The publication of this pathbreaking study of radical movements in pre-World War I Egypt and Syria could not have been better timed, occurring as it has on the eve of the momentous events that have engulfed virtually every Middle East state that emerged out of the ruins of the Ottoman Empire. The book highlights the hidden history of groups, mass movements, and classes that can be considered early precursors to popular movements that materialized during the period of the Anglo-French Mandates and have more recently been mythically caricaturized as the Arab street.
The Eastern Mediterranean challenges three major entrenched assumptions about 19th-century Arab modernity: first, that the 19th-century Arab nahḍa was basically a nationalist and predominantly bourgeois movement of Syrian-Lebanese intellectuals and immigrants; second, that it was a regional movement unconnected to global ideological upheavals; and third, that it was a literary political Arabist movement devoid of a social agenda and a revolutionary perspective. Khuri-Makdisi casts her work as a new interpretation of the nahḍa by systematically throwing light on previously unexamined or underexamined groups and sources. These include syndicalist and labor movements, theater and dramatic groups, municipal archives, migratory networks linking the Syrian littoral to Egypt and urban centers in the new world (notably, São Paolo, Buenos Aires, and New York), and—most important—the biographical trajectories of scores of radical writers and activists, many of whom have been relegated to oblivion by the ascendancy of nationalist discourse.
The careers and intellectual output of Farah Anton, Amin Rihani, Sayyid Rida, and many others are re-examined in light of their contributions to the creation of a hitherto unknown socialist and radical discourse. The author unveils a silenced and marginalized narrative whose impact is crucial to the understanding of the political and intellectual milieu of the Middle East and its urban environment at the turn of the 19th century. She attributes this silencing to a number of factors, including the hegemony of post-World War I nationalist historiography, the triumph of the fragmented regional states and their local elite narratives, and the preponderance of studies examining intellectual history through the restricted prism of the press and elite memoirs. Given the considerable presence of illiteracy and censorship, Khuri-Makdisi argues that the printed word “was certainly not the only vehicle for the articulation of radicalism—many radical ideas were expressed on stage, in coffeehouses, and in mutual aid societies and in night schools” (p. 168). And even though many leading figures in these radical associations, especially those from the press and the theater, initially came from religious or marginalized Levantine ethnic minorities (Italians, Armenians, and shāmī emigrants in Egypt), the author makes a convincing case that early on, and certainly by the 1880s, the movement—or rather movements—became indigenous and indigenized, involving a plethora of Islamic reformers, working class militants, and anarcho-syndicalists.
It would be a mistake, in Khuri-Makdisi's view, to look at the 19th-century nahḍa primarily within the prism of Arab national resurgence because many of its leading exponents were also involved in radical and revolutionary local and global movements. Between Cairo, Beirut, and Alexandria, Alexandria seems to have been the lynchpin of these movements. It exemplified the synthesis of international and regional currents, which gave rise to a creative and highly original cosmopolitan urban milieu.
The author's zeal to demonstrate the impact of early radicalism in Syria and Egypt occasionally leads her to extrapolate too much influence from obscure and minor contributors. In her long discussion of the labor movement in Mount Lebanon and the leading role of Faris Mushriq and Jirji Baz's newspaper al-Nur, for example, Khuri-Makdisi concludes that through its advocacy of workers’ rights and control over the productive process al-Nur pushed new limits toward a radical conception of labor. She adds that
this conceptualization of workers as having bargaining power was a result of two trends: on one hand it was the result of the realization of very locally rooted facts, the specific economic situation of Syria and the realities of European penetration; on the other, it marked the transcending of this very local reality . . . since it was tied to the articulation of a more abstract conceptualization of labor, which indicated a more sophisticated grasp of economic principles (pp. 101–102).
Yet the material that the author quotes previously in support of this conclusion is more indicative of a social democratic, pacifist, and corporatist (almost charitable) tendency among those same labor leaders, whose objective was to conclude a working agreement with the owners of the enterprises precisely to avoid a head-on clash with labor in the form of prolonged labor agitation. “Our intention is not to trigger a rebellion,” she quotes them as saying, “or a strike between the company and these workers . . . but we ask the administration to assist these poor people [to] give them what they deserve and make their rights equivalent to the obligations” (p. 101). Here quietism and avoidance of class conflict is given a cover of radical sophistication.
