I. INTRODUCTION
The system of thought of Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations (WN hereafter) can be split into two ideal parts: one is focused on the theory of value and distribution (Book I), the other on the theory of capital and growth (Book II). While the first part is mainly built on the twofold view of value as labor embodied and labor commanded, the second part is mainly built on the twofold view of capital from the standpoint of either its individual owners or the whole society. The two parts are linked together by the interactions between the principles of self-interest and competition, on the one hand, and between the process of capital accumulation and the future of wages, on the other.Footnote 1
The aim of this paper is to focus on these interactions in an attempt to highlight the long-run relationships between the accumulation of capital and the demand for labor, and between the increase of population and the supply of labor. This will be done by singling out, first, the containment of the principle of self-interest (which, if pushed to excess, would lead all men to try to “reap where they never sowed,” WN, I.vi.8) by the principle of competition; and, then, the containment of the increase of population by the “uniform, constant, and uninterrupted effort of every man to better his condition” (WN, II.iii.31).
This aim will be pursued in six different steps. The first will consist in moving from the sentiments of sympathy and propriety discussed by Smith in his Theory of Moral Sentiments (TMS hereafter) to the principles of self-interest and competition as focused upon in his Wealth of Nations (section II). The second step will consist in moving from these principles to the determination of the exchangeable value of labor (section III), while the third step will consist in moving from the impact of the accumulation of capital on the “productive powers of labour” to the resulting possible increase of that exchangeable value (section IV). The fourth step is carried out in section V and constitutes the core of the paper. This step consists in providing three partial supports and one final adjustment of Smith’s theory of population in the light of the reproductive behavior of human beings in modern societies. As argued in the following section VI, this adjustment is needed for moving towards the link between the accumulation of capital (in its widening and deepening directions) and the long-run increase of wages as observed in the history of modern societies.
The paper’s conclusion is that, when the conditions under discussion are met, the accumulation of capital reappears as the ultimate cause of a long-run increase of wages in spite not only of the counter-interested behavior of “masters and manufacturers” but also of the tendency of population to increase beyond the means of its subsistence. This unexpected outcome is eventually regarded as just one of the “many other cases” alluded to by Smith in the frequently misunderstood passage on the individual who, though engaged in international trade exclusively for his own profit, “is led by an invisible hand to promote an end which was no part of his intentions” (WN, IV.ii.9).Footnote 2
II. FROM SYMPATHY AND PROPRIETY TO SELF-INTEREST AND COMPETITION
To understand the roles assigned to self-interest and competition in the Wealth of Nations, it may be useful to start from two shifts that keep apart this work from Smith’s Theory of Moral Sentiments. Footnote 3 One of these shifts goes from the sentiment of sympathy to the principle of self-interest, and the other goes from the propriety of that sentiment to the principle of competition between different individuals. Leaving aside a detailed discussion of these shifts,Footnote 4 this paper will start by highlighting the different roles assigned in WN to the two principles mentioned above. The first thing worth noticing in this connection is that, despite the important role assigned in WN to the principle of competition and despite the fact that the term “self-interest” is there used just once and is replaced by the term “self-love” only twice (see V.I.191 and I.2.2), the role assigned in the same work to the principle of self-interest is even more crucial than the role assigned in it to the other principle. The reason lies in the fact, highlighted by Smith in the first place, that the principle of self-interest is so strong that it may affect the implementation of the other principle along two completely different directions. While in one of these directions the principle of self-interest is used to reinforce the other principle in the process of production of national wealth, in the other completely different direction it rather serves to support the “abuses” and “monopolizing spirit” of “merchants and manufacturers” (not to speak of the “capricious ambition” of kings and ministers) when they try to persuade the public that “the private interest of a part, and of a subordinate part of the society, is the general interest of the whole” (IV.iii.38; I.x.80).Footnote 5
III. FROM SELF-INTEREST AND COMPETITION TO THE LABOR MARKET AND THE VALUE OF LABOR
The shift from the concepts of sympathy and propriety to the concepts of self-interest and competition is implicitly brought to the fore by Smith himself when he states, right at the beginning of WN, that “the annual labour of every nation is the fund which originally supplies it with all the necessaries and conveniences of life.” This statement implies that labor plays in the WN a more crucial role than even sympathy does in TMS. Footnote 6 It must be noted, however, that this role is somewhat obscured when, in the context of his theory of value, Smith comes to the further statement that “equal quantities of labour, at all time and places, may be said to be of equal value to the labourer”; and, even more so, when he moves on to the all-encompassing conclusion that “labour, therefore, never varying in its own value, is alone the ultimate and real standard by which the value of all commodities can at all times and places be estimated and compared” (WN, I.v.7; italics added).
