Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T08:11:41.910Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Difference reductions and period doubling in the aerodynamics of two tandem foils flapping near a boundary layer

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 March 2026

Chihao Lin
Affiliation:
School of Science, Harbin Institute of Technology , Shenzhen 518055, PR China
Pan Jia*
Affiliation:
School of Science, Harbin Institute of Technology , Shenzhen 518055, PR China
Zheng Zhong*
Affiliation:
School of Science, Harbin Institute of Technology , Shenzhen 518055, PR China
*
Corresponding authors: Pan Jia, jiapan@hit.edu.cn; Zheng Zhong, zhongzheng@hit.edu.cn
Corresponding authors: Pan Jia, jiapan@hit.edu.cn; Zheng Zhong, zhongzheng@hit.edu.cn

Abstract

This work studies the aerodynamics of two tandem foils flapping near a boundary layer (BL). The interaction between the tandem foils and the BL is modulated by the foil-to-wall distance rescaled by the foil chord length ($H_0/c$) and the Reynolds number based on free stream velocity (${\textit{Re}}=U_{\infty }c/\nu$). Taking the single foil under the same configuration as the reference, difference reductions are observed in forces between either of the tandem foils and the single foil, due to the weakened coupling between tandem foils in the presence of the BL. For a similar reason, it is revealed that, as ${\textit{Re}}$ increases, the force evolutions of the hind foil increasingly resemble those of the fore foil, being a second difference reduction. When examining the system’s evolution, we find that, in some cases, the evolution period of the force and the wake flow doubles that of the flapping cycle. From the Lagrangian coherent structures, it is indicated that this period doubling occurs because, in these cases, only one of two trailing edge vortices, shed in two successive cycles, is convected downstream, while the other is trapped and eventually dissipated in the BL. This interpretation has also been well confirmed by the frequency response from the modal analysis. In the cases with period doubling, the effect of the BL is relatively weak, corresponding to a coupling-dominated mode of interaction. Additionally, BL-dominated mode (low ${\textit{Re}}$ and/or low $H_0/c$) and foil-dominated mode (high ${\textit{Re}}$ and/or high $H_0/c$) are also identified, where the period doubling is not present anymore, respectively because of the strong BL effect and its absence. Finally, a bifurcation analysis is conducted to explore the dynamical nature of the system’s evolution. As $H_0/c$ increases, the system first undergoes a flip bifurcation, leading to the period doubling due to the decaying BL effect; and then an inverse period doubling bifurcation occurs, corresponding to a transition from coupling-dominated to foil-dominated interaction mode. If taking ${\textit{Re}}$ as the bifurcation parameter, a flip bifurcation is also first observed, sharing the same physical picture as the flip bifurcation identified when increasing $H_0/c$. Further increasing ${\textit{Re}}$, the system will undergo a Neimark–Sacker bifurcation due to the nonlinear nature of the convective flow, and the evolution of the system transitions from period doubling to quasi-periodic state.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.(a) Computational domain and boundary conditions for the present tandem flapping foils configuration. (b) Two sets of meshes used in the immersed boundary-lattice Boltzmann method: a fixed Eulerian mesh for the flow field and a dynamic Lagrangian mesh for the moving solid boundaries immersed in the fluid. (c) Schematic of the tandem flapping foils interacting with the BL (shown in grey) at a stationary, flat and no-slip wall. This schematic corresponds to an enlarged view of region framed by the red dashed frame in panel (a). The locations and orientations of the foils during the downstroke and upstroke phases are denoted by black solid and red dashed lines, respectively. Please note that these schematics are not to scale for a clear view.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Validations of the present numerical method and the custom-made code. Comparisons of the present calculations with the reported data for the tandem flapping-fixed aerofoil configuration of Wu et al. (2022) for the drag coefficients of (a) the fore foil and (b) the hind fixed foil during one flapping cycle, where the distance between two foils is $3c$ in the flow direction, with a zero attack angle for the hind fixed foil. Curve conventions are given in panel (a) for both panels.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Validations of the present numerical mesh. Temporal evolution of the fore foil and hind foil drag coefficients over one flapping period for different mesh spacing of the lattice at ${\textit{Re}}=200, \, H_0/c=1.5$. Drag coefficients for (a) fore foil and (b) hind foil are shown. Curve colour conventions are given in panel (a) for both panels.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Evolution of the lift coefficient and near-wall vorticity fields for tandem foils interacting with a viscous BL and under the pure ground effect, at $H_0/c = 1.0$ and ${\textit{Re}} = 100$. (a) Lift coefficient $C_l$ of the hind foil. Normalised vorticity fields ($\omega c / U_\infty$) at the beginning of the flapping cycle for (b) the pure ground effect case and (c) the tandem foils–BL interaction case.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Comparisons of $C_l$ and $C_d$ between the tandem foils configuration and the single foil configuration. Temporal evolution of the lift and drag coefficients over one flapping cycle after the system reaches the statistically steady state for ${\textit{Re}}=100$, $H_0/c=0.8$ and $6.0$. The lift coefficient $C_l$ is shown for (a) fore foil and (b) hind foil; the drag coefficient $C_d$ is shown for (c) fore foil and (d) hind foil. Dashed lines in each panel correspond to $C_l$ and $C_d$ of the single foil as a reference. At the top of each column, the location and orientation of the foils during one flapping cycle are schematically indicated, corresponding to the time points labelled on the horizontal axis, with the leading edge on the left. Curve conventions are defined in panel (a) and apply to all panels.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Normalised vorticity fields ($\omega c / U_\infty$) for specific time points when ${\textit{Re}}=100$: (a) single foil, $H_0/c=6.0, \,t/T=0.20$; (b) tandem foils, $\,H_0/c=6.0,\,t/T=0.20$; (c) single foil, $H_0/c=0.8,\,t/T=0.80$; (d) tandem foils, $H_0/c=0.8,\,t/T=0.80$. The dash frames in each panel is appended to indicate the lower part of the shed vortex.