To be sure, Khuri-Makdisi does not posit a subaltern against an elite history but rather a hidden, layered, and complex network of intellectual discourse undertaken by a class of artisans and middle-class professionals, many of whom were secure in their economic status and agitated for a social order free from class exploitation and state oppression. Their instruments were mutual aid societies, night schools, a radical press, and—most significantly—a popular theatrical movement, which acted as the “press of the masses.”
The originality of The Eastern Mediterranean lies in an investigatory paradigm that seeks the regional and global networks in which these ideas and movements operated. Through this paradigm, the author reinterprets the nature of the shāmī immigrant presence in Egypt and the New World, as well as the linkages between a radical Levantine intelligentsia and socialist and anarchist currents in southern Europe and the Americas. The focus of her analysis is the triadic relationship between Alexandria (“the mother of Eastern Mediterranean radicalism”), Cairo, and Beirut—cities that Khuri-Makdisi terms “nodal centers” of a regional network. But the choice of these three cities is both illuminating and problematic. Cairo, Beirut, and Alexandria were cosmopolitan cities that had a vibrant press, a nascent theatre, and an intellectual class whose members vigorously debated radical ideas in constant dialogue with Darwinist, socialist, and anarchist intellectuals in Europe. (They also debated women's emancipation and Islamic reform—two movements that receive much less attention by the author.) These cities were linked by two crucial movements that bonded them. The first was the great migration of Syrian merchants, professionals, and intellectuals in the latter half of the 19th century to escape press censorship and repression, creating what became known as the shāmī presence in Egypt. Less known (and not treated by the author) is a reverse Egyptian and heavily proletarian migration to Syria and Palestine beginning with the campaign of Ibrahim Pasha in the 1830s and continuing unabated until the end of the century. The second movement was that for Ottoman decentralization, which was based in Cairo and sought to redefine the High Porte's relationship with Syria in favor of an Egyptian presence.
Yet Khuri-Makdisi's choice of cities is also problematic because of its exclusions. Because her study is framed by a paradigm addressing the placement of a globalized network of movements in the Eastern Mediterranean, one is struck by the absence of Damascus and Istanbul, the two cities along with Aleppo that most exemplified and reflected the dilemmas of Ottoman identity in greater Syria between the two constitutional revolutions of 1876 and 1908. It is illustrative that when Shibli Shumayyil, one of Khuri-Makdisi's heroes and a towering figure of socialist and Darwinian thought in the 19th century, was expelled from the Syrian Protestant College's medical school in Beirut in the 1880s, he took refuge in Istanbul rather than Cairo, where many of his comrades, including Jurji Zaydan and others, migrated. Although Khuri-Makdisi makes important observations in regard to the significant contributions of Midhat Pasha to the creation of public spaces in Syria, and to the contributions of local Ottoman officials, such as the mutasarrif of Mount Lebanon Muzaffar Pasha, to the expansion of night schools for workers in a number of regions (p. 97), these observations are not integrated into her main thesis. Also, one notices a rich and textured treatment of radical groups in Mount Lebanon but a total absence of very important provincial urban centers such as Latakia and Jaffa, both of which exhibited early labor radicalism (tobacco farmers in the former and port workers in the latter). Would the picture have been different if she had examined debates about similar radical preoccupations in the important avant garde Istanbuli journal Servet-i Funun and the Damascene press?
Khuri-Makdisi concludes her study with a short but intriguing reference to the devastating impact of World War I and the end of the Ottoman Empire on the possibilities embedded in these radical groups. This work can be read at different levels: as a revisionist history of the nahḍa, as a window to the world, lives, and times of pre-Communist Levantine revolutionary thinkers, and as a study in global networks of 19th-century radical thought linking the Eastern Mediterranean through its nodal urban centers.
Khuri-Makdisi's command of Arabic, Ottoman Turkish, Italian, and French sources enabled her to reveal lost and, to many readers, unknown facets of the cultural life of the Arab East. The book is bound to become a standard reference on 19th-century Arab radical thought and its Mediterranean and global linkages. Scholars of the nahḍa will be enriched by her meticulous unearthing of important but silenced voices of the early labor, socialist, and anarchist movements as well as early precursors to the theater and the press.
