No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 September 2004
Owen Gutfreund explores the development of auto-oriented transportation systems and urban sprawl in the United States in the twentieth century. The first chapter chronicles the development of federal highway policy and the “automobility” that it induced. Automobility refers to automobile-oriented transportation systems provided to motorists on a toll-free and subsidized basis. The remaining chapters document the effects of policy-induced automobility on three disparate communities: a major city (Denver, Colorado); a small town (Middlebury, Vermont); and a small sun belt community that benefited from federally subsidized infrastructure (Smyrna, Tennessee).
Gutfreund does a good job summarizing the development of federal highway policy. He chronicles the role of auto interests and highway planners in creating the federal-aid highway program and the Interstate Highway System. The evolution of the rural bias in federal highway policy that promoted rural highway construction at the expense of urban road construction is well documented. Gutfreund also describes the controversies over highway financing involving the level of user fees and persistent efforts by auto interests to dedicate any and all user taxes to highway construction.
Gutfreund is at his best when analyzing the ever-widening gap between highway costs and revenues that resulted from capping auto user taxes at woefully inadequate levels. Policies that promoted automobility cultivated expectations among American motorists that they ought to be able to drive wherever they wanted, whenever they wanted, at little or no cost, and free of interference from other drivers. These expectations fueled the demand for more highways. At the same time, limited user fees and policy biases restrained revenues and created persistent crises in communities that had to cope with the need to build more highways with limited funds. Automobility also curtailed and eliminated alternative transportation system such as public transit.
Large cities such as Denver were excluded from meaningful federal highway funding. As a consequence, highways on the urban periphery were constructed with federal subsidies. Population growth on the periphery exploded while growth in the city lagged. Jobs left the city and the urban economic base deteriorated. At the same time, traffic congestion increased due to the sprawl at the periphery. With user taxes capped, property tax increases limited and federal monies unavailable, the city turned to debt financing in its battle to keep up with automobility.
Middlebury was a small town transformed by highway policies that promoted auto use, but excluded the town from federal funding. Rural highway improvements brought traffic congestion, but the town's “urban” status excluded it from the federal-aid highway program. In addition, Vermont's need for state matching funds to fund the Interstate System dried up all state highway aid for the community. With user taxes kept deliberately low, Middlebury fought an ongoing and largely unsuccessful battle to cope with the widening gap between highway costs and available revenues.
On the other hand, Smyrna benefited from these same policies. A small rural community in 1920, Smyrna was transformed by federally subsidized infrastructure. The initial subsidy came from the federal-aid highway program. This was followed by subsidized construction through New Deal policies, military expenditures at a nearby air base, and finally construction of the Interstate Highway System. With subsidized highways, electricity, and water and sewer systems in place, Smyrna was able to weather the closing of the air base in 1965. It went on to attract outside firms to relocate to Smyrna. Nissan Motors built the largest automobile assembly plant in the country in Smyrna in the 1980s. Other firms soon followed. Gutfreund characterizes Smyrna as an example of a federal industrial relocation policy in action.
If there is a weakness in Gutfreund's analysis, it is in his handling of the urban portions of the Interstate Highway System. These urban components of the system were built at tremendous cost, despite the long-standing rural bias in the federal-aid highway program. The Interstate Highway System did not simply circumvent cities but rather incorporated very expensive urban radial routes that went through cities. In addition, the inclusion of these costly urban components created an important impediment that delayed construction of the Interstate Highway System. The urban sections of the Interstate were more than “lip service” (p. 56). And if no one was pushing for these urban freeways (p. 45), why were they included? The lobbying record is not complete here.
This point does not detract from the compelling case that Gutfreund makes for attributing urban sprawl to policies that promoted and subsidized auto use while inhibiting other transportation alternatives. This is an excellent work that will be indispensable to scholars seeking to understand the transformation of the twentieth-century urban landscape. It will be of vital interest to everyone interested in understanding the forces responsible for urban sprawl and the problems that it has created.