Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T15:59:11.152Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Kraichnan–Leith–Batchelor similarity theory and two-dimensional inverse cascades

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 February 2015

B. H. Burgess*
Affiliation:
Department of Physics, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario M5S 1A7, Canada
R. K. Scott
Affiliation:
School of Mathematics and Statistics, University of St. Andrews, St. Andrews, Fife KY16 9SS, UK
T. G. Shepherd
Affiliation:
Department of Meteorology, University of Reading, Reading, Berkshire RG6 6BB, UK
*
†Email address for correspondence: belhburgess@physics.utoronto.ca
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

We study the scaling properties and Kraichnan–Leith–Batchelor (KLB) theory of forced inverse cascades in generalized two-dimensional (2D) fluids ( ${\it\alpha}$ -turbulence models) simulated at resolution $8192^{2}$ . We consider ${\it\alpha}=1$ (surface quasigeostrophic flow), ${\it\alpha}=2$ (2D Euler flow) and ${\it\alpha}=3$ . The forcing scale is well resolved, a direct cascade is present and there is no large-scale dissipation. Coherent vortices spanning a range of sizes, most larger than the forcing scale, are present for both ${\it\alpha}=1$ and ${\it\alpha}=2$ . The active scalar field for ${\it\alpha}=3$ contains comparatively few and small vortices. The energy spectral slopes in the inverse cascade are steeper than the KLB prediction $-(7-{\it\alpha})/3$ in all three systems. Since we stop the simulations well before the cascades have reached the domain scale, vortex formation and spectral steepening are not due to condensation effects; nor are they caused by large-scale dissipation, which is absent. One- and two-point p.d.f.s, hyperflatness factors and structure functions indicate that the inverse cascades are intermittent and non-Gaussian over much of the inertial range for ${\it\alpha}=1$ and ${\it\alpha}=2$ , while the ${\it\alpha}=3$ inverse cascade is much closer to Gaussian and non-intermittent. For ${\it\alpha}=3$ the steep spectrum is close to that associated with enstrophy equipartition. Continuous wavelet analysis shows approximate KLB scaling $\mathscr{E}(k)\propto k^{-2}~({\it\alpha}=1)$ and $\mathscr{E}(k)\propto k^{-5/3}~({\it\alpha}=2)$ in the interstitial regions between the coherent vortices. Our results demonstrate that coherent vortex formation ( ${\it\alpha}=1$ and ${\it\alpha}=2$ ) and non-realizability ( ${\it\alpha}=3$ ) cause 2D inverse cascades to deviate from the KLB predictions, but that the flow between the vortices exhibits KLB scaling and non-intermittent statistics for ${\it\alpha}=1$ and ${\it\alpha}=2$ .

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© 2015 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Table 1.Simulation parameters. Here $N$ is the resolution, $s$ the order of hyperviscosity, $k_{f}$ and $k_{m}$ the forcing and maximum resolved wavenumbers, ${\it\nu}$ the small-scale dissipation and $k_{d}$ the dissipation wavenumber. The injected energy and enstrophy are ${\it\varepsilon}_{I}$ and ${\it\eta}_{I}=k_{f}^{{\it\alpha}}{\it\varepsilon}_{I}$ respectively.

Figure 1

Figure 1.(a) Longitudinal and (b) transverse correlation coefficients. (c) Growth of the integral scale $r_{I}$ as a function of $t/T_{{\it\alpha}}$. The circled points correspond to the nondimensional times listed in (a,b). The solid line is $r_{I}\propto (t/T_{1})^{0.549}$, the dotted line is $r_{I}\propto (t/T_{2})^{0.92}$, and the dash-dot line is $r_{I}\propto (t/T_{3})^{1.0}$.

Figure 2

Table 2.Characteristic times $t/T_{{\it\alpha}}$ at which data were taken and corresponding integral scales $r_{I}$, enstrophy flux ${\it\eta}$ in the direct cascade and energy flux ${\it\varepsilon}$ in the inverse cascade.

Figure 3

Figure 2.Low-wavenumber scaling of $\mathscr{E}(k)$ for ${\it\alpha}=1$ at $t/T_{1}=850.9$, ${\it\alpha}=2$ at $t/T_{2}=168.3$, and ${\it\alpha}=3$ at $t/T_{3}=39.7$. The energy spectra are offset by several decades for clarity. The straight lines correspond to $k^{5-{\it\alpha}}$.

Figure 4

Figure 3.Fluxes of generalized energy ${\it\Pi}_{E}$ and of generalized enstrophy ${\it\Pi}_{Z}$, normalized by their respective injection rates, for (a) ${\it\alpha}=1$ at $t/T_{1}=850.9$, (b) ${\it\alpha}=2$ at $t/T_{2}=168.3$, (c) ${\it\alpha}=3$ at $t/T_{3}=39.7$. Positive values indicate downscale fluxes, and negative values upscale fluxes. These fluxes correspond to the spectra in figure 4.

Figure 5

Figure 4.Inverse cascade energy spectra for (a) ${\it\alpha}=1$, (b) ${\it\alpha}=2$ and (c) ${\it\alpha}=3$ averaged over times $t/T_{1}=763.4{-}850.9$, $t/T_{2}=121.5{-}215.0$ and $t/T_{3}=34.9{-}44.6$ respectively, together with best fit and KLB power laws indicated by straight lines. Part of the direct cascade range is also shown.

Figure 6

Figure 5.(a)$~{\it\theta}$ and (b) $|\boldsymbol{v}|$ for ${\it\alpha}=1$ in a $1024^{2}$ region at $t/T_{1}=850.9$. The axes are labelled with the distance in grid sites.

