Roughly 56,000 Union and Confederate soldiers perished in prison camps during the Civil War and their suffering came to symbolize one of the most contentious aspects of the war's memory. In Haunted by Atrocity, Benjamin Cloyd unfolds the contested memories of Union and Confederate prisoners plus the often overlooked emancipationist interpretation of African Americans. Cloyd develops the particular usefulness of the prison controversy both as a sleeve of the Republican “bloody shirt” campaign in the North and as a potent defensive tactic for the Southern “Lost Cause.” In contrast to these divisive political and social uses, African Americans first interpreted POW sacrifice as a heroic corollary to emancipation celebrations in the immediate postwar years, and by the 1880s survivors extolled the same theme of heroism.
Thus, conflation of emancipationist and heroic themes was possible by the 1880s as witnessed by Memorial Day celebrations at Andersonville, sponsored by the Grand Army of the Republic, and attended by large gatherings of African Americans. Cloyd remarks that “African Americans ignored the social disapproval” of white Southerners, but he might further explain how this “memory coalition” of Union veterans and African Americans was eventually disrupted (p. 76). The implication looms that Jim Crow laws were responsible, but the author missed an excellent opportunity to further analyze the construction and dissolution of collective memory.
Large-scale atrocities in twentieth-century wars forced Americans and, for the first time, professional historians to reinterpret Civil War prisons. William Hesseltine's thesis of “war psychosis” symbolized an attempt to comprehend the inhumane treatment of Civil War POWs in the context of modern examples. Combined with popular interpretations like Mackinlay Kantor's Andersonville, Americans were ready for a less sectional but more objective version of the prison controversy. After 1960 Cloyd asserts that Americans were prepared for a non-contentious consumption of the prison controversy. The author admits that “commercialization of Civil War prisons did not begin in the early 1960s, but the celebration of the Civil War Centennial represented a unique opportunity to turn memories of the conflict into profit” (p. 144). It might have been useful to explore consumerism's effect on prison memory in earlier chapters as well, especially the market for survivor reminiscences. Cloyd remarks that “the desire to make a profit” might have motivated authors in the 1880s and 1890s, which leads to the question—was this market a perpetuating factor that kept this topic in the collective memory so long (p. 58)? The 56,000 inhumane deaths might be reason enough to keep the memory alive, but Americans have satisfactorily reasoned away other shameful episodes from the collective national memory, especially non-profitable ones.
By the end of the twentieth century, widespread sectional animosity waned as recent
American generations consumed a safe, sanitized, and objective version of Civil War prisons. This phenomenon might simply be linked to the adage that “time heals all wounds,” but Cloyd wisely asserts that this objectification distorts historical memory. The author admits that “the sectional wounds of the Civil War prison tragedy can be considered almost fully healed,” but also warns that this phenomenon can be “sadly unsatisfactory at best and misleading at worst” because responsibility for the atrocity is minimized (pp. 177–78). In this case, reconciliation can not absolve the Civil War generation of its most egregious example of inhumanity.
Cloyd's work is the finest historiographical treatment of the Civil War prison controversy to date. Andersonville dominates the narrative, but the thesis is carefully constructed and easily applied to the overall prison controversy. At times, the organization gets a bit predictable but this minor criticism is more than overcome by a detailed historiographical approach and consistently decisive analysis. Professor Cloyd contributes a vital addition to the ever growing catalog of “Civil War memory” scholarship and Haunted by Atrocity is a must-read for students of the prison controversy.