The ambiguities of these passages lie in the term “value,” which is intended, in the first statement, as the constant “value to the labourer” of equal quantities of his own labor; whereas, in the following statement, it is intended as the varying “value of all commodities” as products of labor (which in turn is said to be “never varying in its own value”). These ambiguities have not been stressed in the literature as much as they would deserve.
Concerning the first ambiguity, it must be noted that the verbs “to purchase” and “to acquire” are used in that chapter as if they represented the purchase of something by one set of individuals from another. These expressions, however, should rather be intended as metaphors serving to highlight the vertically integrated process (as it is called in modern literature) by which the final output of today reappears as the result of the total labor employed in a near or a distant past. This is silently admitted by Smith himself when, in one of his sentences quoted in the previous footnote, the expression “wealth of the world” (not, therefore, the wealth of a particular country, individual, or group of individuals) is said to be “originally purchased” by labor, an expression that at this point must be understood exclusively in the sense that it was originally produced by labor.
Concerning the other ambiguities, it must be noted that the term “value” is used in the statements above in the sense of the “toil and trouble” experienced by the (average) laborer as the (negative) use value of his labor from his own standpoint; but it is also used in the sense of the (positive) exchange value of one product of labor in terms either of a different product, or (in the form of wage goods) of labor itself. Smith’s ambiguities reach here a climax in that his wording obscures not only his initial distinction between the elementary concepts of value in use and value in exchange, but also his further and more advanced distinction between the concepts of labor embodied and labor commanded, which lie at the root of his theory of value—not to speak of his less known distinction between “work done” and “work to be done” as highlighted by Smith himself in his public mourning example (WN, I.vii.19). For it must here be noted that one thing is to exchange a product of labor for a different product (or work done in a specific form for work done in a different form, or even, in Karl Marx’s own terms, one form of dead labor for a different form); another thing is to exchange some products of labor (wage goods) for labor as living labor in a work-to-be-done context. Furthermore, one thing is to exchange either a product of labor for a different product in the “early and rude state of society”; another thing is to exchange it in a more advanced state (once division of labor and capital accumulation have taken place). For the wage goods here exchanged for the labor available this year are not only the result of the labor employed in a recent or more distant past; they are also the condition for the labor of this year to promote the reproduction of commodities, including wage goods, to be consumed in the next or in the following years. Net of the problems created by rent, this calls for splitting the exchangeable value of the commodities produced this year into the share determined by the amount of (direct and indirect) labor embodied in each of them and the share determined by the (greater) amount of labor that these commodities will command, or be exchanged for, in the form either of work done (dead labor) or of work to be done (living labor) in the years to come.Footnote 7
IV. FROM THE LABOR MARKET AND THE VALUE OF LABOR TO THE ACCUMULATION OF CAPITAL AND THE INCREASING “PRODUCTIVE POWERS OF LABOUR”
The concept of labor as the original source of value, however ambiguously presented by Adam Smith, plays in WN a more explicit role than the role assigned in it to laborers as the potential receivers of the benefits resulting from the increase of national wealth. This second role, however, deserves to be highlighted more than it is usually done in the current literature. This can be done by examining the arguments provided in WN, Book I, and more particularly in its chapter VIII, “Of the Wages of Labour,” in connection with the arguments of Book II, and more particularly of its chapter III, “Of the Accumulation of Capital, or of Productive and Unproductive Labour.” The link between these two sets of arguments will be discussed below in the light of the process of capital accumulation as an engine activated by “masters and manufacturers” exclusively in the light of their own self-interest.
