Barth's ecclesiology has attracted criticism in recent years from proponents of what Healy calls the ‘new ecclesiology’: those who strongly affirm the significance of the historical, concrete church and its practices for theological accounts of the Christian life.Footnote 1 For such theologians, Barth's preoccupation with the assent of faith, over and above the ecclesial setting in which this takes shape, results in a reductionist ecclesiology which fails to describe the church as a community that takes up space in the world. In this article, I will argue that Barth's reluctance to pronounce on the concrete church (what I will call his ecclesiological minimalism) can be read as pneumatological in function, that is, it is how Barth ensures the freedom of the Holy Spirit in relation to the concrete church. By exploring this way of interpreting Barth, I will argue that his ecclesiology establishes certain theological safeguards necessary for a pastorally careful concrete ecclesiology.
The revisionist intent of this article is limited: when I say that what I will call Barth's ecclesiological minimalism has a pneumatological point, I do not mean that this is the only way of reading Barth, nor that his ecclesiology does not have some of the problematic vectors which the new ecclesiologists identify, indeed my analysis of Barth's ecclesiology will probably verge on being overly kind. My purpose in proposing a pneumatological point to Barth's ecclesiology is twofold. First, it mitigates some of the more severe readings of Barth's account of the church. My contention here is that, even if Barth can be read as denigrating the Spirit or the visible church, he needn't be read like that. The second purpose follows on from the first, namely, that it is more theologically fruitful to read Barth's ecclesiological minimalism as having a pneumatological point. If Barth does use ecclesiological minimalism to secure the freedom of the Spirit, as I will suggest, it has much to offer the proponents of the new ecclesiology in their search for a theology that is at once realistic and faithful.
Things fall apart: Barth's ‘unstable center’
Providing some further details of the charges against Barth will give some rationale for why I explain Barth's ecclesiology in the way that I do. The concrete ecclesiological approaches I have mentioned evince a very strong Barthian influence, particularly as mediated through Hans Frei and the Yale School. This is most often obvious in their reliance on narrative as a theological trope, but also in their insistence on the inseparability of theology and ethics, and the general scope of their theological interests. Their appropriation of Barth is, on the whole, approving. However, despite Barth's considerable influence for these new concrete ecclesiologies, he is frequently found lacking in two key areas: ecclesiology and pneumatology.
Hauerwas’ Gifford Lectures of 2001 made an unlikely move in enshrining Karl Barth as the hero of the natural theology story. Hauerwas makes Barth's christocentric disordering of the epistemological priorities of modernity central to his project. However, in as much as he appropriates Barth's epistemological move, he also criticises him and moves away from what he sees as Barth's failings towards a stronger account of the church's involvement in our knowledge of the world, and thus a stronger role for the church in the process of salvation. Hauerwas finds Barth insufficiently catholic because he fails to provide an account of the Holy Spirit's work, and Hauerwas finds his account of the church's role in the economy of salvation overly cautious.Footnote 2 Barth is not concrete enough: he cannot ‘acknowledge that, through the work of the Holy Spirit, we are made part of God's care of the world through the church’.Footnote 3
Hauerwas’ quarrel with Barth is not new. His analysis in With the Grain of the Universe relies on two articles, first on Joseph Mangina's ‘Bearing the Marks of Jesus: The Church in the Economy of Salvation in Barth and Hauerwas’, and also on Nicholas Healy's ‘The Logic of Karl Barth's Ecclesiology: Analysis, Assessment and Proposed Modifications’.Footnote 4 Healy argues that Barth's high ecclesiology, though developed in the context of credo in Spiritum Sanctum, is an outworking of his high christology, and it means high claims for the church in terms of it truly being the body of Christ.Footnote 5 However, he notes that the way this belief interacts with Barth's sense of the church as a contingent event, as people may or may not respond to the Holy Spirit, leaves the church vacillating between reality and unreality.Footnote 6 Though intended as a check on triumphalism, Healy argues that Barth's division of the church into die wirkliche Kirche (the true spiritual church) and die Scheinkirche (the earthly apparent-church), with Christ the only guarantor of the former and our human action causally unrelated to the ‘event’ of the church, results in an abstract and reductionist ecclesiology.Footnote 7 Importantly for Healy's own agenda, he argues that Barth's consistent prioritising of the christological rule makes it difficult to see the church's response to Christ as concretely human.Footnote 8
