This book is the fourth in a series on cultures and globalization. The others are Conflicts and Tensions (Vol. 1, 2007); The Cultural Economy (Vol. 2, 2008); and Cultural Expression, Creativity and Innovation (Vol. 3, 2010); all were issued by the same publisher. This is a heroic effort to deal with a slippery subject, and a fifth volume, Cities, Cultural Policy and Governance, is due out this year (2012).
The book is dense. Its range is broad, and it brings together articles from more than 40 scholars. Furthermore, it deals with a subject that is rapidly developing and that may make some of the most forward-thinking look out of date within 10 years. One can only admire the courage of the editors and publishers in undertaking this very ambitious but clearly needed contribution to scholarship on cultural policy. It makes even a reviewer quail, since his or her comments are equally subject to such dynamic changes. Nonetheless, the subject is key to policy decisions in the twenty-first century, at a time when nature and technological development present enormous challenges to the future of humanity. I have therefore tried to give as much detail of the content as possible in order to show where current thinking may take us in meeting these challenges. But, as the distinguished French historian Pierre Nora warns us in his Foreword to this volume, the concern with memory, identity, and heritage is far from being a momentary fad or crisis, but is the profound expression of a radical mutation that has only just begun.
In his introductory essay, Raj Isar describes the dominance of the views of the North American and European countries in the early days of UNESCO in all its activities, including its cultural programs. Nevertheless he seems himself from time to time to fall into the same kind of bias. For example, he states: “Many points of doctrine and methodology have been globalized quite smoothly, others less so. Some have even been contested in the non-Western world” (p. 41). One must add to that statement, that some have also been contested in the Western world—consider the opposition of the United States and a number of important European states to the UNESCO Convention on the Protection of the Underwater Cultural Heritage 2001, where there was substantial consensus in all other regions, as well as in some in the European (Mediterranean) and North American (Canada) regions. Resistance to the principles of the UNESCO Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property 1970 was only overcome for significant Western states by weakening the text of the Convention during its negotiation (United States) or by considerable delays in its acceptance (by Belgium, France, Germany, Netherlands, and United Kingdom).
The terminology of heritage studies is a minefield: Isar mentions that “heritage sites are termed properties” (p. 43), but this is only the case in the context of the UNESCO Convention Concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage 1972. It is notable that the 1970 Convention uses the collective term “cultural property” and that the 2001 and 2005 UNESCO Conventions, on underwater cultural heritage and intangibles respectively, avoid both usages, employing the term “heritage” instead. The 1972 Convention was strongly influenced by United States administrators of natural sites, but it also reflects the extreme views of property owning that are entrenched in that legal system. It is significant that most discussions of the Convention and its Operational Guidelines use not the term “properties” but “sites.” The 1978 Statute of the UNESCO Intergovernmental Committee for Promoting the Restitution of Cultural Property to Its Countries of Origin or Its Restitution in Case of Illicit Appropriation represents the entirely different view of “property” in the majority of countries most concerned with that issue. Here is a rich field for debate and one that could have been the subject of a chapter in itself in this study. While the early activities of UNESCO necessarily were modeled on the law and practice of the European and English-speaking countries, it was inevitable that there would be changes as the international organs themselves became worldwide in their reach. Isar rightly notes that the search for prestige through global recognition of other cultures has been a contributing factor in the way the heritage concept has been diversified and expanded internationally. Despite the superlative “outstanding universal value” used in the world heritage Convention, it is clear from a careful analysis of the World Heritage List that, according to purely scientific criteria, many sites do not reach that standard and the Convention has been used “as an instrument in the operations of a global economy of cultural prestige” (p. 45). It is significant that the list of intangible heritage does not use this phrase and is instead based on “representativity.”