Figure 6

Table 1.Force coefficients differences evaluated by the square of the 2-norm when comparing to the corresponding case of a single foil.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Temporal evolution of the lift and drag coefficients over one flapping cycle after the system reaches the statistically steady state for various $H_0/c$ at ${\textit{Re}}=10$, 100 and 500. Each column represents a specific force for tandem foils: (a, e, i) fore foil $C_l$; (b, f, j) hind foil $C_l$; (c, g, k) fore foil $C_d$; and (d, h, l) hind foil $C_d$. In panels (e–h), capital letters are appended to label the turning points. At the top of each column, we have also schematically indicated the location and orientation of the foil in one flapping cycle, corresponding to the time point labelled on the horizontal axis, with the leading edge on the left. Curve conventions are defined in panel (a) and apply to all panels. Please see also supplementary movie 1 for ${\textit{Re}} = 100$ and supplementary movie 2 for ${\textit{Re}} = 500$ both at $H_0/c = 0.8$, available at https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2026.11242.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Average force coefficients $\overline {C}_l$ and $\overline {C}_d$ as a function of the rescaled distance to the wall $H_0/c$ for various of Reynolds numbers ranging from 10 to 500: (a) fore foil $\overline {C}_l$; (b) hind foil $\overline {C}_l$; (c) fore foil $\overline {C}_d$ and (d) hind foil $\overline {C}_d$. In each panel, the dashed line is used to indicate the other average value related to the ‘period doubling’ of force evolution and the enlarged views are appended in panels (a, c, d) for clear illustrations. Grey background in panel (d) indicates the drag reduction zone. Curve conventions are defined in panel (a) and apply to all panels.

Figure 9

Figure 9.(a) Temporal evolution of the hind foil lift coefficients over two flapping periods at ${\textit{Re}}=500, \,H_0/c=1.0$ and 1.5. In panel (a), a dash line is used to indicate the differences observed in the peaks occurring in the two successive flapping cycles. (b) Average hind foil lift coefficients for successive flapping cycles at ${\textit{Re}}=500, \,H_0/c=1.0$ and 1.5. $N$ corresponding to the flapping cycle number.

Figure 10

Figure 10.FTLE fields at ${\textit{Re}}= 500$ and $H_0/c=0.8,\, 1.0$ and 1.5. The columns from left to right are (a–c) $H_0/c=0.8$, (d–f) $H_0/c=1.0$ and (g–i) $H_0/c=1.5$. Each row represents a specific instant with a time interval of one flapping cycle: (a, d, g) $t/T=0.0$; (b, e, h) $t/T=1.0$ and (c, f, i) $t/T=2.0$. The LCSs are revealed by the FTLE fields with a normalised integration time of $T_{{L}}/T=-2.0$ (negative time means backward integration). The contours of FTLE are plotted as regions of FTLE ${\gt } 0.2$ for the better view of the ridges of FTLE fields. The solid frames in panels (d–f) are appended to indicate the difference in the LCSs. Please see also supplementary movie 3.

Figure 11

Figure 11.FTLE fields at ${\textit{Re}}=500$, $H_0/c=1.0$ at specific time points $t/T$: (a) $t/T=0.04$; (b) $t/T=0.55$; (c) $t/T=1.00$; (d) $t/T=1.46$ and (e) $t/T=2.00$. LEVs and TEVs are indicated with ‘LEVx’ and ‘TEVx’ respectively and an arrow in blue and red in all panels, at a given time instant. Colour conventions are the same as those in figure 10. Please see also the supplementary movie 4.

Figure 12

Figure 12.FTLE fields for the case of the ${\textit{Re}}=500$ and $H_0/c=0.8$ at three specific time points: (a) $ t/T=0.36$; (b) $ t/T=0.80$ and (c) $ t/T=1.40$. LEVs and TEVs are indicated with ‘LEVx’ and ‘TEVx’ respectively and an arrow in blue and red in all panels, at a given time instant. Colour conventions are the same as those in figure 10. Please see also the supplementary movie 5.

