Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T05:03:59.030Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Instabilities and transition in cooled wall hypersonic boundary layers

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 March 2021

S. Unnikrishnan*
Affiliation:
Mechanical Engineering, Florida State University, Tallahassee, FL 32310, USA
Datta V. Gaitonde
Affiliation:
Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: usasidharannair@fsu.edu

Abstract

Wall cooling has substantial qualitative and quantitative effects on the development of instabilities and subsequent transition processes in hypersonic boundary layers (HBLs). A sequence of linear stability theory, nonlinear two-dimensional and three-dimensional direct numerical simulations is used to analyse Mach 6 boundary layers, with wall temperatures ranging from near-adiabatic to highly cooled conditions, where the second-mode instability is accompanied by radiation of energy. Decomposition of linear stability modes into their fluid-thermodynamic (acoustic, vortical and thermal) components shows that this radiation comprises both acoustic as well as vortical waves. Furthermore, in these cases, two-dimensional simulations show that the conventional ‘trapped’ nature of second-mode instability is ruptured. A quantitative analysis indicates that although the energy efflux of both acoustic and vortical components increases with wall cooling, the destabilization effect is much stronger and no significant abatement of pressure perturbations is realized. The direct impact of these mechanisms on the transition process itself is examined with high-fidelity simulations of three-dimensional second-mode wavepacket propagation. In the near-adiabatic HBL, the wavepacket remains trapped within the boundary layer and attenuates outside the region of linear instability. However, wavepackets in the cooled wall HBLs amplify and display nonlinear distortion, and transition more rapidly. The structure of the wavepacket also displays different behaviour; moderately cooled walls show bifurcation into a leading turbulent head region and a trailing harmonic region, while highly cooled wall cases display lower convection speeds and significant wavepacket elongation, with intermittent spurts of turbulence in the wake of the head region. This elongation effect is associated with a weakening of the lateral jet mechanism due to the breakdown of spanwise coherent structures. These features have a direct impact on wall loading, including skin friction and heat transfer. In moderately cooled walls, the spatially localized wall loading is similar to those in near-adiabatic walls, with dominant impact due to coherent structures in the leading turbulent head region. In highly cooled walls, the elongated near-wall streaks in the wake region of the wavepacket result in more than twice as large levels of skin friction and heat transfer over a sustained period of time.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Cases studied with varying degree of wall cooling.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Effect of wall cooling shown using similarity profiles of (a) streamwise velocity, (b) temperature and (c) function, F1. The arrows indicate the trends in the profiles with decreasing values of wall temperature. The profiles are plotted at a streamwise location, $x=2$. The vertical dashed line in (c) marks $F1=0$.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Loci of the unstable discrete mode obtained for the wave with $\lambda =0.025$. Green and red loci have their origins near the slow and fast continuous acoustic spectra, respectively. The horizontal dashed lines mark $c_i=0$. The vertical dashed–dotted lines on the left, centre and right mark the wave speeds, $(1-1/M_\infty )$, $1$ and $(1+1/M_\infty )$, respectively. The inset in (h) magnifies the region marked within the dashed rectangle. $(a)\ T_{W} = 7,\ (b)\ T_{W} = 5,\ (c)\ T_{W} = 3,\ (d)\ T_{W} = 1,\ (e)\ T_{W} = 0.7,\ (f)\ T_{W} = 0.5,\ (g)\ T_{W} = 0.3,\ (h)\ T_{W} = 0.1.$