Dacia Viejo-Rose points out, in a chapter dealing with the destruction and reconstruction of heritage, that while globalization has been seen as “a destructive force, a tidal wave of homogenization, sweeping before it local distinctiveness and replacing it with the signs, symbols and values born of the marketing and commoditization strategies of an aggressive global economy,” globalization itself may be shaped by notions of heritage, memory, and identity that resist it and play powerful roles in reconstruction of heritage and restoration of memory (p. 54). Destruction in remote countries that would barely have been noted a century ago is now only too graphically present, to call up memories of local destruction, despair, and eventual repair or replacement. Destruction and replacement have become central to international politics. Indeed, some examples become international icons: the destruction of the Bamiyan Buddhas and the towers of the World Trade Center came to symbolize destruction at the international level, whereas other equally significant destructions such as the Ayodhya Mosque in India or the Museum of Vukovar in Croatia are seen to have retained importance only for specialists and local communities. War, of course, may also create new sites of memories: of the landings, battles, sieges and so on. Attempts to suppress memorials of abandoned regimes (statues of Stalin, Saddam Hussein, and now Muammar Gaddafi) are not, as the author points out, necessarily conducive to dealing with their consequences. Memories of traumatic events last long: The trial of senior officials of the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia began 30 years after their misdoings, and in Argentina efforts are still being made to find the names and fates of those who disappeared under the dictatorship of the 1970s. Furthermore, communities of exiles may construct different memories to those who remain in a country after conflict. Another paradox is the effect of no-man's-land areas in preserving natural green belts and species (p. 64).
Tim Winter discusses the globalization of heritage funding through international organizations, international nongovernmental organizations, local benefactors, and national states. France, China, and Japan, in particular, have been following a strategy of securing influence in newly recreated states “strategically pivotal in a region of rapid economical [sic] growth and potential political volatility” (p. 75). Heritage tourism actively contributes to the production of heritage and memory and may be a long-term supporter of the rejuvenation of historic quarters—but of course it also has its dangers, leading to calls for “sustainable heritage tourism.” In certain cases, says Winter, “the heritage sector continues to unwittingly advance the very ties between culture and capital that it is trying to resist by deploying techno-managerial approaches” (p. 79). This is a thoughtful contribution to the discussion and merits careful consideration.
One of the most interesting chapters in the book concerns heritage and diaspora. Ien Ang sees diaspora is as a key phenomenon of cultural globalization. “Diasporic memory is about dislocation, exile, separation from a place, loss of (and nostalgia for) home”—can this kind of memory be publicly asserted and officially acknowledged as heritage in the contemporary world? (p. 87). She gives the example of the giant Snowy Mountains Hydro-Electric project, which was listed on the National Heritage Register by the Australian Heritage Commission. It was built with the labor of 100,000 foreign workers from 30 different countries over 25 years, and Ang notes its cultural significance for marking the birthplace of Australian multiculturalism—a way of retrospectively accommodating an important social and cultural change from a largely mono- to a multicultural society (p. 88).
Currently there are a number of emigration museums (such as that at Bremen, recording the exit of many Germans in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries) and equally museums of immigration, which seem to be more common (found in Australia, Brazil, Canada, and United States). These serve important political ends: European states “are being forced to recognise that they are no longer homogeneous imagined communities but are now irrevocably multicultural societies” (p. 89). The other side of this diasporization is the desire of the emigrants to continue to have contacts with the old country: sometimes for genealogical research, sometimes to associate themselves with the culture from which they are now set apart, sometimes to influence the politics of their country of ultimate origin, or simply to acquire or revive diverse histories. I would add that some communities in the country of origin find the intensity of the emigrants' interest in their local, and sometimes international, politics a complicating factor. Though their affluence might assist a struggling economy through donations, it is not the donors that have to deal with hostile neighboring communities who resent their apparent influence. And often the heritage they remember has been greatly changed: Descendants of the emigrants, perhaps three generations later, have conceptions of their grandparents' “heritage” that can be related with difficulty to the “heritage” celebrated and memorialized by the current inhabitants. Nor, in most cases, do these outsiders have any rights in the ancestral homeland. But some of these homelands are reaching out to these populations in a broader international trend to pursue the national interest in today's increasingly entangled world: Some offer passports to the grandchildren of former citizens (Ireland), a “right of return” (Israel), voting rights (France, Italy), or setting up “cultural centers” in the lands where they live (Japan). Ang wisely concludes that bringing “heritage” and “diaspora” together highlights the enduring tension between freedom and belonging, embrace of the new and fidelity of the old: “If we must turn diaspora into heritage, … the biggest challenge for policy and best practice is to allow the careful, creative and intelligent articulation of that ambivalence, the unsettling of the national (whichever nation it may be)” (p. 93).
