West and South Asia, from the Balkans to Bengal, experienced a period of strong political control and cultural flowering that lasted for several centuries under the rule and patronage of three Muslim dynasties. Each empire, Ottoman, Safavid and Mughal, reached its peak within the sixteenth to seventeenth centuries. The rulers and central institutions of each have always attracted scholarly interest, but attention has turned in recent years to some hitherto neglected aspects of their histories, for example, to the haram, to provincial and local diversities, to non-elites, to popular religion, and to questions on the ideological underpinning of dynastic claims. A new willingness among political historians to draw from the insights of cultural historians, and from art historians in particular, is drawing attention to the symbolism of power as expressed in buildings and paintings. A spate of exhibitions, all generating gloriously illustrated catalogues, has encouraged close contact with the artifacts of empire. Television programmes and new secondary school and college courses are making these empires much better known to a public brought up hitherto, if not on western history alone, on a nodding acquaintance only, and usually in junior classes at that, with the pre-Islamic ‘classical’ empires of Persia and India. Dale's volume reflects the needs of such wider readerships in contributing to a new series that, focusing on ‘particular periods’ and ‘turning points’ in the evolution of Asian history, is specifically intended for use in the ‘classroom’.
This volume is innovative, too, in making a break with the hitherto separate treatment (some art historical works and general histories of Islam excepted), of each of these ‘Muslim empires’, for Dale's object is to show that a comparative study of all three will benefit understandings of the nature and workings of each, particularly by emphasising as well as their common roots and characteristics, some important differences between them. Interestingly, another similarly titled history, Islamic Gunpowder Empires: Ottomans, Safavids, and Mughals (Boulder, 2010), by Douglas Streusand, has appeared very shortly after Dale's volume. Like Dale's, Streusand's is also intended primarily for student use. Such a happy coincidence suggests a new awareness of the advantages of a comparative approach. Similar though these two titles are, however, their authors have adopted rather different strategies to convey within the limit of about 300 pages the complexities of three long-lived and extensive empires. Streusand, after two introductory chapters, treats each empire separately, finishing in the eighteenth century, and reserving many of his comparative comments for a concluding chapter. Dale, in contrast, has taken on the perhaps more demanding task of structuring his volume thematically within an overall chronology that, stretching from the tenth to the twentieth centuries, gives due weight to all these regions, both before and after their imperial peaks, as well as to what he calls each dynasty's ‘golden age’.
Another difference concerns the thematic foci of each volume. What to omit was bound to be a major problem for both these authors since ‘space’ was presumably strictly limited. No doubt the decisions each took partly reflected personal interests. In common is the attention both pay to the currently topical and interrelated questions of imperial legitimacy and ideology. Dale plays to his already well-proven strengths on the commercial links forged between these empires in a chapter on their economies that is mainly concerned with trade, but he also contributes valuably to another highly topical concern with the varied cultural activities that flourished under imperial patronage. Streusand's foci are, instead, the more familiar ones long associated with any ruler's expansion and administration of vast territories. Unlike Dale, he gives cultural and intellectual history only brief attention. For his is first and foremost the work of a military historian who in making ‘gunpowder empires’ synonymous with ‘Islamic’ in his title (though he later restates the connection as ‘empires of the gunpowder era’ not ‘empires created by gunpowder weapons’) makes his own interests very clear. Symbolism being another popular theme of recent studies of these empires, it is revealing of things to come that the cover illustration chosen for Dale's volume is a madrasa, for Streusand's a battle scene. Dale's volume alone receives further attention here, but the almost simultaneous publication of two volumes both opening up new, and different, comparative perspectives on empires is sure to be welcomed by teachers and students of the Middle East and South Asia.
To pull off a comparative study successfully is no easy task. The height of empire for all three empires fell within the longue durée of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Yet, the Ottomans having tasted power much earlier than the Safavids and Mughals, then ‘peaked’ in the first half of the sixteenth century, the other two dynasties experiencing their ‘golden ages’ only later in that century, the Mughals arguably only in the mid-seventeenth century. Such disjuncture in the chronology of imperial evolution Dale meets by a careful structuring of his volume that embeds the various stages of expansion, administrative consolidation and cultural florescence in a broadly chronological framework within which apposite points of comparison and contrast between the empires can be made. The point is well made in the Introduction that the sources extant for each empire differ in ways that must affect both the questions asked and the answers reached. Ottoman archives yield rich central and local administrative and legal documents that are lacking especially for the Safavids; the literature of intra-religious debate is, however, particularly rich for the Safavids, while the Mughal dynasts and their chroniclers were famously prodigious in the writing of autobiographies and dynastic histories. The personalities of the most influential emperors come out strongly in this unashamedly top-down study, Dale's earlier work on the Mughal emperor Babur's autobiography and poetry certainly giving him the credentials for placing the ‘individual in history’ in appropriate political structures. Sulaiman I, Abbas I, Akbar and Shah Jahan contribute a strong quartet of success stories, but others, both earlier and later, though lacking their ‘transformative’ capacities, also receive due attention.
