to compensation through the unexpected development of others. Blind people, for example, develop enhanced aural perception. People suffering from Alzheimer's disease, which gradually renders them incapable of functioning in most normal activities, often retain an awareness of and responsiveness to music.
The friendly word tales in the title draws the general reader in to what is in fact a series of anecdotes, some as short as two pages. Many recount appalling suffering, disability and worsening of ‘normal’ mental powers, but all are shot through with descriptions of the extraordinary resilience of human musicality which, in many cases, seems to outlive other faculties such as memory for events, speech or the ability to count. ‘Especially moving here is not merely the preservation but the apparent heightening of musical powers and sensitivity, as other powers wane.’ The sequence of case studies is somewhat reminiscent of Freud's early writings, although Sacks has no grand theory to propound. However, he does confront the reader with fundamental questions. What is music? What is its survival value? Why is it that rhythm, ‘in the special sense of combining movement and sound – appears spontaneously in human children, but not in any other primate’?
The book opens, literally, with a thunderbolt. A surgeon, hit by lightning, made a full recovery, but the influx of electricity into his brain stimulated a dormant appetite for music that emerged and almost took him over. Sacks, who declares himself ‘an old Jewish atheist’ will have no truck with supernatural explanations: ‘even the most exalted states of mind, the most astounding transformations, must have some physical basis or at least some physiological correlate in neural activity’. Although this and many of Sacks’ other cases highlight extreme and exceptional circumstances, for me the most interesting pages deal with the more mundane peculiarities of music and the way that it seems to flow, like an underground river, permeating the subconscious. Why, for example, working at a humdrum household task the other day, did I notice that a piece of music that I had not heard since my student days, some 40 years ago, was playing at the back of my mind? Why do some musical people routinely associate pitches, chords or keys with colours, while others do not? Just as Freud's Psychopathology of Everyday Life interested me more than some of his more far-fetched studies of early twentieth century Viennese neurotics, Sacks’ chapter on ‘Music on the Brain: Imagery and Imagination’ stimulated me most in its exploration of the astonishing ordinariness of much normal mental engagement with music. One anecdote has a decidedly Freudian ring as Sacks recalls puzzling about a dream conjured up the sounds of Mahler's Kindertotenlieder the day after he had resigned from a post in a children's unit. ‘My dreaming mind, with infallible precision, came up with an appropriate symbol of the previous day's events.’
Sacks writes throughout in a style that is both eloquent and readable. The few passages of medical jargon, no doubt essential in the presentation of clinical evidence, do not seriously impede the compelling overall flow of his narrative. One of the many pleasures that the book affords is its wide range of cultural reference, not only to music (from Mahler to the Grateful Dead, from Christmas carols to Jewish cantillation); but also to medicine (naturally), culture, literature and languages. Sacks’ erudition also covers the physical sciences, religion and philosophy. One of the many footnotes sheds intriguing light on the use that one of the greatest scientists of all made of his acute aural imagery:
Galileo famously exemplified this in his experiments timing the descent of objects as they rolled down inclined planes. Having no accurate watches or clocks to go by, he timed each trial by humming tunes to himself, and this allowed him to get results with an accuracy far beyond that of the timepieces of his era.
Sacks also wonders if pianist Paul Wittgenstein, who continued to perform with his left hand after losing his right arm during the First World War might have ‘played a part in inciting’ the thinking of his philosopher brother who wrote: ‘If you know that here is one hand, we'll grant you all the rest.’ as the opening proposition of his book On Certainty.
While believing that ‘there is much to suggest that there is an innate musicality in virtually everyone’, Sacks does not shirk the issue of ‘amusia’ – indifference to music or defective perception of music, which may be temporary or permanent. Loss of hearing in one ear may cause this. (We hear stereophonically just as we see stereoscopically, and we under-estimate the emotional flattening that occurs when we lose either the sight in one eye or the hearing in one ear.) While dealing with the physiology of the brain, Sacks identifies areas that research has mapped and identified as distinctively musical. He shows that the ability to listen to a complex texture is an extraordinary learned act of perception. One gifted composer lost the ability to perceive and sort musical complexity after being involved in a road accident. She, in her own words, had lost her aural ‘filtering system’. Sacks calls this ‘dysharmonia’ – the inability to integrate different voices and instruments when listening. Hearing loss can bring with it added misfortune if accompanied by a loss in pitch perception, making the experience of listening frustrating and painful. Yet the brain has a wonderful ability to adapt. Patients whose hearing of pitches seemed to get worse during the first weeks of the onset of deafness, nevertheless eventually adjusted to the new situation:
I, as a neurologist, am filled with wonder that the retuning in his musician's brain has been able to counterbalance the patchy and inconstant output from his aging cochleas, that through intensive musical activity, attention, and will, Jacob's brain has literally reshaped itself.
One chapter deals with musical ‘savants’, people with exceptional ability. Some, but not all, have impairment in other faculties, relating to autism, or its milder form, Asperger's syndrome. Sacks is careful to differentiate here. Some gifted people have special abilities such as absolute pitch, while remaining completely closed off as human beings. However, people with other forms of disability may show an exceptional warmth and personal connectedness that are conveyed through a deep liking for and involvement in music on an emotional level. ‘In children with Williams Syndrome . . . there is always a strong desire to play music with and for others.’ The longest and most affecting case study in the book is that of Clive Wearing, the distinguished English conductor and musical scholar who was cut down in his prime by a virus that left almost all his faculties for memory in tatters, apart from those related to his musicianship and his ability to communicate this to others through his conducting. The account of re-building of his life, through the loving and devoted support of his wife over more than 20 years is both poignant and inspirational.
The final section on ‘Emotion, Identity and Music’ shows how music can knit feeling and thinking together. ‘Often when we listen to music, we are conscious of both: we may be moved to our depths even as we appreciate the formal structure of a composition.’ Even when we lose the cognitive side of listening, we can still be moved. One patient, who could no longer recognise even the items in her personal record collection, could still say she was moved by the sadness that Albinioni's Adagio seemed to convey, although she could not recall ever having heard it before! Sacks concludes that ‘the emotional response to music may have a very specific physiological basis of its own, one that is distinct from that of emotional responsiveness in general.’
‘Every disease is a musical problem, every cure is a musical solution’, said the German Romantic writer Novalis. This may seem an overstatement, but as this book shows, perhaps his intuition wasn't that far off the mark. There are several allusions to Sacks’ own experiences of illness and bereavement, where music played a therapeutic role. The ‘sudden whisper or intimation of life, of joy’ conveyed by the sound of a Schubert song pouring from a basement window in New York's Central Park is among the many vivid snapshots that Sacks conveys from his personal encounters with music's healing power. Great thinkers of the past, such as Darwin, Freud and William James showed little interest in music's role in shaping human evolution or the functioning of the mind. Sacks’ new book is therefore especially welcome as a contribution to the developing intellectual climate of the present century.