The next contributor, Jean-Pierre Warnier, takes up the “politics of autochthony” and gives a very interesting analysis of the diverse origins and conflicting aims of indigenous people in the United States, Canada, Africa, and Russia. Their coalition to achieve the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples in 2007 was an extraordinary achievement—indigenous issues, standards, and administrative practices (p. 102) have now been recycled all around the world to create a globalized terminology. The author sees the issue of territorialization as the heart of the relationship between indigenous peoples and the state:
Since the nineteenth century, there has been a scramble for land and natural resources all over the world…. Most indigenous peoples were defined as “lacking” in law, land tenure systems, writing, economic potential, political organization, in other words in “civilization.” This provided a rationale for displacing them, pushing them to the margins and depriving them of their lands and resources. Indigenous peoples have succeeded in reversing the ideological trend. Instead of being perceived as lacking, they are seen as being endowed with identity, memory, heritage, with an authenticity and an autochthony that has been lost by the rest of the world population. (p. 102)
Although the pursuit of mining rights, major developments such as roads and dams, and purchase or appropriation of large tracts of land in the areas of indigenous peoples continue, they are now challenged and sometimes undone. Some claims for redress of past roles have also been successful. The author concludes that the 2007 Declaration should not mark the end of a long struggle but “the beginning of a new dynamics in matters of memory, heritage, identity, and corporate rights” (p. 104).
“Grass-Roots memorials as sites of heritage creation” (p. 106) deals in particular with spontaneous construction of memorials without any official participation; their nature as shrines, as an expression of mourning, and as a component of political action such as has been seen in Madrid after the terrorist attack on three major train stations, sites of political deaths in Northern Ireland, or the World Trade Center in New York. Closely related is the following chapter, “Sites of Conscience—Heritage of and for Human Rights” (p. 114), which deals with museums with three commitments: to interpret history through a site, to engage in programs that stimulate dialogue on pressing social issues today, and to share opportunities for public involvement in those issues. Examples include the Gulag Museum at Perm, Russia; the Villa Grimalkin in Chile; and The Old Fort in Johannesburg—among many others dedicated to the slogan “Never Again!”
Although landscapes and the environment are dealt with in a number of contributions, only one focuses directly on the environment: Benjamin Morris's “Not Just a Place: Cultural Heritage and the Environment” (p. 124), a theme taken up by David Lowenthal in the last contribution to the book (pp. 280–284). Morris proposes a more nuanced notion of the natural world and the human world as “mutually influencing, responding to, and co-producing one another”—in other words, to avoid the attitude of purely scientific observation or that of an immersion in nature which prevents a clear view of its impact on the human being, and vice versa. While modern conservation builds on ancient beliefs of responsibility for the welfare of the natural environment, it has a darker side: Natural spaces are constructed by scientific and political regimes that have impact on the communities that live in, near, and outside them. Yet the natural world creates its own landscape: coastal erosion, seasonal storms and floods, earthquakes, and volcanic eruptions which become central events for memorialization by human beings. Stemming the tide of exploitation and degradation that engenders climate change means reassessing societal values, norms, and expectations attached to the environment and requires a change not just in the way that heritage is used but also how it is conceived.
A key issue in the conservation of heritage in recent years has been that of “authenticity” (p. 140), bravely tackled by Jagath Weerasinghe. This concept was included in the Venice Charter in 1964 in relation to architectural structures. There was good reason for this inclusion because of the desire to understand how we got to where we are and why fabric is important. It was not designed to mean that “heritage is a static entity belonging to the past” (p. 145), but it caused considerable unease particularly in Asian countries when applied to their religious structures (“living sacred heritage”) and also in other contexts such as those dealing with indigenous sites of heritage. Despite responses such as the Burra Charter (Australia ICOMOS [International Council on Monuments and Sites]) 1979 (revised 1999) and the Nara Declaration 2003, there still seems to be some confusion as to exactly what is being preserved: the intangible heritage attached to a structure or natural site or its physical attributes. And can either be “preserved” in a dynamic context where human and natural elements continue to develop new challenges? Can these elements all be protected, or must there be, as Weerasinghe proposes, a change in the role of expert to that of a mediator between standard conservation concepts and the aspirations and concerns of the traditional custodians and associated communities (p. 146)?
