Brian McLaren, an assistant professor of architecture at the University of Washington, has produced a magnificent and scholarly work to add to the growing number of books on colonial architecture. However, this is not an ordinary description of building designs and city plans in a colonial setting. Using extensive and often esoteric source material in Italian, McLaren has succeeded in producing a compelling theoretical work based on the Libyan case.
The book's main thesis is that the tourist experience of Libya existed in the space in which the modernization of Italy's colony and the preservation of its indigenous culture were negotiated. Tourism depended on a modern infrastructure: ports, road networks and transportation, and up-to-date facilities and institutions. Tourism in fact represented the third wave of colonization after military conquest and the creation of transportation infrastructure. At the same time, tourism demanded the attractions of an exotic “native” culture carefully choreographed in architecture adopting stereotypical, historical forms.
McLaren bases his argument on four distinct theoretical strands. First, he adopts “ambivalence,” a central concept in Homi Bhabha's postcolonial theory: that colonial encounters should not be seen as a simple dialectical process but rather as one in which contradictory elements emerge and coexist ambivalently. Second, from the fields of art and architectural history, “ambivalent modernism” also draws on analyses of architectural modernism under fascism, in which it was possible for proponents to hold simultaneously revolutionary and reactionary positions on social and architectural questions. Third, McLaren looks to tourism studies on questions of originality and authenticity, with “staged authenticity” fitting the Libyan case. Fourth and finally, he suggests that Antonio Gramsci's national–popular and folkloristic provincialism provides a useful frame for examining the colonial discourse in Libya and the architecture of tourism specifically.
The structure of the book derives from McLaren's main theoretical premise, ambivalence. The first two chapters discuss the modernization program of the Italian fascist government in its North African colony and its relationship with the tourist industry. The next two chapters consider preservation initiatives and their connection to tourism. Finally, the last two chapters examine the relationship between the modernization and preservation tendencies.
Especially intriguing is McLaren's comparison of the work of Carlo Enrico Rava and Florestano di Fausto, architects designing hotels in Libya in the 1920s and 1930s. Rava, a rationalist, advocated adopting indigenous forms and materials to create an architecture well suited to the Mediterranean climate. His hotel near the excavations of Leptis Magna employed a courtyard vernacular design, verandas and other shading devices, asymmetrical massing, and unadorned facades indicating interior functions. It was thoroughly a modern interpretation of indigenous design. Di Fausto, whose approach was ultimately favored by colonial authorities, directly mimicked traditional forms to create a simulacrum of authenticity while providing for tourists' diverse needs. Rava and di Fausto represented the two sides of ambivalent modernity in Libya, but both architects shared the belief in Italian supremacy and indeed, in the Roman origins of what was valued in Libya.
Architecture of Tourism in Italian Colonial Libya: An Ambivalent Modernism will inevitably be compared to the encyclopedic work by Jean-Louis Cohen and Monique Eleb, Casablanca: Colonial Myths and Architectural Ventures (New York: Monacelli, 2002). Although more tightly focused on one particular type of architecture, hotels and other tourist facilities, McLaren's is a more broadly interesting work for its sophisticated presentation of the Italian colonial enterprise in Libya and its intriguing theoretical propositions. Its weakness is that the Libyans themselves are merely bystanders, a point he acknowledges. One is reminded of the work of Mercedes Volait in neighboring Egypt and in particular her documentation of the lively debate within the nascent Egyptian architectural professional on the same issues that preoccupied Carlo Enrico Rava and other Italian rationalists. (For instance, see Volait's “L'Architecture Moderne en Egypte et la Revue al-Imara 1939–1959,” Cairo: CEDEJ Dossier 4, 1987.)
The book is written in clear and elegant prose and is well illustrated with architectural drawings, old photographs, and reproductions of tourist brochures, posters, and postcards. Architectural history and theory books are ironically often poorly produced; the University of Washington Press should be commended for the superior design and reproduction of images in McLaren's fine book.
