Since China joined the World Trade Organization (WTO) in 2001, there have been a number of books published on the implications of China’s WTO membership for China and the rest of the world. Esther Lam’s China and the WTO: A Long March Towards the Rule of Law is the newest addition to this body of literature. What seems to distinguish Lam’s work from other books is that she focuses on the impact of WTO requirements on the reform of China’s legal system.
The eight chapters of the book are divided into three parts. Part I, consisting of chapters one and two, deal with China’s pre-WTO legal history. Chapter one examines the core features of the imperial Chinese legal traditions. Largely based on T’ung-Tsu Ch’u’s book, Law and Society in Traditional China,Footnote 1 chapter one describes the “basic features of the traditional Chinese legal system” as (a) “a secondary role of law in society”; (b) law “merely as a means to an end”; (c) “insignificant individual rights”; (d) a non-litigious society; and (e) no separation of powers (pp. 9–13). It then goes on to examine the legal reforms in the early twentieth century, concluding that there is “a theoretical deficit in traditional Chinese legal history”. Chapter two examines the evolution of the Chinese legal system between 1949 and 2001. Following the conventional wisdom, it divides the pre-PRC legal history into two stages, namely the pre-reform period from 1949 to 1978, and the reform era from 1978 to the present day. Instead of giving a systematic account of the basic characteristics of the Chinese legal system in the respective periods, chapter two mainly explains certain concepts such as the “socialist market economy” as well as the role played by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) in China’s post-Mao legal reform.
Although there is nothing very new in chapters one and two with respect to China’s legal history, part I still provides a useful background for understanding the impact of WTO membership on China’s legal culture. On this basis, part II, comprising chapters three, four, and five, examines the “motivations, process and challenges” in China’s “Long March to the WTO” (p. 45). In general, the value of part II lies in the author’s interviews with WTO officials and national trade representatives who personally witnessed China’s WTO accession process. Some of the interviews might be helpful in ascertaining the intentions of the Chinese and foreign negotiators when it comes to the interpretation of relevant provisions in China’s WTO accession documents in trade disputes involving China.
Part III, consisting of chapters six to eight, forms the centrepiece of this book. It purports to examine “the long-term impact of China’s WTO membership on the development of the Chinese legal system” (p. 117). Chapter six studies examples of legal development in two areas: both the revised foreign trade law and the newly made administrative licensing law have redefined the relationship between the market and the government by shifting more power and legally guaranteed rights to private citizens. Chapter seven proceeds to assess the implementation of four WTO-induced rule of law principles in China, namely, due process and procedural fairness, transparency, equality, and justiciability of government actions. For each principle, it identifies the legislative changes, and then uses selected cases and executive actions to prove that there are improvements in the respective area. Finally, chapter eight aims to present the challenges ahead, namely the opportunities and risks in China’s legal reform. It, however, is more of an extension of the substantive discussion in the preceding chapter, as it brings up fresh issues such as the new property law, political legitimacy, social unrests, etc. It concludes with cautious optimism that China will continue to move on the rule-based approach under the influence of the WTO.
The book, if characterized as a legal work, has several weaknesses. First, like any scholarship of this kind, this book faces an inherent dilemma in that it is almost impossible to prove that the major legal changes in China’s post-WTO period have been induced by the country’s WTO accession. In fact, China embarked on market-oriented legal reform long before it acquired WTO membership. One would wonder what would happen to China’s legal system had China not joined the WTO, but certainly could not exclude the possibility that the same WTO-consistent legal reforms would have been implemented thanks to a growing market economy and citizens’ demand for more legal rights (even in the absence of WTO membership). That is to say, merely presenting the facts of legal changes in the post-WTO period is not sufficient to support the conclusion that they are WTO-induced reforms. Second, the discussions of the rule of law in this book lack a coherent analytical framework. It puts together a variety of different definitions of and theories on the rule of law without reconciling their differences—and even conflicts. This seriously undermines the analytical value of the book, which seems to follow a prescriptive approach with respect to legal development in China. Third, relying on legislative changes and selected cases to prove the improvement of the Chinese legal system might be a bit artificial, especially when no efforts are made to establish that those changes and cases are representative of mainstream legal development in China. Fourth, the book obviously fails to include in its reference—and presumably scope of research—some of the classic works on China and the WTO published in China and overseas.
On the whole, the book, written by a former journalist, offers a useful examination of the historical changes in the legal area of China around the country’s WTO accession. In fact, it is the first systematic account of China’s WTO accession process and the legal development thereafter. Some of the previously undisclosed facts together with the insightful observations made by the author and her interviewees have certainly enriched the literature on the negotiating history of China’s WTO accession.