Having written in 1972 on the litigation on the temple of Preah Vihear,Footnote 1 concerning a border dispute in the International Court of Justice between Cambodia and Thailand, I found the chapter on this temple and its modern political implications within these countries the most interesting one in the book. Preah Vihear (in Khmer) or Phra Viharn (in Thai) is an outstanding temple complex mainly built in the eleventh century on the escarpment high above the Cambodian plateau. Both states claimed the temple as on their territory in the 1962 border claim.Footnote 2 The iconography of the temple is Hindu, though both Cambodian and Thai populations are now overwhelmingly Buddhist. Nonetheless, it is revered by both peoples and tended by Buddhist monks. Both sides admire Khmer architecture and Northern Thai sites such as Si Satchanalai and Sukothai that have been in Thai hands since the fourteenth century—the authors describe it as a “site of collective memory” for the Thais (p. 149), while for many Cambodians, the current tensions are seen as part of the centuries-long history of Thailand's attempts to “steal” Cambodian territory and destroy Khmer identity.
The court's decision relied on a 1904 border delimitation between Thailand and the French authorities in Cambodia: The text declared the watershed line to be the border, but on the map drawn up by the French military mapping team, the border was shown on the other side of the temple than it proved to be in fact. The court held that the temple belonged to Cambodia, but neither side was happy with the decision, which was based on the very narrow ground of the colonial treaty. Thailand resented the loss and the refusal of the court to give weight to the evidence of colonial pressure. Cambodia, though pleased with the result, was also disappointed with the nature of the justification of the decision. Both sides felt that historical and cultural arguments should not have been simply dismissed. Croissant and Chambers reveal not only the historical and cultural factors used for arousing, endorsing, and strengthening claims in past and current local politics, but also the arousal of dormant animosities to serve internal political goals. Initially Thailand did reluctantly accept the ruling on the temple complex itself, but it has never recognized the map on which the court based its decision. Animosities flared between the two countries in the late 1970s when the newly communist Cambodia was facing the military-led Thai government. Tensions diminished at the end of the Cold War in 1991, declined again in the 2000s, but suddenly became a prominent issue in 2008. Thaksin Shinawatra (Prime Minister 2006–2007) supported the Cambodian application for listing as a UNESCO World Heritage site, but the following government challenged this process. The issue was used against the Shinawatra faction and led to violent clashes on the border. This brief summary does not do justice to the detailed analysis given to the political aspects of the conflict, which should be read by all those who are concerned with the use of cultural heritage sites for political ends.
What is eco-tourism contributing to the globalization of heritage tourism (p. 157)? Apparently it has the potential to reinforce collective and individual memories which may be fading, to reinforce respect for the local communities and to assist in the preservation of traditions. Memory can be recognized as a repository and a source of identity. Where collective memories become sources of interpretation of material culture and the environment, they can explain to visitors the relationship of the landscape and rituals to traditional culture. A striking example is the case of Zulu speakers in the Kamberg Valley in South Africa where the San were supposedly extinct or fully assimilated into the Zulu culture, but where, since the listing of the Drakensberg area as a World Heritage site, some have been asserting their San heritage, especially that relating to the prolific rock art of the San in this area. Calling themselves the Abatwa, they apply indigenous beliefs at the reserve to avoid “spiritual pollution” by visitors. Tourists are asked to rub their legs with indigenous grasses before entering—a process that builds on the tourism experience and sensitizes tourists to the spiritual nature of the rock art for the local people (p. 164). In Botswana the study of taboos and totems has reawakened connections to intangible heritage in protected areas: A totem can be an animal, plant, or any other natural object believed to be ancestrally related to a group as the tutelary spirit, and in contemporary Botswana, totems still act as virtual indicators of ethnic identity among communities. Taboos were, and to some extent still are, traditional social rules relating to environmental resources and are transmitted from generation to generation through memory. Even where community members no longer interact directly with the now-protected landscape, some still remember aspects of intangible heritage associated with that landscape and can interpret the environment for the purposes of upmarket tourism by diversifying the wilderness and wildlife experience (p. 160).