Leaving aside the important issues, announced by Smith at the beginning of chapter VIII, Book I, of the shares of output (profit and rent) not appropriated by (distributed to) laborers, and leaving also aside Smith’s introductory discussion of the ineffective combinations of laborers as “desperate men” struggling for an increase of their wages, we will here focus exclusively on the arguments concerning the circumstances that enable laborers to experience a repeated increase of wages in spite of their masters’ potential combinations against them. Here Smith implicitly resorts to the principle of demand and supply in order to explain both the causes of an increasing demand for labor and its effects on the increasing supply of it. While, with regard to the causes, they are traced to a continuous increase of the funds destined for the payment of wages, with regard to the effects, these are traced, in a short-run context, to the possible increase of the “liberal reward of labour” and, in a long-run context, to a continuous increase of population.
We will focus below on the causes and consequences of the latter increase. For now our analysis will be focused only on two different effects of the increasing demand for labor: one of these effects consists in an increase in the “productive powers of labour” (WN, I.viii.3–5), while the other consists in an increase in the “industry of the common people” (WN, I.viii.44). However similar these two effects may appear to be, they have a completely different relevance. The latter effect is limited by the restrictive attitude of laborers concerning the “toil and trouble” of their labor, while the former effect has an unlimited relevance within Smith’s theory of capital accumulation, on the one hand, and the resulting increase of wages, on the other. Three remarks deserve to be made in this connection.
First. One remark concerns the term “industry” used by Smith with regard to the second effect. This term is used, at least in the passage just mentioned, not in today’s sense of a particular branch of production but in Smith’s own sense of the “human quality” (“industriousness” in modern terms) by which a laborer becomes more “active, diligent, and expeditious” (WN, I.wiii.44).Footnote 8 Now, if the “liberal reward of labour” is regarded, as Smith does, as a source of industry in this sense, it cannot be regarded as the source of an increase in the “productive powers of labour” beyond the limits set by that human quality. For, once these limits have been reached, the “productive powers of labour” can be increased only by resorting to another more powerful and enduring factor. This is mentioned at the end of Smith’s chapter on wages in support of his rejection of the idea that an increase of wages, by increasing the price of many commodities, would result in a reduction of their consumption (and therefore of the demand for the labor employed in their reproduction). Here his argument runs as follows: “The same cause, however, which raises the wages of labour, the increase of stock, tends to increase its productive powers, and to make a smaller quantity of labour produce a greater quantity of work,” so that “there are many commodities, therefore, which, in consequence of these improvements, come to be produced by so much less labour than before, that the increase of its price is more than compensated by the diminution of its quantity” (WN, I.viii.57; see also I.xi.240).
This argument provides one of the best insights as well as one of the best visions of the WN. Footnote 9 This insight will be discussed in the following subsection while the resulting vision will be highlighted in the third and final subsection.