Figure 3

Figure 3.Eigenspectrum in the vicinity of the peak amplification of the second mode for (a) $T_W=7$ and (b) $T_W=0.1$. The horizontal dashed lines mark $\omega _i=0$. The vertical dashed lines on the left, centre and right mark the circular frequencies corresponding to the wave speeds, $(1-1/M_\infty )$, $1$ and $(1+1/M_\infty )$, respectively. Variation in the amplification rate as the instability wavelength is varied uniformly in the range, $\lambda _0 - 0.01 \le \lambda \le \lambda _0 + 0.01$, for (c) $T_W=7$ and (d) $T_W=0.1$, in increments of $0.002$.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Absolute values of real and imaginary components of the pressure eigenfunction, $R(p')$, and $I(p')$, respectively, plotted at (a) $x=4.3$ – prior to synchronization and (b) $x=5$ – after synchronization. Profiles of various speed limits as indicated, plotted at (c) $x=4.3$ and (d) $x=5$. The vertical dashed–dotted lines in (c) and (d) mark the phase speed of the corresponding unstable wave.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Modulus of streamwise and wall-normal components of (a) vortical, (c) acoustic and (e) entropic constituents of the unstable eigenmode at $x=4.3$. Plots (b), (d) and ( f) show the corresponding results at $x=5$.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Streamwise variation of RMS values of wall-pressure perturbations for various cold walls. The dashed circle on the horizontal axis marks the streamwise location of the actuator.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Pressure perturbation contours highlighting the form of the second-mode instability for (a) $T_W=5$ and (b) $T_W=0.1$. The regions marked by the dashed rectangles in (a) and (b) are magnified in the respective insets, (a1) and (b1). Insets (a2) and (b2) plot the space-wavenumber, $x\text{--}\alpha$, variation in the pressure perturbation signal for $T_W=5$ and $T_W=0.1$, respectively, at a wall-normal location, $y \sim 0.008$. For reference, this location is marked with horizontal dashed arrows near the $y$-axes of insets (a1) and (b1).

Figure 8

Figure 8.Flux lines of the acoustic component, $(A_x',A_y')$, for (a) $T_W=5$ and (b) $T_W=0.1$. The contours represent the magnitude of the acoustic field.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Streamwise variation of (a) vortical and (b) acoustic efflux of energy from the HBLs, for various cold walls. The actuator is placed at the lower neutral limit.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Streamwise variation of RMS values of wall-pressure perturbations for various cold walls, with the actuator placed at the lower neutral limit.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Instantaneous vortical structures induced by the wavepacket, visualized using Q-criterion, coloured by $u$. Results obtained when the perturbations reach the exit of the computational domain in each case. Plots for (a) $T_W=7$, (b) $T_W=3$, (c) $T_W=0.5$ and (d) $T_W=0.1$. All panels display identical contour levels, as indicated in (a). $(a)\ T_{W} = 7,\ Q = 1,\ (b)\ T_{W} = 3,\ Q = 100,\ (c)\ T_{W} = 0.5, Q = 100,$$(d)\ T_{W} = 0.1, Q = 100.$

Figure 12

Figure 12.Streamwise distribution of wall-pressure perturbations at the indicated time instances for (a) $T_W=7$, (b) $T_W=3$, (c) $T_W=0.5$ and (d) $T_W=0.1$. The dashed inclined lines in (a), L01 and L7, trace the trailing edges of the wavepackets in $T_W=7$ and $T_W=0.1$, respectively, to estimate their convective speeds. $(a)\ p^{\prime}_{N}\ {\rm vs.}\ x_{NC}, T_{W} = 7,\ (b)\ p^{\prime}_{N} \ {\rm vs.}\ x_{NC}, T_{W} = 3,\ (c)\ p^{\prime}_{N} \ {\rm vs.}\ x_{NC},\ T_{W} = 0.5,$$(d)\ p^{\prime}_{N}\ {\rm vs.}\ x_{NC}, T_{W} = 0.1.$

Figure 13

Figure 13.Surface contours of wall-pressure perturbations at the indicated time instances. Plots (a,b,c) correspond to $T_W=3$. Plots (d,e, f) correspond to $T_W=0.1$. All panels display identical contour levels, as indicated in (a). $(a)\ T_{W} = 3,\ t_{{\rm o}} + 1,\ (b)\ T_{W} = 3,\ t_{{\rm o}} + 2,$$(c)\ T_{W} = 3,\ t_{{\rm o}} + 3,\ (d)\ T_{W} = 0.1,\ t_{{\rm o}} + 1, (e)\ T_{W} = 0.1,\ t_{{\rm o}} + 2,$$(f)\ T_{W} = 0.1,\ t_{{\rm o}} + 3.$

Figure 14

Figure 14.Spanwise wavenumber ($\beta$) spectrum obtained as a function of streamwise distance, at the indicated time instances. Plots (a), (c) and (e) correspond to $T_W=3$. Plots (b), (d) and ( f) correspond to $T_W=0.1$. In each panel, the half-plane of the spectral (vertical) axis is overlaid with the half-plane of the wall-pressure perturbations shown earlier in figure 13. Arrows A1 and A2 highlight relevant features in respective panels. All panels display identical contour levels, as indicated in (a).

