The ten chapters in this new collection edited by Laurel Kendall offer a kaleidoscopic view of everyday life, through the lens of consumption, in colonial and contemporary Korea. The topics these essays cover range from Lotte World to yangban lineage house tours, from colonial-period tourist guides to contemporary back-pack tourism, from recent international kimch'i wars to department store dining in the colonial capital. The subjects are quirky, but taken together the material illuminates the ways in which “Korean tradition” has been produced and consumed, by outsiders and by Koreans themselves, with various goals, but always in a context of the contested authenticities of object, practice, people, and self.
Although the title reflects a somewhat awkward temporal span, in her introduction Kendall explains that the collection “sustains a dialogue between historians of early modern Korea and scholars of contemporary South Korean life” (p. 3). To enhance this dialogue, the papers have been divided into four groups (entitled “Modernity as Spectacle/Spectacular Korea,” “Korea as Itinerary,” “Korean Things,” and “Korea Performed,”) within each of which historical and current material are juxtaposed. For example, Timothy Tangherlini's chapter, “Shrinking Culture: Lotte World and the Logic of Miniaturization,” is paired with Katarzyna J. Cwiertka's study of late-colonial period department store restaurants, “Dining Out in the Land of Desire: Colonial Seoul and the Korean Culture of Consumption.” (The other chapters in this volume are: Hyung Il Pai, “Travel Guides to the Empire”; Okpyo Moon, “Guests of Lineage Houses: Tourist Commoditization of Confucian Cultural Heritage in Korea”; Robert Oppenheim, “Tapsa and Paenang Yŏhaeng as Travel Goods”; Laurel Kendall, “The Changsŭng Defanged”; Kyung-Koo Han, “The ‘Kimchi Wars’ in Globalizing East Asia”; Judy Van Zile, “The Impact of Japanese Colonization and Ch'oe Sŭng-hŭi on Dance in South Korea Today”; and Keith Howard, “Kugak Fusion and the Politics of Korean Musical Consumption.”) Kendall offers brief commentary at the start of each section to highlight the specific themes and connections among those particular selections.
In her introductory chapter, Kendall provides an orientation to scholarship in the fields of material culture and consumption, as well as other work specifically on Korea. Kendall takes Invention of Tradition, edited by Eric Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983), as the intellectual touchstone, inspiring questions about authenticity and its connections with the nation-state, the ascendance of capitalism, and the development of consumer cultures. She notes that, unlike the studies of the infusion of consumer objects and practices from elsewhere into Korea (for example, the ubiquitous Starbucks), the essays collected here “look at the other side of the mirror, exploring the ironic space where contemporary South Koreans consume a traditional ‘us’. . .” (p. 3).
Yet it is worth asking: a quarter century after a “new” interest in the connections between identity, authenticity, and consumption was sparked in both history and anthropology (see also Arjun Appadurai, The Social Life of Things: Commodities in Cultural Perspective [Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986], in addition to the aforementioned Hobsbawm and Rangers volume), while this book provides case studies on topics that are likely to sustain reader (especially student) interest, does it break new ground? The essays primarily work within existing analytical frameworks, so perhaps the principal contribution of this collection is that it demonstrates the complexity of Korean encounters with modernity. The authors sustain a consistent focus on the overlapping influences of colonialism (as context and as heritage), shifting class hierarchies, global capitalism, nostalgia, and fantasies of modernity in Korea. Taken as a whole, the book makes a strong case that Korean material resists simplistic analyses of “national” culture, despite the appearance of (and persistent claims to) cultural homogeneity. Looking at and through Korea, we are pressed to inquire beyond the first, automatic answers to questions of the origins and meanings of cultural phenomena. This complexity positions these Korean case materials as illuminating beyond the sphere of Koreanists.
As is common with compendia such as this, chapters vary somewhat with respect to the detail of the data and the sophistication of their analysis. Further, depending on their own predilections, readers will find some topics more interesting than others (in part because the disciplinary interests of the authors are reflected in their stylistic choices). Oppenheim's chapter stands out for its attempt to engage in an analysis inspired by fresh ideas—in this case, playing with tourism as both the consumption of place as a form of meaning-making, and as a transactional practice that is framed yet has the potential for experiential “overflow”—but all the chapters are richly grounded in primary scholarship. While the book is perhaps best positioned to provide readings for advanced undergraduate classes in Korean studies, it stands on its own as a collection of intriguing explorations of the ongoing generation of Korean traditional culture.