Mangina takes Healy's argument further still, arguing that for Barth the cross is a decisive end to history, such that there is no real role left for the church or the Holy Spirit.Footnote 9 The only task of the Spirit is to witness to Jesus, and the sole content of its witness is Christ, such that the Spirit is not a salvific entity in its own right.Footnote 10 Pointing first to the role left to faith by Barth's soteriological objectivism (namely that faith is internal and analytic rather than external and synthetic in our salvation), and then to a thought experiment where Barth wonders what things would be like if the resurrection had not happened, Mangina concludes that Barth's theology routinely exalts the cross at the expense of making post-resurrection history superfluous.Footnote 11 Mangina goes so far as to suggest that Barth's treatment of the church is similar to his treatment of Israel after the resurrection: ‘If Israel disappears in a negative Aufhebung at the cross, the Christian community is positively established – and at the same moment deprived of its contingent historical identity.’Footnote 12 Finally, Mangina outlines the way in which Barth's high view of revelation and scripture locates apostolic witness outside the believing community and situates it entirely within the self-witness of Christ through the Spirit, which renders the church unnecessary.Footnote 13
Reinhard Hütter's critique of Barth in his Suffering Divine Things: Theology as Church Practice follows similar lines. Barth's account of the Spirit's action is developed along Chalcedonian lines. In Christ, the Holy Spirit holds together difference in his fully divine and fully human natures; so, too, the Spirit is responsible for holding together divine and human action. Hütter writes ‘The crucial problem of the “center” thus conceived is that it is unstable, that is, that it lacks any unequivocal referent, quite unlike the original Christological “life setting” of the Chalcedonian definition . . . The construction does not provide for the Holy Spirit to tie itself to such a confession or for such a confession to express human action “in” the Spirit such that the confession itself might be understood as a work of the Holy Spirit.’Footnote 14 In short, Barth is not concrete enough.Footnote 15
The charge seems to be that Barth does not claim enough for the church. The problem with Barth's emphasis on the momentary nature of grace and the unpredictable, ‘event’ nature of the wirkliche Kirche is that it cuts short any account of the community of the church as anything but casually related to salvation. Quite simply, Barth doesn't need the concrete church as much as the new ecclesiologists think he ought to. By contrast, the new ecclesiology typically has quite robust claims for the importance of the concrete church: Joseph Mangina asserts that the church is ‘the binding medium in which faith takes place. The medium is, if not the message, the condition of possibility of grasping the message in its truth.’Footnote 16
The case for ecclesiological minimalism
Anyone familiar with the new ecclesiology or arguments over Barth's treatment of the church will be aware that Nicholas Healy's article ‘Karl Barth's Ecclesiology Reconsidered’ revises his earlier interpretation of Barth, and addresses some of the concerns of the new ecclesiologists. My concern is that Healy's second article on Barth has received little attention, while his first critical paper on Barth is increasingly taken as the natural position on Barth for concrete ecclesiologists without further ado. In ‘Karth Barth's Ecclesiology Reconsidered’, Healy proposes that the reason Hauerwas (and others) disagree with Barth over anthropology and pneumatology may be because of their disagreement with him over the church. ‘In my view, Hauerwas and those who raise similar concerns about Barth have not necessarily misread or misunderstood Barth, or if they have, that is not the most interesting issue between them. Rather, they disagree with him in significant ways, and any misreading of Barth seems to be more of a consequence than the premise of their disagreement.’Footnote 17 That is, the new ecclesiologies come to Barth with an already formed ecclesiology of their own which is the source of the disagreement, rather than their ecclesiology proceeding constructively from a critical engagement with Barth.