Overcoming any problems of chronological disjuncture and disparate sources, the study identifies these contiguous empires as comprising an “imperial cultural zone within the broader Islamic civilization” (p. 3) but also shows why, and in what respects, each empire, while sharing a common civilisation, developed “idiosyncratic regional cultures” (p. 135) and “distinct histories and characteristics” (p. 77). The roots of a common civilisation consist here not in Islamic doctrine or practice per se but in their founders being “joint legatees of the Turco-Mongol, Perso-Islamic political and cultural heritage of the preceding centuries” (p. 49), sharing a pool of linguistic, literary and religious codes and preferences. These shared heritages, yet with important differences over time and place, are illustrated, among several other ways, by showing how the various emperors, their chroniclers and artists established claims to dynastic legitimacy. Military success over other tribes was at first enough to legitimate Ottoman rule, but the seizure of Constantinople from Byzantium and later victories over the Mamluks which transferred Mecca and Medina to Ottoman control, justified the assertion of imperial legitimacy as Sultan-i Rum and with the assumption of the caliphate, as Padishah-i Islam. Particularly interesting is the disentangling of the use made by the Safavids of their “dual Sufi and Shi'i religious identities”, yet also of pre-Islamic Iranian imperial rhetoric, mainly Sasanian, to boost their own image both as recipients of a divinely bestowed charismatic essence and as “Padishah of the World” (pp. 52; 79–80). Though both these dynasties drew from an impressive array of tribal, imperial and religious sources of legitimation, Dale nevertheless has Ottomans as well as Safavids suffering from ‘lineage envy’ of the early Mughals’ easy recourse for legitimation to their own direct blood descent from the Timurid-Chingizid conquerors. Though the Timurid link remained strong, Akbar owed his outstanding success in India to projecting himself more broadly as an ‘Indian monarch’ by displaying a profound interest in Hinduism, by encouraging sull-i kull, ‘peace with all’ other religious communities, and by incorporating non-Muslim elites, notably Rajputs, in state service. The successful assertion of legitimacy, reinforced verbally and visually in all three empires by court historians and artists, comes over here as at least as important, and certainly as interesting, as military, administrative and economic acumen for understanding of successful empire building.
Other differences are strongly stressed to give a critical comparative edge to the treatment of each epoch and theme. Examples from among many are the Safavids’ weaknesses, especially economic, even at their own height of power, relative to the other two empires; the importance of military slavery to the Ottomans and Safavids in contrast to the complete non-dependence of the Mughal military machine on slaves (though there was certainly domestic slavery); differences in the upbringing of royal princes, especially their confinement in the haram in the later Safavid and Ottoman periods, which became thereafter a significant factor in dynastic weakening; and the emergence of a powerful and autonomous Shi'i ‘ulama class in Safavid Persia, in contrast to strict state control of the ‘ulama by the Sunni Ottomans and a via media preferred by most Mughals that involved neither subordination of the ‘ulama to the state nor clerical autonomy. Two full chapters give detailed attention to forms of cultural patronage, and particularly to religious buildings, paintings and poetry that, inspired by Persian precedent, were often developed by the Ottomans and Mughals as “regional variants of their shared Iranian artistic legacy” (p. 176).
The author somewhat disarms any possible reservations by explaining his process of selection in the Introduction. Some, particularly in India, will no doubt want to take issue, nevertheless, with the title ‘Muslim Empires’, explained here as empires “ruled by Muslim dynasties, whose individual monarchs embraced Muhammad's revelation and, to varying degrees, observed the tenets of the Islamic faith” (p. 3) The civilisation these rulers patronised “cannot be equated solely with rigid, narrowly doctrinal interpretations of the faith”, and their courts, Dale suggests, show aspects of Islamic society in a positive light that the twenty-first century western reader seldom encounters in the media (pp. 1–2). Thus the ‘Muslim’ adjectival has a positive purpose in the redressing of some prevailing negative stereotypes based on ignorance of history. Some may question, however, a concentration on the emperors and the aristocratic elites who served them, all male, to the neglect almost entirely of women, and of men of intermediate and lower social levels, apart from some merchant and service communities. The “short shrift” (the author's words) given to aristocratic women is certainly surprising, given that much recent work on the haram in all three empires is changing previous perceptions of female agency, cultural as well as political and economic. Apart from some brief references to the haram, in discussion mainly of the upbringing of princes and of royal marriage patterns, women remain invisible in these courts. One of the strengths of the volume is certainly its nuanced attention to religious architecture, poetry and painting, but some closely related patronage to music, dance, secular architecture and some literary genres other than poetry receive less attention. Such cultural forms might be brought together under the umbrella of courtly patronage within the various spaces (diwan-i khass, haram or enclosed garden) where these rulers and their nobles held majlis and other assemblies to enjoy secular forms of creativity that complement the more religion-focused activities in the kulliye mosque complexes (including madrasas, libraries, baths, hospitals and khanqahs) so effectively evoked in Dale's study.
Too modestly described as a ‘synthesis’ of the recent work of others, this comparative study certainly bears the strong mark and authority of its author's own previous research on both specialist and comparative questions concerning all three of these regions and also Central Asia. It is welcomed as being very likely to encourage students and other readers to cross the conventional frontiers of their regional or ‘area’ studies to tread the many unexplored paths that meet and diverge within and between these three great empires.