Figure 13

Figure 13.(a) Phase diagram for the interaction mode in the parameter plane of ${\textit{Re}}-H_0/c$. The symbol conventions in the plots: BL-dominated mode (), foil-dominated mode () and coupling-dominated mode (). The dotted lines are appended to schematically indicate the borders of the three interaction modes. (b) Normalised boundary layer thickness $\delta /c$ at the locations of the fore foil ($x/c=20.0$) and the hind foil ($x/c=21.5$) for all ${\textit{Re}}$. We also append the Blasius laminar boundary layer solutions for comparisons. The orange background indicates the flapping range of the foils in the normal wall direction; here, only the farthest cases with $ H_0/c=6.0$ and the nearest case with $ H_0/c=0.8$ are shown.

Figure 14

Figure 14.(a) Computational domain for the DMD modes (light grey background) and the relative position of the tandem foils. The amplitude of DMD modes $|b_{k}|$ and their corresponding $\bar f$ at various of ${\textit{Re}}$ and $H_0/c$. (b) ${\textit{Re}}=10,\, H_0/c =1.0$, (c) ${\textit{Re}}=100,\, H_0/c =1.0$, (d) ${\textit{Re}}=500,\, H_0/c =0.8$, (e) ${\textit{Re}}=500,\, H_0/c =1.0$ and (f) ${\textit{Re}}=500,\, H_0/c =1.5$.

Figure 15

Figure 15.DMD modes of the vorticity ${\textit{Re}}=500$: (a, d, g) $H_0/c =0.8$; (b, e, h) $H_0/c =1.0$; and (c, f, i) $H_0/c =1.5$. Each column represent a specific DMD mode: (a–c) Mode 0, (d–f) Mode 1 and (g–i) Mode 2. The contours present the mode excluding the time coefficient, thus the colour encode the relative intensity of the vorticity. The DMD modes are selected with the respect to the frequency of the DMD modes. The amplitudes and frequencies corresponding to each mode are shown in the figure 14. The numbers in panels (d–f) represent the count of the shed vortex in the modes. In panel (b), the black dash line frame shows the region where the vorticity distribution is not continuous.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Bifurcation diagrams of the hind foil $\overline {C}_l$. (a) $\overline {C}_l$ at $H_0/c=1.0$ for different Reynolds numbers. (b) $\overline {C}_l$ at ${\textit{Re}}=500$ for different $H_0/c$. In both panels, the labels of P, PD and QP are respectively the abbreviations of periodic, period doubling and quasi-periodic. Dashed lines are the envelopes of the data points in period doubling and quasi-periodic regimes in both panels.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Time series analyses of the hind foil $C_l$ at $H_0/c=1.0$ and various ${\textit{Re}}$. (a–c) ${\textit{Re}}=100$, (d–f) ${\textit{Re}}=500$ and (g–i) ${\textit{Re}}=700$. The panels in the first column (a, d, g) show the logarithmic power spectral density for the frequency spectra; in the second column (b, e, h), reconstructed phase space; and in the third column (c, f, i), recurrence plots.

Figure 18

Table 2.Numerical parameters, from left to right: ${\textit{Re}}$, $H_0/c$ and the $\overline {C}_l$ and $\overline {C}_d$ for the fore foil, and $\overline {C}_l$ and $\overline {C}_d$ for the hind foil. The data marked with a grey background correspond to the cases with ‘period doubling’.

Supplementary material: File

Lin et al. supplementary movie 1

Temporal evolution of the force coefficients and the corresponding normalised vorticity field for Re=100 and H0/c=0.8.
Download Lin et al. supplementary movie 1(File)
File 3.6 MB
Supplementary material: File

Lin et al. supplementary movie 2

Temporal evolution of the force coefficients and the corresponding normalised vorticity field for Re=500 and H0/c=0.8.
Download Lin et al. supplementary movie 2(File)
File 4.4 MB
Supplementary material: File

Lin et al. supplementary movie 3

Temporal evolution of the FTLE fields for Re=500 and H0/c=0.8, 1.0 and 1.5.
Download Lin et al. supplementary movie 3(File)
File 10.4 MB
Supplementary material: File

Lin et al. supplementary movie 4

Temporal evolution of the force coefficients and the corresponding FTLE fields for Re=500 and H0/c=1.0.
Download Lin et al. supplementary movie 4(File)
File 10.6 MB
Supplementary material: File

Lin et al. supplementary movie 5

Temporal evolution of the force coefficients and the corresponding FTLE fields for Re=500 and H0/c=0.8.
Download Lin et al. supplementary movie 5(File)
File 10.3 MB
Supplementary material: File

Lin et al. supplementary movie 6

Temporal evolution of the force coefficients and the corresponding normalised vorticity field for Re=100 and H0/c=6.0.
Download Lin et al. supplementary movie 6(File)
File 3.8 MB
Supplementary material: File

Lin et al. supplementary movie 7

Temporal evolution of the force coefficients and the corresponding normalised vorticity field for Re=500 and H0/c=6.0.
Download Lin et al. supplementary movie 7(File)
File 4.8 MB