How fair are the criticisms of the new ecclesiology? On a quick survey of Barth's sections on the church, the concerns of the new ecclesiology certainly seem justified. There seem to be many instances where Barth says things about the church that, perhaps rightly, should worry any concrete ecclesiologist. In his reconsideration of Barth's ecclesiology, Healy presents what Barth might say in self-defence against such criticisms. His focus is on the active connotations of the concept ‘knowledge’ in Barth (III/3, IV/1), the idea of the church as cooperating and corresponding with Christ (III/3) and Barth's account of sanctification and witness in community (IV/2, IV/3).Footnote 18 Healy's broader account of Barth's ecclesiology is closer to the view I would like to articulate, and a good corrective to the impression one gets from Hauerwas and Mangina of Barth's ecclesiology, which I have already suggested is too narrow. However, there are enough remarks about the church in the Church Dogmatics alone to construct several different (and conflicting) views of the church from Barth's theology. Arguably more important than looking at what Barth says is looking at how he says it. Can we describe Barth's reticence to ascribe a fulsome role to the church as pneumatologically orientated ecclesiological minimalism? By this, I mean that Barth's caution over the place of the church has the function of ensuring the freedom of the Holy Spirit, as well as having pastoral uses.Footnote 19 And if we can describe Barth in this way, is that a good thing?
In his defence of Barth's ethics from Hauerwas’ criticisms, Nigel Biggar writes:
we know of one reason of principle why Barth would have deliberately eschewed depicting the Christian life in detail: his methodological axiom that, since Christian life has no independent existence, it should not become an independent object of thought. The motive behind Barth's espousal of this principle is the belief that even to think of the Christian life apart from the dynamic relationship with God that constitutes it is bound to lead to the supposition that such life is ontically absolute.Footnote 20
In what follows, I will seek to show that Barth's methodological axiom – what I will describe as his ecclesiological minimalism – is helpful for concrete ecclesiology, not just insofar as it prevents us idolising the concrete in the way Biggar suggests, but also because the freedom of the Spirit that Barth ensures in this way is necessary for a pastorally careful ecclesiology.
Sketching Barth's thought on the church inevitably produces a rather cubist picture: in taking account of all the contexts in which Barth writes about the church, one ends up presenting far more facets than would be normally visible in any single view of his theology. My presentation here is restricted to how the church fits into the wider theological context in which he places it each time. The aim of this is to show how the theological contexts in which Barth describes the church allow him to create ‘space’ for the Holy Spirit, while refusing to finally identify the Spirit's work with any specifically described ecclesial construct. In particular, I seek to show that Barth's use of the resurrection as a theological setting for describing the church establishes a space for the working of the Holy Spirit which preserves its freedom in relation to the pre-eschaton church. Barth's description of both Christ's resurrection and the life of the church as contingent allows him to preserve the Spirit's freedom in relation to the church, while maintaining a strong actualism with regard to the Spirit's presence and action therein. I will argue that the theological point of Barth's methodology is to focus on the Spirit as the one who freely holds together difference. This pneumatological move squares Barth's focus not on the concrete church in and of itself, but on the dynamic relationship between the concrete church of pre-eschaton uncertainty and struggle, and the living presence of the ascended Christ at the right hand of the Father.