Figure 15

Figure 15.Time-frequency signature of wavepacket evolution represented using scalograms of wall-pressure perturbations on the mid-span, at indicated streamwise locations. Plots (a), (c), (e) and (g) correspond to $T_W=3$. Plots (b), (d), ( f) and (h) correspond to $T_W=0.1$. The upper and lower dashed horizontal lines mark the forcing frequency and its subharmonic, $\omega = 150$ and $\omega = 75$, respectively. Arrows A1, A2, A3 and A4 highlight relevant features in respective panels. All panels display identical contour levels, as indicated in (a).

Figure 16

Figure 16.Spanwise wavenumber spectrum obtained as a function of time for (a) $T_W=3$ and (b) $T_W=0.1$, near the exit of the computational domain, $X_{NC}=4$. In each panel, the wavenumber spectrum is augmented with the corresponding pressure scalogram on the mid-span. Contour levels displayed are indicated in (a).

Figure 17

Figure 17.Physical structure of the turbulent spots generated in (a) $T_W=3$ and (b) $T_W=0.1$, as seen in primary views, visualized using Q-criterion, coloured by $u$. The two dashed lines in the top view of each panel mark a $4^{\circ }$ angle with the horizontal axis. All panels display identical contour levels, as indicated in (a).

Figure 18

Figure 18.(a) Contours of streamwise vorticity, $\omega _x$, as observed on the exit plane, $x_{NC}=4$, in the leading POD mode for $T_W=3$. (b) Spanwise wavenumber spectrum of the vorticity field, obtained as a function of wall-normal distance. Plots (c) and (d) show the corresponding results for $T_W=0.1$. The horizontal dashed lines in (a) and (c) mark the laminar boundary layer thickness, $\delta _{99}$. The arrows on the vertical axes in (b) and (d) mark $\delta _{99}$ and the location of the peak in the spanwise spectrum, $y_{\beta M}$. Panels (a) and (c) display identical contour levels, as indicated in (a). Panels (b) and (d) display identical contour levels, as indicated in (b). $(a,\, b)\ T_{W} = 3,\ (c,\, d)\ T_{W} = 0.1.$

Figure 19

Figure 19.Contours of spanwise velocity, $w$, as observed on the exit plane, $x_{NC}=4$, in the leading POD mode for (a) $T_W=3$ and (b) $T_W=0.1$. The region marked by the dashed rectangle in (a) is magnified in (c). The vector field in (c) corresponds to $(w,v)$, as defined in the leading POD mode. The arrow on the horizontal axis in (c) marks a vortex beneath the lateral jet. All panels display identical contour levels, as indicated in (a).

Figure 20

Figure 20.Chronogram of wall-pressure perturbations on the mid-span for (a) $T_W=3$, (b) $T_W=0.5$ and (c) $T_W=0.1$. The solid contour lines in (a), (b) and (c) trace the envelope of the evolving wavepackets. These three envelopes are overlaid in (d). Arrows A1, A2, A3 and A4 highlight relevant features in respective panels. Panels (a), (b) and (c) display identical contour levels, as indicated in (a).

Figure 21

Figure 21.(a) Temporal evolution of spanwise averaged skin friction coefficient, $c_f$, at $x_{NC} =4$, for various cold walls. Instantaneous near-wall contours of streamwise velocity for (b) $T_W=3$ and (c) $T_W=0.1$. Panels (b) and (c) display identical contour levels, as indicated in (b).

Figure 22

Figure 22.Temporal evolution of surface heat transfer coefficient, $c_h$, at $x_{NC} =4$, for (a) $T_W=3$, (b) $T_W=0.5$ and (c) $T_W=0.1$. The solid contour lines in (a) and (b) mark $c_f=0$. All panels display identical contour levels, as indicated in (a).

Figure 23

Figure 23.Results obtained for $T_W=0.1$, using the finer grid, G2. Physical structure of the turbulent spot visualized using Q-criterion, coloured by $u$ – view from the (a) top and (b) beneath. (c) Spanwise wavenumber spectrum obtained as a function of time, near the exit of the computational domain, $X_{NC}=4$. (d) Pressure scalogram on the mid-span at $X_{NC}=4$.