Second. A further remark is whether what is called, in the passage just quoted, an “increase of stock” does, or does not, coincide with what had been called, in some previous passages of the same chapter, an “increase of revenue and stock.” This issue can be introduced by the following questions: Is it by chance that the term “revenue” is dropped by Smith in the passage just quoted? Or are these two expressions consistent with the different sets of arguments they are intended to support? If one reads chapter VIII, Book I, having in mind what is argued in chapter III, Book II, one can realize that the jargon adopted by Smith in the previous chapter is consistent with the fact that the demand for labor is there dealt with regardless of whether it comes from the “expenditure of revenue” or from the “employment of capital.” For what is there under discussion is whether the demand for labor, however generated, increases by more or less than population (usually intended in WN as a proxy for labor supply). Thus Smith abstains from going deeper into the difference between these two increases, for what he is here interested in is only that, if the funds lying behind the demand for labor “have continued for several centuries of the same, or very nearly of the same extent” (i.e., if these funds do not increase from period to period along with population), then “labourers would be obliged to bid against one another” to get the employment they are looking for (WN, I.viii.24). The fact is that what really matters is not so much whether a country is rich or poor in a given period, but whether its wealth is increasing or not from period to period. And what matters most, when its wealth is increasing, is not whether the whole demand for labor is increasing but whether it is increasing by more than its supply. Hence, the principle of demand and supply here applied to the determination of wages in the long-run context of a changing population. Hence, the link between what happens in the labor market of the current period and what will happen in the labor markets of the periods to come. Here the initial conclusion is that an increase in the “funds destined for the maintenance of labour” is needed for wages to increase above the rate “consistent with common humanity.” But the final conclusion is that the future of wages will depend on whether these funds will actually increase by more, by as much, or by less than population will do in the same periods.Footnote 10
Third. The final remark is that Smith’s transition within chapter VIII, Book I, from the expression “revenue and stock” to the expression “increase of stock” can in turn be regarded as an introduction to the more crucial transition from the latter expression to the increase of the “productive powers of labour.” The important difference between this concept and the concept of “industry” discussed above lies in the fact that, while “industry” cannot increase beyond the limits set by the length of the working day, the “productive powers of labour” can increase, whatever the length of the working day, beyond the level reached even after the division of labor has been “thoroughly introduced” (WN, II, Introd., 2). What contributes to increasing the “productive powers of labour” beyond this level is the accumulation of capital as the ultimate, and unremitting, engine for the growth of national wealth.Footnote 11 Hence, Smith’s fundamental insight quoted within the first remark above. For not only does this insight imply a support for the idea that there are circumstances in which an increase of wages may not raise the price of commodities. It also goes further by hinting at the increasing “productive powers of labour” promoted by the accumulation of capital (through the introduction of new machinery and technical progress) as a natural reaction of “masters and manufacturers” to such an increase.
This is one of Smith’s most important visions with regard not only to the development of a “great society” but also to the economic history of the world in the centuries following the publication of his work. It also paves the way for a distinction and a relationship that have been introduced only later in the language of economic analysis. These are, in the first case, the distinction between capital widening and capital deepening; and, in the second case, the wage-profit inverse relationship.Footnote 12 It is the interaction between these two forms of accumulation as well as between the two directions of this relationship that has made it possible in the past, and will make it possible in the future, to arrange and rearrange the production and reproduction of “many” commodities at a diminishing labor cost per unit of output in spite of increasing wages, or, to use a still different terminology, in spite of the increasing value of labor in terms of the wage goods exchanged for it.Footnote 13
V. FROM THE ACCUMULATION OF CAPITAL TO THE GROWTH OF POPULATION: THREE PARTIAL SUPPORTS AND ONE FINAL ADJUSTMENT OF SMITH’S THEORY
The principle of demand and supply has been discussed above with exclusive regard to the long-run demand for labor. Now the time has come to extend it to the long-run supply of it. This is what Smith does in the middle of chapter VIII, Book I, when dealing with the dynamics of population. The analysis of this dynamics is brought to the fore in the context of the arguments on the “liberal reward of labour” mentioned above; and, more particularly, in the context of Smith’s central thesis that the “demand for men” regulates and determines the “production of men” in different countries of the world (WN, I.viii.40). Some remarks, however, are to be made concerning the correspondence between these passages and what has happened to the condition of laborers in the centuries following the publication of Smith’s work.
