No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 September 2005
Morocco under French colonial rule has been the subject of a number of books in recent years, especially centered on the imposing first resident-general, Marshal Lyautey. The architect of the colonial Moroccan state, Lyautey was also influential throughout the French empire. With the voluminous work of Daniel Rivet, two books by William A. Hoisington, Jr., the older but still useful book by Robin Bidwell, and other general and more specialized studies, I was surprised to discover how many new insights Moshe Gershovich's book offers. None of the previous studies has so comprehensively explored the military aspects of the French administration for the entire length of the Protectorate. He convincingly argues how the actual “pacification” of Morocco, which was accomplished only in the south of the country in the 1930s, helped create the framework for the postindependence Moroccan state.
Gershovich has important things to say not only about the entire French colonial experience in Morocco, but also about France's overseas empire, the subject of the first chapter. Colonial intervention in Morocco took shape against the background of France's imperial strategy in Algeria and Tunisia, Indochina, sub-Saharan Africa, and elsewhere in the French empire. Indigenous Moroccan troops were employed in the conquest of Morocco but also served the French army in Europe and elsewhere in the overseas empire. France's reliance on its colonial armies was typical of this period of European expansion, though it was not as specific to the French as Gershovich suggests, especially considering the British employment of colonial troops. The book's discussion of the role of Moroccan troops contributes to a growing literature on the global impact of troops from colonized peoples in the waning days of empire and the period of decolonization.
Chapter 2 focuses on the erosion of Moroccan sovereignty in the precolonial period. The political turmoil in the first decade of the 20th century, coupled with France's growing military involvement in Morocco, set the stage for the establishment of the French Protectorate in 1912. Gershovich shows in the following two chapters how Lyautey's policy evolved during his tenure as resident-general in Morocco (1912–25). He arrived in Morocco with the concept of indirect rule, the ideology behind establishing a “protectorate” in Morocco, but what this meant in terms of Morocco's political future was ambiguous. It is clear that Lyautey, in light of his monarchist and aristocratic tendencies, saw in the preservation of the indigenous elite and the sharifian dynasty, though subservient to the French, a strategic alliance. Lyautey sought a compliant monarch and quickly pressured Sultan

Abd al-Hafiz to abdicate, foisting Mawlay al-Yusuf, a more passive monarch, into his place.
Whether by circumstance or design—and perhaps against Lyautey's intentions—the French military and civilian officials soon undermined any pretense of indirect rule as the practical realities of ruling Morocco unfolded in the first years of the Protectorate. While Lyautey may have desired to see the Moroccan governing authorities (Makhzan) become an effective public service, minimizing the need and expense of direct French intervention, increasingly the Makhzan's real power was reduced and made subordinate to French officials. For similarly practical reasons, the French did confer authority to the “great qā

ids,” especially the powerful Si Thami Glawi. In exchange for equipment and recognition of their status that predated the Protectorate, the qā

ids at times maintained ruthless authority and control over vast regions in the south that the French were still unable to penetrate.
Even if France wanted to rapidly “pacify” all of Morocco, Gershovich demonstrates how the distinctive methods of colonial warfare, especially as it applied to Morocco, preferred whenever possible “political” over “military” penetration, attempting to accommodate dissident tribesmen to colonial rule by selectively distributing benefits such as medical treatment. Military concerns in Europe took precedence over the colonies, which put constraints on metropole involvement. Some of the most interesting parts of the book analyze, against the background of political events in France and Europe, the complicated negotiations and conflicts among the military in Morocco, Lyautey, and France over the implementation of military rule in Morocco. To minimize expense and spare French lives, Lyautey deployed, whenever possible, local, irregular levies, incorporated into auxiliary and regular formations (the groupe mobile). Lyautey's famed “peaceful penetration” was, as Gershovich demonstrates, a complicated affair, which in reality was very costly both in terms of expense and loss of life. Increasingly it was the Moroccan recruits rather than the French who were fighting the Moroccan resistance.
It took France more than two decades to subdue the “dissident” regions of Morocco, where the French military suffered a number of major setbacks. The abandonment of the Tafilalet in 1918 signaled a strategy to divide Morocco between regions classified as “useful” under direct rule and “nonuseful” areas that would not require direct control. The illusion that Morocco had been pacified, in accordance with this new division, was challenged by the Rif war in 1925.
Gershovich covers familiar ground on the French conquest of Morocco but succeeds in retelling the story through new analytical lenses. New ground is broken, however, in his discussion of the Moroccan soldiers who fought for the French, the focus of chapter 6. The establishment of the Protectorate led to the disbanding of the ineffective sharifian army and the creation of the new Moroccan Auxiliary Troops, who soon embarked to Europe to fight on the German front during World War I. Thousands of Moroccan troops fought on the front line in France during World War II, and Moroccan regiments continued to serve the French military overseas in Madagascar and Indochina. One of the most fascinating discussions is on the mixed goums, the small irregular units of North African troops led by a small contingent of French personnel. These Moroccan soldiers, increasingly drawn from Berbers of the Atlas, played a significant role in the last stage of Morocco's “pacification” and continued to serve the French in the countryside until the last days of colonial rule. The growing defection of these seemingly loyal Berber goumiers to the resistance hastened the decision of France to end its effort to control Morocco militarily, leading to political compromise and Moroccan independence in 1956.
This discussion of Moroccan soldiers in the French military complicates the picture of the colonizer and colonized. One of the lasting effects of French colonialism was the military legacy of Moroccans in French uniforms. A military academy for Moroccan officer cadets, established in Meknes in 1919, remained a central institution in independent Morocco. And despite their service to the French (or, rather, because of it), many soldiers were integrated into the Moroccan armed forces. Indeed, as Gershovich argues, the royal family depended on them to establish its hegemony: “devoid of nationalist credibility, they became dependent upon the patronage of the king to shield them from the mistrust and envy of nationalist-oriented colleagues and rivals” (p. 214). Gershovich convincingly argues that the submission of former dissident tribes to French rule contributed to the creation of a cohesive postcolonial national entity.
Gershovich has amassed considerable evidence in support of his thesis, culling from the major colonial and Protectorate archives. Missing somewhat from the picture is the Moroccan side of the story of resistance to French military rule. As the author is well aware, this can probably be told only through unpublished writings and oral testimonies located throughout the Moroccan countryside. We learn from Philip Khoury's foreword to the book that Gershovich's current research seeks to recover the voices of Moroccan veterans of the French military in Morocco. Such a study would add to the picture already so well portrayed in this informative book.