One of the major themes of scholarship on post-authoritarian Brazil, and Latin America for that matter, is the transition from clientelism to universalism. Although clientelism assumes many different forms, it is usually defined as a system of political mobilisation and control based on the unequal exchange of votes, or support, for favours. Universalism, on the other hand, is a system whereby goods, in their various forms, are distributed not as favours, but as rights. In much of the literature on post-authoritarian Brazil, clientelism is perceived as the enemy, as a manifestation of backwardness and tradition and, more importantly, as a means of holding those who exist at the margins of society firmly in their place.
Aaron Ansell's well-written and engaging ethnography examines attempts by the newly elected Partido dos Trabalhadores (PT) to use the flagship programme Zero Hunger (Fome Zero) to educate and ultimately ‘liberate’ agricultural workers in a small town in the interior of the impoverished north-eastern state of Piauí. Based on extensive field research conducted in the early 2000s, Ansell witnesses first hand the arrival of young, idealistic and somewhat naïve PT activists as they set out to convince local, poor, largely subsistence farmers of the merits of the federal government's programme.
Zero Hunger, in its early years, consisted of many different programmes, including collective livestock rearing projects, cash cards, which became the mainstay of what was subsequently renamed Bolsa Família, and attempts to construct a shared, emancipatory identity that would encourage poor agricultural workers to bring pressure to bear on municipal, state and federal governments to claim what they were being told were their rights. Encountering resistance, or more to the point, a great deal of confusion, the government workers, according to Ansell, employed three strategies to get their message across.
The first of these is what Ansell calls ‘Induced Nostalgia’ which marked an attempt by PT activists to get local farmers to imagine and, more importantly, to reinvent a largely mythical, bygone era of collective labour and consumption that pre-dated the imposition of patron-client ties. The second is what Ansell describes as ‘Programmatic Pilgrimage’ which involved bussing large numbers of agricultural workers to the state capital in Teresina where they were encouraged to set aside their local, individualised identities in favour of a shared, post-slavery ‘Quilombola’ past. And finally, the third strategy that Ansell describes marked an attempt by PT activists to bypass and undermine local politicians, and in particular the mayor, by placing the control of the administration of Fome Zero in the hands of an elected and relatively autonomous committee.
Faced with the failure, or at least the limited success of these strategies, the PT activists were forced to reassess their views of what Ansell calls ‘intimate hierarchies’, which are the relationships and networks of relationships that agricultural workers use to survive. As Ansell points out, we are not talking here about vote buying, or the more instrumental and naked forms of exchange that are often associated with clientelism, but rather the long-term, lopsided friendships between elites and masses according to which gifts or, in the language of clientelism, favours are exchanged without any sort of explicit tallying or calculation.
This is not to say that the PT activists had no impact on the agricultural workers they were sent to transform. First of all, the provision of financial and technical assistance for various livestock projects did improve the economic situation of many farmers in the community. Second, the interaction between activists and local farmers also empowered women in a way that questioned, if not undermined the long-standing, patriarchal foundation of households. Third, the emphasis on a collective racial past, whether imagined or not, did spur local residents, nonetheless, to think of themselves as part of a larger regional underclass. And finally, the emphasis of Fome Zero in general on rights and citizenship changed the way people perceived of patronage in the sense that it effectively ‘condemned commodified (short term) vote-buying and sought to build moral, long-term relations of reciprocity’ (p. 188).
The strength of Ansell's study is that, rather than examining concepts like clientelism, and universalism, in the abstract, it gives you a sense of how these different modes of social and political thought and action play out on the ground. This is particularly interesting in the context of the somewhat misguided efforts by the PT to change the way poor agricultural workers go about their lives. Not misguided in the sense that they are disingenuous or misplaced, but in the sense that they are grounded in a vision of the poor that is a fair distance from reality.
Finally, unlike a lot of ethnographies, this is not one that is dominated by the author's voice. On the contrary, throughout the book we get to hear from a wide variety of actors, from poor agricultural workers, to local politicians, to out of town administrators and activists. This is no small achievement in a community where being seen talking to one person can close off access to another. Ansell proves that he is a skilled ethnographer by the very fact that he can bring so many different voices to the table.