First. After starting with a “but” the sentence on the reproduction of human beings soon after the sentence on the reproduction of “every species of animals,”Footnote 14 Smith does admit that the latter kind of reproduction may be typical of the “inferior ranks of people” (as in the case of the “half-starved Highland woman” who, after generating twenty children, remains with only two alive). But he also seems to introduce the view that this reproductive behavior is destined to change if the demand for labor keeps increasing from period to period. Here the weakness of Smith’s arguments lies only in the fact that he leaves unsettled the crucial issue as to whether, once the “combinations of masters” are dissolved and population is increasing, the “liberal reward of labour” will, or will not, increase in the course of time along with a continuous increase in the demand for it. This implies the more specific issue, announced at the end of subsection 2 of section IV above, as to whether the rate of increase of the demand for labor will exceed, or remain equal to, the rate of increase of population as the source of its supply. The settlement of this issue is crucial, as we shall see below, for a final assessment of Smith’s vision of the future of wages.Footnote 15
Second. The difference between the reproductive behavior of human beings (lying behind the long-run supply of their labor) and that of “every species of animals” is not highlighted in chapter VIII, Book I, as much as it would deserve. Yet such a difference can be singled out if another famous passage of Book I is linked to one of the most crucial arguments of Book II. This passage occurs when Smith comes to highlighting an aspect of human behavior that is totally absent in the life of animals. This is the “the propensity to truck, barter, and exchange one thing for another” (WN, I.ii.1). This aspect, however, is more far-reaching than Smith’s words seem to imply. For the propensity of human beings to truck one thing for another is not confined to an exchange of present for present goods, a form of exchange that prevails (if ever) in the “early and rude state of society.” But it can also be extended to the exchange of present for future goods, a more advanced form of exchange pursued by forward-looking individuals in a more advanced society. It is indeed this further form of exchange that supports that great vis medicatrix reipublicae (in Thomas Malthus’s own words) that is the “uniform, constant, and uninterrupted effort of every man to better his condition” (WN, II.iii.31).Footnote 16
Third. The sentence just quoted is repeatedly used in different forms in the Wealth of Nations Footnote 17 and is widely known to its readers.Footnote 18 The most detailed presentation of such an effort, however, is put forward when, in the context of the theory of capital set out in Book II, Smith comes to the contrast between the “principle which prompts to expence” and the “principle which prompts to save” (WN, II.iii.28). Now, if one thinks of the adjectives “uniform, constant, and uninterrupted” attached to the term “effort,” and if one remembers that this effort is said to be typical of every man (apart from the minority cases of prodigality and misconduct), it is possible to conclude that the propensity to save is a prevailing feature of human beings as forward-looking individuals; and also that, the opposite principle being just a “passion for present enjoyment,” the propensity to save may in turn be regarded as a passion for future enjoyment or, in more modern terms, as a result of the time preference by which the future benefits expected by individuals from their current savings will overcome the corresponding sacrifice of their current consumption.Footnote 19
Now, if these arguments are considered in the light of the dynamics of population discussed above, it is possible to conclude that the “uniform, constant, and uninterrupted effort of every man to better his condition” cannot materialize if population were to increase, as Smith seems to imply in chapter VIII, Book I, at the same rate at which the funds destined for its maintenance do. But it must be noted that, for Smith’s arguments on the potential increase of population and on that “uniform, constant, and uninterrupted effort” to be consistent with each other, the rate of increase of population must be assumed to fall short of the rate of increase of the funds destined to the maintenance of all its components—i.e., of productive laborers, unproductive laborers, and “those who do not labour at all.” Now, even if there is no direct evidence in Smith’s text of these diverging rates, such an assumption must be considered as implicit or necessary for supporting the internal consistency, as well as the intertemporal validity, of his system of thought insofar as it is focused on that “uniform, constant and uninterrupted effort of every man to better his condition.” It must be noted, however, that the success of this effort cannot materialize if one believes that, even in modern societies, technical progress, whether in its neutral or capital-saving forms, is not strong enough for keeping the increase of those funds above a given increase of population. And it cannot occur for even a stronger reason if one believes, in Smith’s footsteps, that the accumulation of capital is “almost always” needed for increasing the productivity, rather than the employment, of labor (WN, II.iii.32). This implies that, net of the benefits resulting from the simpler forms of technical progress and given the obstacles provided by the possibility of diminishing returns, the process of capital accumulation cannot provide a continuous increase of national wealth such as to overcome a continuous increase of population. Hence, the spread of the preventive checks (to use a term introduced by Malthus with exclusive regard to the postponement of marriages and of sexual intercourses) so widely practiced in modern times under the synthetic term of birth control. The implementation of this new approach to the reproduction of human beings has made it possible to turn the population of modern societies into a variable depending on the actual or expected level of income per head—i.e., into something that was either impossible or unacceptable in past centuries when infant mortality and life expectancy were so far away from what they are today.
