In order to avoid accusing a book of this genre of being something which it is not and does not intend to be, we must be clear in presenting the nature, purposes, and idea behind it and the circumstances that convinced the author that such a volume was needed. In this case, W.'s book originated from a series of lessons he gave on the Near East from Alexander to Muhammad. He felt that the students needed an easy-to-read reference book able to provide the fundamentals of this vast and complex period over an equally vast and complex area, to make his students familiar with the main issues and themes before attending more specific lectures (xvi). All those who have taught Classical Near East modules have had to face similar problems, typically solving them by suggesting one or more valid and fundamental monographs on the subject. None among these, though, from the more specific and chronologically limited like Millar's,Footnote 1 to the more general and inclusive,Footnote 2 to those more oriented toward archaeologyFootnote 3 or cultural history seem to have matched precisely what the author had in mind to prepare his students. More than in the region's political history, W. was interested in the history and evolution of the communities of people who populated it in the extended period, communities that adopted through the centuries different cultures and ways of life and political and social institutions, and that changed the appearance of their cities accordingly.
This book, therefore, will be extremely useful for students and young scholars approaching the Classical and post-Classical Near East for research purposes, or more experienced scholars who, due to their specific research interests, need to acquire a general knowledge regarding the origins and development of the cities in the Near East from Alexander to the Islamic period. In fact, these are the protagonists of the volume: the cities of the Near East and, in general, the introduction of a form of urban settlement from the West, which, through its development in the following millennium, changed the history and society of the area radically.
Only with the Macedonian conquest of the East, and with the extensive city founding (or refounding) activity that followed, did the Greek city and its particular forms of political self-government and the right to administrate a carefully delimited portion of territory become the institutional brick used by the Seleucid and then the Roman Empire to establish solid control over such a vast, composite, and multicultural region. This situation changed with the affirmation of the religious elites in the Late Roman and Byzantine period and later with Islam's arrival. The new protagonists responsible for the cities' organization and appearance were thus the provincial political officers and the emerging Christian clergy. The decline of the Eastern cities and the abandonment or reuse of their “Classical” buildings did not occur with the Islamic conquest, as was thought in the past, but took place long before and gradually increased through Late Antiquity and the Byzantine period, mainly due to the significant loss of population. Therefore, the coming of Islam did not abruptly put an end to the “Eastern Classical City” but reshaped it, reorganizing its spaces according to new rulers and their beliefs.
Unlike all previous manuals on the ancient Near East, W. has chosen to consider an extensive period: from Alexander's conquest to the collapse of the Umayyads (750 CE), maintaining at the same time the aim of providing students with the basic knowledge needed. Therefore, the resulting approach considers the significant changes in the Near Eastern cities' organization and evolution, leaving aside “the minutiae of scholarly and archaeological debate” (xvii). Since his main focus is on cities' lives, to avoid sacrificing the text's simplicity to deal with the many Near Eastern urban centers, W. chose eight exemplary cases discussed in four pairings. Before examining the specific cases, he introduces the basics of the topic, dealing in general with urban planning and development, and presenting and discussing the main types of public and private buildings.
The first pair of selected cities are Antiochia and Apamea on the Orontes in north Syria. Both are early Greek foundations, and both lie in the middle of one of the most prosperous agricultural territories of the Near East. Both underwent a process of monumentalization, which is considered the best expression of Greco-Roman rule over Eastern cities. Nevertheless, some differences emerge between these two rival Greek centers. Antiochia, the seat of the Seleucid court and then the Roman governor, maintained leading political status among the cities. Its community shared a strong bond with the political authority that used it as an example, as a model for other cities. Thus, if the imperial rule in the 2nd c. CE promoted the monumentalization of the city after a disastrous earthquake with relevant financial support, in nearby Apamea it was the local leading classes who decided to rebuild the city at their own expense, following the capital's example.
The second couple, formed by Gerasa and Scythopolis, two cities of the Decapolis, represents the case of Greek cities with strong indigenous communities in and around them that changed throughout the centuries to become key regional settlements in the Islamic era. The third pair introduces Jerusalem and Caesarea, two Jewish cities with completely different histories. Jerusalem already had a long history before the arrival of Greeks and Romans, having been destroyed and become a Roman colony, and maintaining its key role as holy city in the Christian and Islamic periods. Caesarea was a creation of King Herod, a loyal servant of the Romans who wanted to create a Greco-Roman town in Judea. Conceived ex nihilo for the non-Jewish population of his kingdom, following the model of Western cities, it maintained a certain relevance under Byzantine rulers and played a pivotal role as a center of anti-Islamic resistance before losing its importance in the following period.
Finally, the last set of cities explores the desert fringes, at the limits of Roman territorial control: Nabatean Petra and Palmyra. Both towns arose from the gradual settlement of nomadic inhabitants of the desert steppe at the periphery of intensely settled areas. Both developed quickly under the influence of the Roman state's authority following the urban model of Western Classical cities applied to the specific environmental, social, and cultural conditions that characterized them. Petra's importance faded with its inclusion in the Roman Empire, whereas the same event boosted Palmyra's wealth until its political apogee. Reduced to a regional capital and a military base in Late Antiquity, Palmyra embraced its fate as a regional trade center after the Islamic conquest, experiencing a process of slow abandonment.
W.'s book is a story of the Near East told by cities, with cities as the protagonists. Eight cities grouped into couples sharing similar characteristics but distinguished by some key elements are compared in their development and history, a sort of parallel lives of cities. The result recalls the narrative tool employed and made famous by the novelist W. Faulkner: different characters provide a specific point of view on the events to give the reader an all-around comprehension of the plot. The plot here is the story of the Near East from Alexander to Muhammad.
