In 1637 Anna Maria van Schurman, an accomplished scholar, wrote to André Rivet, “in the history of great expanses of time, the memorials to women's names are no more in evidence than the traces left by a ship crossing the ocean.” Carol Pal sets out to trace a more lasting memorial in The Republic of Women, by reconstructing the evidence for a set of multinational intellectual networks that included women, operating for about thirty years in the middle of the seventeenth century. This book is, on the one hand, a collective biography of a number of scholars: Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia, Anna Maria van Schurman, Marie de Gournay, Marie du Moulin, Dorothy Moore, Katherine Jones (Lady Ranelagh), and Bathsua Makin. These women, despite differences in nationality and in social class, became known to one another and formed intersecting networks of philosophical, scientific, and educational reform. Pal aims to convince us that they were not dabblers, “learned ladies,” or salonnières, but scholars, whose systems of intellectual exchange are an important part of the evidence for their seriousness, and she succeeds. Pal does not overstate her case, allowing that women were too few in number to constitute an intellectual epicenter (11), and recognizing that there has always been female scholarship; but, as she says, if “female scholarship was a constant—female scholarly communities were not” (263).
On the other hand, this book is an argument for the importance of forms of work other than publication in print. Pal starts with two questions: (1) How did this community of female scholars come into being? and (2) How did we lose the historical knowledge of its existence? Her answer to the first question involves an exploration of the practices of intellectual labor in the republic of letters. She identifies four: correspondence, networking, publication, and mentorship. Each of these practices allowed for the exchange of ideas and contacts, and together they constituted the work of a scholar in the seventeenth century. What distinguishes this book is that it moves the focus away from publication, and toward those practices more easily lost to the historical record. Pal is particularly interested in what the learned correspondence of women scholars reveals, not only about the role of letters in the development of intellectual reform, but also about the practices of mentorship and networking. While some of these women published their work (e.g., van Schurman, Gournay), others played an active part in intellectual networks and yet never published. Pal points out that Ranelagh's work, for example, “was identified, translated, excerpted, copied and distributed widely throughout the international community served by scribal publication [i.e., distribution through manual copying and personal networks]” (175). The practice of scribal publication was as important, she suggests, as printed literature in this period.
In the inclusion of women in scholarly communities, Pal sees a pattern: first, certain women were identified as individuals of learning and accomplishment; second, they came to the attention of supportive men already ensconced in a learned network; and third, the women became aware of and engaged with one another. It is clear that mutual expressions of respect, and in some cases acts of mentoring and encouragement, passed between these women. At the same time, there is considerable evidence that inclusion in intellectual networks required the support of at least one powerful man, and that women were more likely to be included if they held some prestige or were connected to men of power. And while men might be privately supportive, they could nonetheless be publicly dismissive of learned women (e.g., Rivet and Montaigne privately supported Schurman and Gournay, but in published works distanced themselves from the cause of women). Pal details the complexities of the relations among these women and between them and their male peers.
The answer to the second question is more speculative, but equally convincing. Pal tries to explain why lists of accomplished and virtuous women survived, while the historical record of this community of women scholars was lost. She suggests that “what we have come to know as the history of intellectual change has in many ways been the history of intellectual institutions instead,” and that the exclusion of women from these institutions is responsible for the loss of knowledge of their community (279). As she points out, the republic of letters did not offer women either a home or a profession in the way that a man might find both in, for example, a university (63, 207). The consequence of this exclusion has been that women were not claimed for the histories of science, education, ecumenism, and (we might add) philosophy, and so their contributions, individual and collective, have not been recognized.
In choosing to focus on the concrete practices of intellectual labor in which these women engaged, rather than the ideas that they intended to circulate by means of these practices, Pal illuminates the structures of intellectual work in the seventeenth century, and explains how it was possible for women to be both included and excluded, influential and yet forgotten. That is an important contribution to our knowledge of the work and lives of early modern women scholars. But the focus on material means and relationships also leads to an emphasis on the practical over the theoretical, which obscures some of the preoccupations and some of the accomplishments of these scholars. So, for example, Pal claims that for van Schurman and other women scholars sex was an instrumental problem, one that might be an obstacle to the pursuit of the scholarly life, but was not itself a subject of theoretical interest. She suggests that for women scholars the question was not what metaphysical or moral justification there might be for the education of women or their inclusion in ecclesiastical or political governance: “sex was not … the primary consideration for any of the women” (9, 66). Although it may not have been the primary consideration, it certainly was an important one, addressed explicitly by, for example, van Schurman and Gournay in their published work. That the female sex shared in a capacity for reason and virtue, and an expectation of eternal life—in other words that the nature of women was not fundamentally different from that of men in these respects—was crucially important. To believe that, and to offer evidence for it, was a necessary foundation for any claim to an entitlement to education, or to participation in the governance or reform of the church. When, for example, Dorothy Moore raises the question of the justice of excluding women from education, the debate has to begin with the nature of women, their capacities, and the intentions of God in creating them, before it can move to practical questions—whether the education of women would be a social benefit, or whether education was compatible with the domestic duties of women (138).
Pal does not, I think, dispute this, but wants to insist that practical concerns, about education, and the correct conduct of a life, motivate the more abstract or philosophical questions about sexual difference, and are primary in that sense. In taking the trouble to look beyond works in print, and to examine the correspondence for what it tells us about the concrete practices of intellectual activity and the complex and intersecting relationships among these women and between them and their male peers, Pal reveals subtleties and ambivalences in their intellectual, religious, and political affiliations. This book leaves us with a richer sense both of the individuals and of the structures of intellectual exchange that bound them into a community.