It can be added, however, that the inverse relationship between income per head and human fertility is somewhat admitted by Smith himself when comparing the “half-starved Highland woman” mentioned above with the “pampered fine lady” who is “generally exhausted by two or three” children (WN, I.viii.37). This inverse relationship can indeed be developed further if we resort to an intertemporal comparison between the fertility rates and living standards experienced by the “inferior ranks of people” in Smith’s own times and those experienced by the same ranks of people in the more advanced economies of our times. This comparison would help us to adjust Smith’s arguments on the “liberal reward of labour” as the necessary effect of increasing wealth (WN, I.vi.27) as well as the cause of an increasing population (WN, I.vi.42). For it is true that, after noting that the habits of these ranks descend from the higher mortality of their children, Smith fails to develop his argument as he would have done if he simply were living in our times. But in this case he would also recognize what the reproductive behavior of the “common people” has become, once the (much lower) mortality of children experienced in modern societies is considered in conjunction with the quantity and quality of the wage goods exchanged today for the labor of the “inferior ranks of people” beyond the levels reached by the “people of fashion” in Smith’s own times.Footnote 20
VI. FROM SELF-INTEREST AND COMPETITION, CAPITAL ACCUMULATION, AND POPULATION GROWTH TO THE LONG-RUN INCREASE OF WAGES
We have noted above that the expression “increase of stock” is introduced at the end of chapter VIII, Book I, in anticipation of, and as a link with, chapter III, Book II, of WN. This is announced by Smith himself when, in the middle of chapter IX, “Of the Profits of Stock,” Book I, he returns to “the connection between the increase of stock and that of industry” by stressing that this connection “will be explained more fully” in Book II (WN, I.ix.11). It must be noted that the term “industry” is used in this book not only in the sense, adopted in Book I and discussed above, of the industriousness of common people but also in the more advanced direction of the increasing productivity of labor (once the length of the working day is given), which results (up to a certain point) from the division of labor (as discussed in Book I) and (from that point onwards) from the accumulation of capital (as discussed in Book II). Although Smith is not so explicit, when he comes to the latter topic, in recognizing the two forms of accumulation mentioned above as capital widening and capital deepening, he provides some hints on this distinction by mentioning two circumstances that reinforce each other in promoting a continuous increase in the productivity of labor. One has already been mentioned with regard to the substitution of machinery for labor as a reaction to increasing wages (and to the corresponding fall of profits). The other occurs when technical progress re-enters Smith’s arguments either in the forms of neutral technical progress (as in the simplified example of the boy “who loved to play with his companions,” WN, I.i.8); or in the capital-saving forms (as when “the same number of workmen” are able to perform “an equal quantity of work with cheaper and simpler machinery,” WN, II.ii.7); or in the more advanced capital-using forms (which, as noted above, are thought by Smith to prevail over the other forms).
