Singapore's history began with the landing of the British imperialist, Sir Stamford Raffles, on the shores of the Singapore River in 1819, when he laid the foundations for the success story that was continued by the Singapore government after independence — or so the official national history proclaimed until very recently. According to one of the original Cabinet ministers who set national historiography on this course soon after independence in 1965, any claim of a Singapore history before Raffles’ arrival was not just false history, but was ‘about as honest as claiming descent from the sun or the moon or the wolves or licentious Greek gods’ (p. 3). Ouch.
Unfortunately for generations of Singapore schoolchildren, this stunted colonialist-cum-nationalist historiography framed their history lessons in school, ensuring that boredom, patriotism and political loyalty would walk arm-in-arm for decades. It also wilfully marginalised the country's indigenous Malays by denying their centuries-long association with the island and the region.
National historiography began cautiously opening itself up to Singapore's pre-colonial past during the 2000s, but it entered the mainstream only at the end of the 2010s, when the prospect of celebrating the 2019 bicentennial of Raffles’ landing triggered an avalanche of revisionist scholarship. Some of the consequent publications, including Seven hundred years, have even benefited from official sponsorship, showing how much Singapore has changed since 1965.
Seven hundred years is a very impressive longue durée history of the island, taking the reader back as far as the fourteenth century, and drawing upon four distinct types of source material: archives in many languages, archaeology, cartography (ancient maps that depict the island under various names) and science (substantially geology and environmental science).
Since Singapore was never a stand-alone polity until recently, Seven hundred years concerns itself as much with the region and the island's various imperial contexts as it does with Singapore per se. Through this wholistic approach, the reader discovers that Singapore has been a naval base and a trading port, not only in the British period, but also centuries earlier when it was part of the Malacca and Johor sultanates. It has been a site of military battles by foreign powers, not just in the Second World War, but on several other occasions over the previous millennia. And no, Raffles was far from the first outsider to recognise the strategic importance of the island.
This book also tells us about the daily life of these ancient ‘Singaporeans’ and especially about their politics: analysing the shifting political and military power structures within the ruling elites, and explaining, for instance, the political decline of the orang laut ethnic group and the rise of the Bugis in the eighteenth century (p. 152). That particular shift contributed to the island's state of relative depopulation when Raffles arrived in 1819, which in turn provided cover for the notion that nothing of consequence happened before that.
The book opens with an adventurous historiographical ‘Introduction’ that probes and exposes the pre-colonial blind spot in the island's national history. It also takes issue with the ‘Whig’ interpretations of history that have been oriented to the legitimisation of the current order, rather than understanding the past — which is the nature of Whig histories. The chapter then briefly canvasses three alternative longue durée approaches that might assist a reader to link the modern present with the ancient past.
The introduction is followed by a series of seven chapters, each of which is notionally tied to a century's history, after which comes a reflective ‘Conclusion’. I say ‘notionally’ because the chapter on the fourteenth century really goes back even further, placing the ancient world of Temasek in the context of even earlier centuries of sea-borne empires and Chinese and Indian traders.
The depiction of Singapore's world from the fourteenth to the end of the eighteenth century is distinctively Southeast Asian in perspective: the view is from an Asian shore, not from the deck of a ship that has newly arrived from Europe. This does not mean that it disregards Europeans or their interventions, but simply that it is able to convey how the locals saw them — as a new set of outsiders with whom one could trade, negotiate, fight or form alliances, whether it be formal alliances against rival powers or less honourable alliances designed to betray one's own raja or subvert a dynastic succession.
Turning the page from the chapter on the eighteenth century to the chapter on the nineteenth century, however, the view changed so severely that I suffered whiplash. Suddenly I was on the deck of the Indiana with Sir Stamford Raffles, and reading about the ‘hunt for a British foothold’ (p. 181) and the ‘nine days that changed Singapore's world’ (p. 184). Five pages into this new chapter I finally found mention of some Asians, including the local Malay aristocrat who lived on the island as its ruler and who played arguably the most critical role in facilitating Raffles’ acquisition. I then had to wait another four pages before being told his name (Abdur Rahman) in a text box that seemed to have been inserted after the main text was complete. The text box explained (at last) how Abdur Rahman, along with thousands of his followers, came to be living on the island and running several successful business enterprises. It also provided a belated account of why he might have thought it was in his interests to help Raffles in his ‘hunt for a British foothold’.
To be fair, Abdur Rahman's fellow Malay aristocrat, Tengku Husain, receives considerably more attention, but this could not compensate for the chapter's severely Eurocentric turn, which surely can only be explained by a fresh change of authors within the team of four. Whatever the explanation, it felt like history did indeed start in 1819, which was incredibly disappointing in a volume that had been so impressive up to that point.
The following chapter, on the twentieth century, is also remarkably out-of-step with the tone of the earlier chapters. It would not have been out of place in one of the old history textbooks from the 1980s or 1990s — showing, alas, how little Singapore has changed since 1965.