The church in doctrinal context
The church is founded on Jesus’ resurrection.Footnote 21 In God's raising of Jesus from the grave, the fullness of God's victory over death achieved in the crucifixion is revealed, and humanity's complete reconciliation with God is accomplished.Footnote 22 God chooses to divide the one event of Jesus’ glorification into two: the resurrection reveals God's glory in a hidden, provisional way and it will only be revealed wholly at the end of time in the final revelation of Jesus’ Lordship over all creation.Footnote 23 Jesus’ resurrection from the dead, unlike the public event of his crucifixion, is not available to historical scrutiny; like the disciples, we can only be convinced of its truth by the working of the Spirit.Footnote 24 Just as the resurrection is the now and not-yet of Jesus’ glorification, so it is the pledge of humanity's hope, and so we see that not-yet future hope already present in the Easter proclamation.Footnote 25 Jesus’ ascension to the right hand of the Father shows the reality of his Lordship, and it marks the beginning of the church's time.Footnote 26 The church is truly the earthly historical form of Christ, the environment of the man Jesus, but Christ enthroned at God's right hand is the only guarantor of the church's reality as such.Footnote 27
So, the church hurries from the tomb of Christ's resurrection, through the time God graciously gives it for faith and witness, all the while waiting for Jesus’ coming in glory.Footnote 28 God could have ended history on Easter Sunday, with all the fullness of reconciliation achieved in Christ. However, God's concrete, historical and particular grace revealed in the person of Jesus is not tyrannical or abstract, but calls out for a response from human hearts of joyful faith and thankfulness.Footnote 29 God is waiting for the church and, with the church, the world.Footnote 30 The knowledge of God's decision about us in Christ, given by the Spirit, should bring about in us a joyful response of thanks and gratitude, which should grow as God reveals his grace to us more and more.Footnote 31 Where God's promise finds faith by creating faith, that is, where the Spirit awakens us to the knowledge of Easter Day, the church comes into life.Footnote 32 There, waiting and hurrying, Christians participate in the resurrection's particular and provisional witness, and await the full revelation of God's glory in Christ at the end of time. The witness Christians give in this way, their provisional representation of the sanctification of all humanity in Christ through the Spirit, is not just made possible, but necessary.Footnote 33 Because our response in faith is a complete gift from God, and because God has already decided our salvation, the church is not part of God's revelation as such, and God does not strictly need the church for his revelation.Footnote 34 Rather, the church participates in Jesus’ self-witness in the Holy Spirit by being a reflection of his glory, a shadowing forth of Jesus as the head of his body on earth.Footnote 35
God is patiently waiting for humanity to respond, but not simply standing back waiting for applause.Footnote 36 The Holy Spirit, Christ's instrument of witness to himself, brings about faith in us as a wholly unmerited gift.Footnote 37 The Spirit's work in the world is redemption, the subjective realisation of reconciliation in Christ, and so it has no other task than to bear witness to Christ and therefore to mediate, through the gift of faith, our participation in that reconciliation.Footnote 38 The faith, hope and love given by the Spirit are not natural or regenerated capacities in us, nor are they our graceful habits, nor our achievements – they are pure grace which, like the manna in the desert, God gives new each moment: the Holy Spirit is an ongoing miracle which turns us to God.Footnote 39 It is because the Holy Spirit witnesses to Christ and to the reconciliation achieved in him that it shows salvation as something outside us, not our renewed dispositions or experiences.Footnote 40 Just as the Holy Spirit is the only active ingredient in our coming to faith, so it is only the Spirit that makes Christian witness a true attestation of Christ. Though only God makes our action worthy of him, Christian persons are not simply an ornamental mill-race for love between members of the Trinity.Footnote 41 Christians participate in God's work, not by synergism, but by the contradiction of grace spoken into their lives, making them new.Footnote 42