Now, if Smith’s advanced arguments on capital accumulation are considered in conjunction with his simpler arguments on technical progress, it becomes possible to highlight the impact that all these arguments imply, once they are reformulated and adjusted in the sense suggested above, in terms of the future of wages. It is worth recalling that, while one of these arguments concerns the increasing demand for labor associated with shifts of the wage-profit inverse relationship, the other concerns the rate of increase of population (labor supply) as falling short of the rate of increase of the demand for it; and, finally, the third concerns the process of capital accumulation as taking place in the context of a permanent competition between “masters and manufacturers.” If these arguments are considered in relation to each other, it is possible to conclude that their unified impact will just involve a long-run increase of the demand for labor in excess of its supply, the unavoidable outcome of this impact being a long-run increase of wages.Footnote 21 This outcome is unavoidable in spite of the fact that the self-interest of “masters and manufacturers” is such that they will not welcome, and are usually combined against, such an increase.
This outcome, it must now be noted, bears some similarity with the apparently different one discussed by Smith when defending the principle of free trade against the restraints upon importation and the encouragement to exportation advocated by mercantilists.Footnote 22 However different the subject of international trade may be from the subject of how the long-run demand for labor will interact with its supply, it is nonetheless possible to conclude that the increase of wages contemplated by the three arguments above may be viewed as one of the “many other cases” in which individuals are led by an invisible hand to promote an end that was no part of their intentions (WN, IV.ii.9).Footnote 23 This implies the further conclusion that, when the conditions assumed in these arguments are met, the process of capital accumulation, whether associated with neutral or more advanced forms of technical progress (as is usually the case beyond a certain limit and in the capital-deepening context of our age), presents itself as the ultimate force that can promote a long-run increase of wages.Footnote 24
VII. CONCLUDING REMARKS
Following Joseph Schumpeter’s view of the relation between TMS and WN as “blocks cut out from a larger systematic whole” (Reference Schumpeter1954, p. 141), we have focused above on the block of market exchanges, starting from the nature of, and the possible conflict between, the principles of self-interest and competition that lie behind the behavior of the individuals engaged in these exchanges. After examining the role played by these principles in determining the value of labor in a demand-and-supply context, we have moved to the manifold link between chapter VIII, Book I, and chapter III, Book II, of WN. This link has been brought to the fore by focusing, first, on Smith’s concept of “industry” as distinct from his more advanced concept of “productive powers of labour,” and, later on, on the accumulation of capital as the main force that, associated with technical progress, can support and elevate these powers from period to period. In order to prove how the increase in these powers may be turned into a long-run increase of wages, we have focused above on the principle of demand for, and supply of, labor in the dynamic context of a continuous process of capital accumulation and population growth. We have accordingly argued that, in spite of Smith’s inclination to assume some equality between the growth of the demand for, and of the supply of, labor (population) in a growing economy, his theory of population needs an explicit adjustment for it to be consistent with the possibility of a long-run increase of wages. This adjustment calls for an introduction into Smith’s system of thought of the assumption (supported as it is in modern societies by the widespread use of birth control techniques) of the long-run supply of labor (population) increasing at a lower rate than the long-run demand for it. This dynamic context includes one of the “many other cases” in which the invisible hand reappears as just one of what are called today the “unintended consequences of human action.” The final conclusion of the paper is that this particular consequence corresponds to a repeated increase in the “liberal reward of labour” (within one country or across different countries) as the ultimate result of the “uniform, constant, and uninterrupted effort of every man to better his condition.” This repeated increase is silently promoted from period to period by the process of capital accumulation if this takes place under conditions of competition within the markets not only of labor (as living labor) but also of commodities as products of labor (or as different forms of dead labor). Hence, the difference between the reproduction of laborers and the reproduction of commodities. For it is the employment of capital and the expectation of profit that lie behind the decisions of individuals to put in motion the production and reproduction of commodities, while it is a completely different principle that lies behind their very different decisions to put in motion the production (to use Smith’s famous term) and reproduction (to use a more appropriate term) of human beings, including laborers as suppliers of the ultimate resource for the production and reproduction of national wealth.
