In the spring of 1703, Tsar Peter I's army captured a small Swedish fort on an island in the delta where the Neva River emptied into the Gulf of Finland. This seemingly minor event in a sparsely populated border region between Sweden and the Russian Empire served as the founding moment in the creation of St. Petersburg. Over the next several decades, Peter and his successors embarked on a massive building program that turned a swampy collection of islands into the capital and largest city of a quickly expanding empire. By the time of Peter's death in 1725, the city held over 40,000 people. In 1811, over 330,000 people called St. Petersburg home, making it the 5th largest city in Europe (p. 23).
Economists and economic historians tend to think about the growth of urban centers in terms of agglomeration forces, amenities, and initial conditions that foster path dependencies. In standard models, the growth of a city is closely tied to the economic conditions of its hinterland, especially when it comes to supplying labor and food, and to the size and scope of trade integration with more distant markets. As Robert Jones clearly maps out in this fascinating study, the rise of St. Petersburg in the eighteenth century occurred despite the dearth of nearby food production and in the face of transportation connections that were initially non-existent and eventually just onerous, costly, and slow. Over the century, an elaborate system of merchants, wholesalers, grain sellers, bakeries, and granaries arose that brought grain to the city by internal waterways (connecting to the grain producing areas within the Volga and Oka River basins) and sold bread to the city's population at various urban markets and other points of sale. The story Jones tells is one of the growth and functioning of a geographically vast commodity market that was of key strategic concern to the burgeoning Russian state. This interest manifested itself in the direct buying and selling of grain by the government, in regulation of the various stages of trade, in the creation of infrastructure such as new canals, and in the maintenance of storage facilities that served to stabilize the price of provisions in the city. Grain price spikes and shortages still occurred, but they were infrequent and quickly ended. By the early nineteenth century, the grain trade was fully developed, and an all-Russian market had emerged. This is the story told exceptionally well by Jones in a way that builds on and improves important Soviet-era studies by scholars such as Boris Mironov and L.V. Milov.
Jones relies on an impressive array of archival and published sources to depict the passage of grain from the mostly peasant producers in the grain regions to the final consumers of bread in the capital. The material allows him to quantitatively document prices and the extent of the trade, although the focus of the study is more on qualitatively documenting the links in the chain. What comes through most evocatively are the micro-details of the grain trade, from the soil conditions of agricultural regions, to the types of sacks and conveyances used to get the product to the capital. At the same time, Jones nicely integrates the Russian case into the broader historical and comparative literatures. Although the focus is historical, the study does well to employ some simple but powerful concepts from economics, and, as a result, any economic historian interested in early modern markets and the role of the state should read it.
In terms of the book's structure, after describing the founding of St. Petersburg, the chapters are organized thematically. Somewhat idiosyncratically, Jones focuses first on the retail sale of foodstuffs in the city, before journeying to central and southern Russia where production occurred, and then following the grain back to the city through the traders, the financing, and the trade routes. These middle chapters of the book constitute not only a close examination of the agents, institutions, and government policies that made the grain trade, but they also amount to a remarkable synopsis of the early stages of Russian economic modernization. The chapters entitled “Production” and “Commerce,” in particular, are wonderful accounts of grain production and the structure of trade. Jones closes by considering exports and the state's role in trading off revenue demands versus supplies for the city.
While deeply impressed by this work, this reviewer did have a few minor quibbles regarding a few aspects of the study. Occasionally, the employment of some simple economic arguments runs into difficulties. For instance, when discussing grain prices Jones tends to conflate relative and absolute price changes and their impact on economic decisions. When framing peasant production reactions to price changes, Jones tends to eschew any mention of profit maximization or optimal resource (i.e., labor) allocation, which would have helped frame the discussion. One final issue concerns the organization of the book. Although incredibly rich in its geographic detail, the narrative moves around in time and space in a somewhat haphazard way that partly masks the structure of its argument.
Peter the Great envisioned St. Petersburg as his “window on the West,” to serve as a trade port for exporting Russian commodities and importing goods, technologies, and culture from the rest of Europe. But building a metropolis in such an inhospitable and remote place meant making sure that food—grain and bread in particular—was available at a reasonable price to construction workers, soldiers, tradesmen, and their families, not to mention the Imperial Court, government officials, and the growing ranks of the nobility who increasingly spent some or all of the year in the capital. Jones's study illuminates how a relatively backward early modern state actually went about fostering and participating in the process of market development prior to industrialization.
