Fransesco Bestagno and Luca Rubini have compiled articles written for and presented to a workshop organized by ASERI (Alta Scuola di Economia e Relazioni Internazionali), the Graduate School of Economics and International Relations of the Catholic University, Milan, held in December 2009. In this edited volume, concepts of development, environmental protection, climate change, and the use and distribution of natural resources are discussed to explain the challenges faced by Asian countries in promoting sustainable development. The inter- and intra-relationships of major economic players in Asia—namely India, China, and Southeast Asia—are examined to address the complexity of rules, actors, and issues at different levels of governing development processes in this dynamic region.
Principally, the book consists of five chapters. After the “Introduction”, the first chapter provides an interesting discussion of the responses of Indian courts in environmental cases. The openness of the Indian courts to international sources of law and to existing legal precedents explains their responsive and progressive rulings. At the same time, such an appreciated characteristic of the courts is also approached carefully by exposing the lack of consistency in laying down the law and questioning the political cost that may rise from the involvement of the courts in changing policies and regulations. Further, the author also argues how the courts’ jurisprudences may have significance for the Indian position in international negotiations of global climate change.
The second chapter explains the Chinese view on the internationally declared right to development. In this chapter, the author gives a favourable observation regarding the realization of the right to development in China. Political support to this right is given, since the right can be used as an important instrument to rebalance civil and political rights, and economic, social, and cultural rights. While much of the explanation revolving around the prominent role of economic development has been deemed as the very foundation for the realization of the right to development, the idea of human-centred development through participation as stipulated in the Declaration on the Right to Development is cautiously discussed.
The increasing role of China in international trade is examined in the third chapter. This chapter details the historical trajectory of China's accession to the World Trade Organization (WTO), which describes how China was treated neither as a developing nor a developed country. Peculiar terms are applied by the WTO, resulting in longer and complex negotiations. The adaptability and complexity of the actors in domestic politics and changing development priorities are presented by the author as significant factors that contribute to the country's behaviour in the global trade system, such as the WTO, and to its position as one of the world's biggest economies.
A critical challenge in financing ecological sustainability is addressed in the fourth chapter. The argument in this chapter is built up from the principle of sustainable development in international law, which forms the key pillar for negotiations of financing development, including the management of natural resources. Besides the magnitude of the current ecological impacts of development, the crucial issue is to carefully observe the obstacles and limitations faced by countries in constructing national strategies that satisfy the principle of sustainable development. Further, the author also argues that balancing the right of countries to exploit their natural resources with responsibility for the ecological basis for human survival need a combination of local and global policies.
The fifth chapter focuses on the relationship between China and Southeast Asian countries, institutionalized within the framework of ACFTA (ASEAN-China Free Trade Area). Through an examination of the regulations and procedures adopted by ACFTA, the author concludes that the amount of trade liberalization may be assessed as modest. The latest developments suggest that utilization of the agreed tariff preferences, for example, are low as actors prefer to maintain preference lists. The lack of attention of policy-makers and negotiators as to whether or not adopted regulations and procedures are susceptible to a national context may be the reason for the protracted liberalization process.
On the whole, the book is written to highlight the contemporary challenges of development in Asia from the perspective of international political economy. Law, particularly international law, plays an important part. The importance of rules and regulations and their selective interpretations are repeatedly analyzed through an interdisciplinary lens, hence readers with no legal background will still able to follow the arguments and issues.
The intricacy of the problems and the behaviour of the actors at a national level are presented as more or less the main focus of the challenges in most of the articles. Because of this, Asia is an attractive kaleidoscope with its diverse actors whose roles are increasingly shaping the global economy. As acknowledged, Asia is more than China, India, and Southeast Asia. Moreover, questions such as civil and political freedoms in development policy-making and access to basic necessities may also deliver discussions on the plurality of culture and power relationships between different actors in Asia. Nevertheless, this book has contributed interesting discussions in exposing different uncertainties which exist between the means and the ends of development processes. Ultimately, despite its simple label, development is an immensely complex issue which, as rightly proposed in this book, requires an understanding of institutional arrangements between actors and the effects of their actions on the structural progress of people to sustain their daily livelihoods.