Figure 7

Figure 6.(a) ${\it\theta}$ and (b) $|\boldsymbol{v}|$ for ${\it\alpha}=2$ in a $1024^{2}$ region at $t/T_{2}=168.3$. The axes are labelled with the distance in grid sites.

Figure 8

Figure 7.(a) ${\it\theta}$ and (b) $|\boldsymbol{v}|$ for ${\it\alpha}=3$ in a $1024^{2}$ region at $t/T_{3}=39.7$. The axes are labelled with the distance in grid sites.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Wavelet and Fourier spectra for (a) ${\it\alpha}=1$ and (b) ${\it\alpha}=2$. The Fourier spectrum (grey) is overlain on the globally averaged wavelet spectrogram (black circles). Wavelet spectrograms for the interstitial flow (solid black lines) with two choices of ${\it\theta}_{thr}$ and $i_{dx}=10,20,30$ and 40 (from top to bottom) also appear, together with KLB scaling (dashed black lines).

Figure 10

Figure 9.Sample interstitial flow (light regions) for (a) ${\it\alpha}=1$ (${\it\theta}_{thr}=3{\it\theta}_{rms}$, $i_{dx}=20$) and (b) ${\it\alpha}=2$ (${\it\theta}_{thr}=4{\it\theta}_{rms}$, $i_{dx}=40$).

Figure 11

Figure 10.(a) Averaged one-point active scalar p.d.f.s. The corresponding averaged kurtoses are $K_{{\it\theta}}=22.99,22.09,3.97$ for ${\it\alpha}=1,2,3$ respectively. (b,c) Total and filtered one-point active scalar p.d.f.s for ${\it\alpha}=1$ and ${\it\alpha}=2$ respectively. The values of ${\it\theta}_{thr}$ used for filtering are given at the top right.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Smoothed one-point active scalar p.d.f.s for (a) ${\it\alpha}=1$, (b) ${\it\alpha}=2$,and (c) ${\it\alpha}=3$.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Two-point p.d.f.s for (a–c) ${\it\alpha}=1$, (d–f) ${\it\alpha}=2$ and (g–i) ${\it\alpha}=3$. (a,d,g) p.d.f.s of active scalar increments, (b,e,h) longitudinal velocity increments and (c,f,i) transverse velocity increments. The separations considered correspond to $2^{m}k_{f}$, where $m=2,1,0,-1,-2,-3,-4,-5,-6,-7,-8,-9$.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Hyperflatness factors of longitudinal and transverse velocity increments for (a) ${\it\alpha}=1$, (b) ${\it\alpha}=2$ and (c) ${\it\alpha}=3$. The straight horizontal lines are the Gaussian values. The vertical lines mark the forcing scale $r_{f}$, the integral scale $r_{I}$ and the maximum vortex diameter $r_{V_{max}}$, where applicable. The ranges on the vertical axes are the same in each panel to facilitate comparison.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Hyperflatness factors of active scalar increments for (a) ${\it\alpha}=1$, (b) ${\it\alpha}=2$ and (c) ${\it\alpha}=3$. The straight horizontal lines are the Gaussian values. The vertical lines mark the forcing scale $r_{f}$, the integral scale $r_{I}$ and the maximum vortex diameter $r_{V_{max}}$, where applicable. The ranges on the vertical axes are the same in each panel to facilitate comparison.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Structure functions for (a–c) ${\it\alpha}=1$, (d–f) ${\it\alpha}=2$ and (g–i) ${\it\alpha}=3$ for even orders from $n=2$ (lowest curve in each plot) to $n=12$ (top curve in each plot). (a,d,g) longitudinal velocity, (b,e,h) transverse velocity and (c,f,i) active scalar structure functions. Straight lines with the scaling $n/3$ are plotted for comparison. The forcing scale $r_{f}$, maximum vortex size $r_{V_{max}}$, and integral scale $r_{I}$ are marked by vertical dashed lines.

Figure 17

Figure 16.(a) Longitudinal and (b) transverse velocity structure functions for ${\it\alpha}=1$ at large scales for even orders from $n=2$ (lowest curve in each plot) to $n=12$ (top curve in each plot). The point density is shown on the bottom curve. Straight lines with the scaling $n/3$ are plotted for comparison. The maximum vortex size $r_{V_{max}}$ and integral scale $r_{I}$ are marked by vertical dashed lines.

Figure 18

Table 3.Relative scaling exponents $\tilde{{\it\zeta}}_{n}$ of longitudinal velocity structure functions at inverse cascade scales for ${\it\alpha}=1$, ${\it\alpha}=2$ and ${\it\alpha}=3$ for even orders from $n=2$ (lowest curve) to $n=12$ (top curve). The latter are closest to $n/3$. For ${\it\alpha}=1$, $\tilde{{\it\zeta}}_{n}^{1}$ and $\tilde{{\it\zeta}}_{n}^{2}$ are the scaling exponents on the smaller- and larger-scale ranges of the inverse cascade, as discussed in the text.

Figure 19

Table 4.Relative scaling exponents $\tilde{{\it\zeta}}_{n}$ of transverse velocity structure functions.

Figure 20

Table 5.Relative exponents $\tilde{{\it\zeta}}_{n}$ of ${\it\theta}$ structure functions.

Figure 21

Figure 17.(a,c,e) Longitudinal and (b,d,f) transverse velocity structure functions for (a–d) interstitial patches and (e,f) ${\it\alpha}=2$ residual field (${\it\theta}_{thr}=2{\it\theta}_{rms}$). (a,b) ${\it\alpha}=1$ and (c,d) ${\it\alpha}=2$. They should be compared with the structure functions for the total field in figure 15(a,b) and (d,e). The forcing scale $r_{f}$ is marked by vertical dashed lines.