Faith in God is knowledge about the truth of reality – Jesus’ Lordship – so it takes the form of obedience and a decision for service.Footnote 43 Faith is necessarily public, because it is a relationship with the Trinity.Footnote 44 This means that the church must be visible, because it is an assembly of faithful people called in the Holy Spirit: the same Holy Spirit who gives us the Word made flesh.Footnote 45 So, the church has a definite history.Footnote 46 However, the church is not to be sought abstractly in the visible.Footnote 47 Barth often talks about the church as though it were a three-dimensional object. The church that is visible to everyone acting as a historical community is only 2D; the third dimension, the church's depth and significance, is given only by Christ through the Spirit.Footnote 48 So, the true nature of the church, its 3D character, is invisible and not open to historical scrutiny from outside – like Jesus’ resurrection.Footnote 49 However, it is a form of ecclesiological docetism to consider the church abstractly in the invisible, too, because the third dimension of the church is not ahistorical – how could it be when Jesus’ particular history, now universally significant in his resurrection, is the foundation of its life?Footnote 50 We must take the visible church seriously, in all its frailty and sin, but live in the hope of the third dimension and Christ's promise in the Spirit.Footnote 51 Apart from the praise of God, which follows from the thankfulness of the individual, the church's task is to witness to the gospel in the world.Footnote 52 This witness to the gospel is inseparable from the being of the church – if it isn't witnessing, it isn't the church.Footnote 53 The idea is not that the witness of the church converts the world or brings about the kingdom – only God does that.Footnote 54 Thus, the church witnesses to the kingdom in a small, provisional, imperfect and yet necessary and historical way.Footnote 55
The pneumatological point and the new ecclesiology
It should be becoming clear that Barth maps the church onto the resurrection (its hidden character), the incarnation (its visibility and historical particularity) and God's being (the church's being is its act of witness). The space that Barth is creating for the Holy Spirit should also be coming into sharper focus. In the time after the resurrection, the Holy Spirit holds together the life of the church with the living Christ at the right hand of the Father. The Spirit bridges the gap between Christ the head and his earthly historical form in the church, and connects his hidden life in God with the hidden life of the true church on earth.Footnote 56 The Spirit also holds together God's action with ours: God's action transcends ours so it is not in tension with it, and so it works like the hypostatic union: our actions are not working with God, nor does God make puppets of us, but our action is held in accordance with (but distinct from) divine precedence by the Holy Spirit.Footnote 57 This means that all our action can really be is a prayer for participation in the holiness of Jesus through the Holy Spirit.Footnote 58 As the promise of the church's deliverance, the Holy Spirit is also a source of humble confidence for Christians, because even though our efforts at a Christian life may be feeble, God's ‘nevertheless’ in the witness of the Spirit gives us again the truth of Christ's resurrection and the knowledge that all has already been made good in Christ in a way that strengthens us to continue in hope.Footnote 59
What of the new ecclesiology? I hope that this redescription of Barth's ecclesiology goes some way towards mitigating the more severe interpretations of his work from this quarter. It now remains to draw out some of the insights the new ecclesiology might take from Barth's ecclesiological minimalism. Biggar's analysis of Barth's method which I quoted at the outset said that Christian life should not be considered in detail apart from the dynamic relationship with God which constitutes it. The new ecclesiology's central tenet is that reflection on the church ought to start with the messy reality of the historical, sinful church. I have argued that Barth's ecclesiological minimalism and concomitant focus on the Spirit as holder-together-of-difference hold the theological emphasis firmly on this dynamic relationship. What might the new ecclesiology garner from this? There are three brief points to make here.
