Betrayal, cruelty, reality, and immorality are all dominant themes in the work of Neil LaBute, and the various manifestations of these themes are fully explored in Christopher Bigsby's study Neil LaBute: Stage and Cinema. Though the book is subtitled Stage and Cinema, it is actually more inclusive, covering LaBute's short story collection Seconds of Pleasure, with the added bonus of an interview with the playwright.
Bigsby's study is one of two books about LaBute published recently. The first, Neil LaBute: A Casebook, edited by Gerald C. Wood (Routledge, 2006), includes essays by scholars responding to various issues of theme and style. In contrast, Bigsby focuses on each of LaBute's works separately, allowing for predominant characteristics of LaBute's creative world (called LaButeland) to gather strength in each successive chapter.
Following an introduction, in which Bigsby insists that LaBute is “the most powerful and original playwright and screenwriter to emerge in turn-of-the-century America” (11), eleven chapters examine sixteen works. The chapters are organized chronologically, the first focusing on Bash: Latterday Plays (1995) and the last on Some Girl(s) (2005), Wrecks (2005), and In a Dark Dark House (2007). In addition to the plays and screenplays written by LaBute, Bigsby also includes a discussion of Nurse Betty (2000), the first big-budget movie LaBute directed but did not write.
Those interested in LaBute will welcome this book as a foundational resource. The plays are contextualized not only by their time period, but also by LaBute's personal and creative influences. His upbringing on a farm in Washington State, his conversion to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints at Brigham Young University and subsequent disfellowship from that church (following the publication and production of Bash: Latterday Plays) provide a background for his characters and moral focus. For all the shocking subject matter in his plays, Bigsby demonstrates that LaBute “is a moralist and his plays and films morality tales” (231). In addition, Bigsby's account of LaBute's short time in London at the Royal Court Theatre as a graduate student and his extensive exposure to both popular and international films as an adolescent provides insight into LaBute's often unpredictable thematic and stylistic choices.
Due to LaBute's extensive debts to contemporary Western playwrights and directors, scholars focusing on twentieth-century American and British theatre and film will also find value in this book. Influences of and direct tributes to playwrights such as David Mamet, Edward Bond, Paula Vogel, Sam Shepard, and Harold Pinter abound in LaBute's plays. Bigsby's study reveals the extent to which the characteristic repetition of allusions, words, and images in each separate work continues on a larger scale throughout LaBute's corpus. From Wycherley's The Country Wife to Elvis Costello's songs, LaBute's inspirations frequently reappear in various forms, delighting, or at least amusing, loyal audiences. The most comical and obvious of the repeated appearances is the inclusion of actor Aaron Eckhart in almost all of LaBute's films, even when his presence is only in the form of a photograph on a magazine cover, as is the case with the 2003 film The Shape of Things.
In addition to his comprehensive discussion of each play, story, and film, Bigsby interrogates LaBute's successful crossover from theatre into film and back again. In reference to Arthur Miller's suggestion that a playwright who chooses to become a Hollywood screenwriter is also making a Faustian pact, Bigsby provides detailed reasons for LaBute's uncommon achievement as an artist with dual loyalties, pointing out that LaBute has had the good fortune to write plays that translate well to the screen, especially under his own direction. He often uses long shots, allowing the actors to move within the frame and for their words to be the primary focus. Consequently, many of his films, especially In the Company of Men (1997), are notable for their silence and their lack of an emotion-enhancing musical score. LaBute's films are also often marked with other elements of theatricality, including relatively lengthy monologues, such as the one found in Your Friends and Neighbors (1998), and brief moments when characters break past the camera lens to address the audience, as with Evelyn's character in The Shape of Things.
LaBute's successful and subsequently lucrative career as a director and screenwriter has enabled him to continue his prolific writing for the theatre, and his explorations into theatre provide the inspiration for his innovative approaches in film. Bigsby is quick to note, however, that reviews of LaBute's works are decidedly mixed. Many audiences have difficulty “orienting to a writer whose characters do not invite empathy and whose plays explore the darker aspects of the human psyche” (35). Bigsby cites critical responses to LaBute's work throughout the book, but academic responses are notably absent. With few scholarly examinations of LaBute to reference, Bigsby relies heavily on LaBute's own commentary found in the introductions to published plays and in filmed and published interviews. These quotations are seamlessly interwoven in the text and provide valuable insight into LaBute's focus on such issues as gender disconnect, verbal, physical, and emotional violence, and other prominent social and artistic concerns.
In the past decade, LaBute's voice has been gaining strength, and Bigsby's analysis of that voice is overdue. As LaBute continues to write and direct, Neil LaBute: Stage and Cinema will be a resource for scholars, actors, directors, and enthusiasts seeking to understand the thematic and stylistic evolution and creative process of this multitalented theatre, film, and literary artist.
