Major portions of the book under review appeared in Turkish in 2008, under the title ‘Ermeni Meselesi Hallolunmuştur’: Osmanlı Belgelerine Göre Savaş Yıllarında Ermenilere Yönelik Politikalar (The Armenian Question Resolved: Policies toward the Armenians in the War Years according to Ottoman Documents [Cağaloğlu, Istanbul: İletişim Yayınları, 2008]). The recent English version, with some modifications and additions, should be considered an important contribution to the historiography of the Armenian Genocide. After many years of research, Taner Akçam presents new evidence from the Ottoman archives in order to demonstrate that the Armenian Genocide and the expulsion of the Greeks from the Ottoman Empire were part of a deliberate policy of the Committee of Union and Progress (CUP) to get rid of the empire's Christians. In the case of the Greeks this policy was achieved through ethnic cleansing (beginning in the spring of 1914) and in the case of the Armenians it was carried out through a systematic annihilation. To prove his case, Akçam uses 600 documents from the Ottoman archives “as the basis for reconstructing a sequence of events as viewed and recorded by the central authorities” (pp. xxi–xxii). According to him these documents demonstrate that despite the massive purging of records pertaining to the Armenian Genocide from the Ottoman archives over the course of the past century, the Ottoman archives still hold a plethora of documents that confirms the complicity of the central government in the genocide.
The book is divided into twelve sections dealing with a variety of themes ranging from the CUP's aim of homogenizing Anatolia, the ethnic cleansing of the Greeks as a dress rehearsal for the Armenian Genocide, the initial and final phases of the decision-making process of the genocide, intent in the genocide, demographic policy, compulsory conversion and assimilation, the confiscation of Armenian properties during the genocide, and finally the rebuffing of denialists’ allegations. After dwelling on the two prevailing interpretations of the Armenian Genocide (aside from the denialists’)—that of continuity (Vahakn N. Dadrian) and that of contingency (Ron G. Suny)—Akçam provides an alternative explanation by arguing that the Armenian Genocide should be viewed as an outcome of a process. According to him, the genocide was not the result of a single decision on a given date as attested by the continuity approach nor was it the result of a contingency, that is, a contingent event that took place in conjuncture with World War I; rather, “it appears to have been the cumulative outcome of a series of increasingly radical decisions, each triggering the next in a cascading sequence of events” (p. 128). Most of the interrelated themes of the book are worthy of comment. However, I would like to highlight a few themes crucial to the historiographical discourse of the genocide: the Armenian reform project of 1914, the CUP's demographic policy, and the concept of intent in the genocide (a major criteria for the definition of genocide according to the Genocide Convention adopted by the United Nations General Assembly on 9 December 1948).
The Armenian reform project of 1914 has not received adequate attention from scholars as an important factor that was seen by CUP leaders as threatening the integrity of the empire, driving them to search for a solution to the “Armenian question,” which had been revived by the Balkan Wars of 1912–13. The Armenian leadership, aided by the European powers, pressed the Ottoman government after the Balkan Wars to improve the condition of Armenians in the Eastern Provinces. The result was the reform package prepared by André Mandelstam (dragoman of the Russian Embassy in Istanbul) and the representative of the Armenian National Assembly in Istanbul, at a meeting in which the ambassadors of France, Britain, and Italy participated. Germany opposed the project and succeeded in obtaining significant modifications. At the end of September 1913, Russia and Germany agreed to divide the Armenian provinces into two sectors, each with an inspector-general. According to Akçam, the Ottoman records reveal that Ottoman authorities were convinced that the Armenian reform project would lead to the dismantling of the empire, which they sought to prevent at all costs. This longstanding reform question, which dated back to the late 19th century, developed into “an existential national security issue for the Ottoman state” (p. 126). Akçam argues that this “intolerable burden of the 1914 Armenian reform agreement lent urgency to the Ottomans’ decision to enter World War I” (p. 131).
The demographic policy of the CUP during the 1910s is a central theme of this book. Indeed, Akçam considers his book a “first” in terms of its exploration of “the demographic policy and genocidal character of the actions against the Armenians on the basis of the archival records” (p. xxi). However, the demographic policy behind the Armenian Genocide was a central theme in an earlier study, Uğur Ümit Üngör's The Making of Modern Turkey: Nation and State in Eastern Anatolia, 1913–50 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011), which does not appear in Akçam's book. Nevertheless, Akçam does provide an in-depth analysis of the systematic deportation policy, arguing that the population ratios of the local communities where Armenians were deported and where they remained were decisive in the CUP's demographic policy—a factor that attests to the demographic anxieties that shaped the deportations (p. 226). Akçam's most important thesis is that the Armenian Genocide “was not implemented solely as demographic engineering, but also as destruction and annihilation, and that the 5 to 10 percent principle was decisive in achieving this goal” (p. 242). Akçam elaborates on the 5 to 10 percent principle by arguing that care was taken by the government to make sure that the number of Armenians who were deported to Syria from the Eastern Provinces should not exceed 5 to 10 percent of the local Muslim population. According to him the only way this could be achieved was through annihilation (p. 242).
Akçam dedicates a whole chapter to discussing the intent to commit genocide, based on documents of the Interior Ministry. He argues that intent was embodied in the dual-track mechanism of the organization of the genocide, in which formal telegrams were sent to the provinces pertaining to the deportations and concomitantly killing orders were sent through informal channels delivered by CUP couriers, as attested by the testimonies in the Ottoman Military Tribunals of 1919. This demonstrates how the formal telegrams veiled intent while the informal one conveyed them.
Akçam's book makes important contributions to the field, especially with regard to the demographic policy of the CUP prior to and during World War I. However, it has some shortcomings. The first is a fixation on the Ottoman archives as the primary source for the study of intent in relation to the Armenian Genocide. Intent itself is a very difficult point to prove in any act of genocide. I would argue that intent can be inferred from a study of actual crimes through an analysis of their simultaneity, systematic organization, and extensiveness. Second, a thorough analysis of the Young Turk/CUP ideology should have utilized recently published scholarship, including the works of Nader Sohrabi, Uğur Ümit Üngör, and M. Şükrü Hanioğlu, which provide an understanding of the CUP's social scientific vision for the empire and the radicalization of its nationalism. Third, the last section of book, which aims to rebuff the denialist approach, disrupts the progression of the book and would be better suited as a separate study. Finally, the book lacks a compelling conclusion as Akçam argues that the fundamental issue in the Armenian Genocide is not a legal but rather a moral one (p. 450). By doing this he strips genocide from its legal connotation and argues that, “Regardless of the term used, it is necessary to fully confront the immense human tragedy whose repetition must absolutely be prevented” (p. 451). At a time in which human rights violations are taking place in Turkey daily against Kurdish and Turkish intellectuals and activists, Akçam ends his book on a positive note by trying to convince the reader that the “recent surges of democratization in Turkey” have provided the ground for discussing the “tragedy” and that the “future looks a little more optimistic” (p. 452).
Notwithstanding some of its shortcomings, The Young Turks’ Crime Against Humanity is a worthy addition to the recent scholarship on the Armenian Genocide. The book is a useful compendium for every graduate student, scholar, and historian who is interested in exploring different dimensions of the Armenian Genocide and late Ottoman history, the transition from empire to nation–state, ethnic violence, demographic policy, and the history of World War I. It is this reviewer's hope that scholars in the field will address some of the critical points raised by Akçam and that the book will provide the basis for many further discussions on the subject.