First, I suggest that Barth's view of the freedom of the Holy Spirit allows a discerning focus on the practices and concrete life of the church.Footnote 60 While acknowledging the primal importance of ordinary Christian practice for reflection on the nature of church, preserving the freedom of the Spirit allows church practices to be open to scrutiny and part of an ongoing prayerful conversation about the faithfulness of the church. Some proponents of the new ecclesiology are in danger, I think, of making Christian practices bear too much theological weight: more weight than the imperfect reality of Christian practice can bear, and certainly more theological weight than they should bear.Footnote 61 I remain unconvinced of the need, voiced by Hütter, for an unequivocal referent of the Spirit's ‘holding together’: the temptation for a concrete ecclesiology is to make this unequivocal referent the idealised church, and to collapse the identity of the church into its means of identification. Very importantly in this context, Barth's ecclesiological minimalism does not allow the presence of the Holy Spirit to be equated with idealised Christian practice. Christian practices, as Christian doctrines, should function in theological reflection as the hubs of arguments.Footnote 62 Take the confessional example ‘Jesus is Lord’. If ‘Jesus is Lord’ is a methodological point insofar as it is shorthand for the ways in which the church has come to understand Jesus as Lord, if we treat it as the hub of an argument, then the key to how ‘Jesus is Lord’ works is not what kind of behaviour we have (though by the grace of God we may have it), but how we go on. If Jesus is Lord, then the kinds of conversations we will have will be about who is in charge, and how we can tell, and what kind of difference we are looking for. We will ask questions about what power might be, and who has it, and questions about what kind of power we are claiming for Jesus when we call him ‘Lord’, and what that entails. Preserving the freedom of the Spirit prises apart the identity of the church from its means of identification in a way that opens a space for discernment and growth.
Second, the new ecclesiology tends towards a rhetoric of continuity with the life of Christ, rather than correspondence with it.Footnote 63 David Fergusson has argued that Hauerwas’ focus is often on the exemplary character of Christ's life, rather than its cosmic significance. This emphasis on the characteristic way of life inaugurated by Jesus can translate into a worrying emphasis on the necessity of Christians appearing socially distinctive. For Barth, focusing on the social distinctiveness (or otherwise) of Christians risks attending only to the ‘2D’ church, as I have called it. If, as for Barth, we focus on Christian practices as prayers for consonance with the work of the Holy Spirit, we much diminish this risk by attending to correspondence with the work of the Spirit (and therefore correspondence with the life of the ascended Christ), rather than a continuity that may or may not be faithful. Thus, the focus remains on Biggar's ‘dynamic relationship’ between God and the church, and the distinctiveness of the church can be seen in the kinds of conversation and question we expect to hear, as well as the kinds of concrete behaviour we expect to see. The identity of the church is thus seen as a sort of Godwards orientation.
Third, Barth's reticence in pronouncing on the Spirit's precise ‘location’ in the concrete church is important if concrete ecclesiology is to be pastorally careful. Here the need for prophetic challenge in the church needs to be balanced with the good news that God's victory does not depend on our struggle. Concrete ecclesiology must strike a balance between calling the church to change, and addressing its calls for change to the church where it is, concretely and theologically. It should question and attend to areas of ecclesial dissonance. But if we engage in visionary theological rhetoric, we must also have the theological resources to cope with reality. Exercises in ecclesiological ethnography or congregational historiography must be careful not to pronounce too confidently or finally on the presence (or absence) of the Spirit, because such judgements always impinge on real lives, where they may be in danger of snapping bruised reeds. While exercises in communal discernment such as Healy suggests may be fruitful and lifegiving, there remains a temptation to deal with the history of a congregation in an epic way, rather than a dramatic way – to fix the meaning or nature of events beyond further revision.Footnote 64 Barth's placing of the life of the church and the work of the Spirit in the now-but-not-yet between the resurrection and the parousia disallows such an epic focus, and frees the Spirit to reveal Christ where it will.
The new ecclesiology's focus on the concrete, historical church as the proper object of ecclesiological reflection is a valuable and promising move. I have argued that the way in which its vision is sometimes articulated in contradistinction from Barth's ecclesiology does a disservice to the way in which Barth attends to the church's concrete life. Through analysing how Barth relates the church to its doctrinal context in the various parts of the Church Dogmatics where it is discussed, I have argued that Barth's reticence in directly addressing the historical form of the concrete church can be read as preserving the freedom of the Holy Spirit in relation to the concrete church. I have suggested that the space that Barth creates for the free movement of the Spirit in this way is necessary for a concrete ecclesiology that would be pastorally careful and appropriately discerning of the practices of the historical, sinful church.Footnote 65