There is an interesting analysis of multiple identities in the Southwest Indian Ocean, Mauritius, Madagascar, and the Seychelles. The government of the Seychelles has encouraged the globalization of Creole identity and the reinstatement of its slave heritage, so that “heritage has become a source of therapy mediated by public officials” (p. 174). In Madagascar, important references to memory, culture, and identity by high government officials are used to encourage dialogue and creativity. Multiple heritages, deployed for purposes of nation building and ethnic memorialization can result in analysis leading to new uses of conflicting memories. In Mauritius the date of abolition of slavery has now become a public holiday, and a special site has been designated to memorialize one of the principal sites connected with the slave trade, which became a World Heritage site in 2008 (p. 172). This recalls the pride now shown by those descended from convicts transported to the early settlements in Australia—an association with a history previously seen as shameful and repudiated by those related to it. Such revisions and revisiting of history can lead to a more balanced and harmonious presence between different cultural groups. As in the case of slavery, there can now be pride in survival and in the contribution made to the formation of the nation.
Other examples of changing views of heritage include “remembering and forgetting communist cultural production” (p. 177), “identity and memory in former Yugoslavia” (p. 187) and “contemporary creativity and heritage in Latin America” (p. 199)—all rich in further examples of the mutation of memories, the molding of identities, and the critical place of heritage in that process.
Following this section concerning regional realities, another seven chapters deal with fields and issues from the widest perspective such as “manipulation of memory and heritage in museums of migration” (p. 213), memories of the destroyed Roma district in historic Istanbul (p. 222) contrasting with a description of migrants learning about the historic places they inhabit in Istanbul (p. 231), divided memories and contested histories in Japan (p. 239), the memorialization of genocide in Ruanda (p. 245), a particularly interesting study of constructing shared identity in couples of mixed cultures (p. 252), and an important contribution on oral records of memories: actualizing by listening and telling (p. 262). All of these include intriguing comments on the process of globalization, changing memories, and developing identities.
Two commentaries round off this part of the collection and seek to distill some of its most important messages. Henrietta Moore concentrates on “living” or “intangible” heritage and raises the issue of cultural rights. She comments on the worrying development of understanding culture as both an index of diversity and as a resource (p. 274) and sees this volatile mix of rights and proprietary assets as tying cultural claims ever more closely to conflict, violence, exclusion, and even war. She also criticizes the use of the term “modernity,” which means different things in different cultures and so cannot be the touchstone for evaluating degrees of globalization. Despite the well-recognized importance of living heritage, any focus on living heritage has a tendency to concentrate attention on the past, which inevitably creates a kind of disconnect between heritage and contemporary artistic creativity (p. 279). The author sees the categories of hybrid/mixed/translocal identities, used by Jimenez Lopez in Chapter 16, as obscuring the fact that “there is no single way in which culture is tied to or presupposes identities, and that this relationship is itself undergoing rapid change” (p. 279).
David Lowenthal asserts that heritage, bolstered by memory and validating identity, has provided “insular havens of like-minded certitude in stormy seas of outlandish ways…. Our … uniqueness … distinguishes us from others … and pious modern affirmations of global unities based on mutual respect for ‘the heritage of all mankind’ founder on the shoals of this or that ethnic, religious, linguistic or national claim of privileged entitlement” (p. 282). He emphasizes that the environmental heritage is both local and global. Paleolithic hunter-gatherer heritage hardwired ancestral brains to ignore futures more than two generations ahead. For Lowenthal, the “conflicting heritage claims detailed in this book pale into insignificance beside imperative needs to reconceive identity on a global level” (p. 283). Synchronic automatic translation systems (SATS) promises almost instantaneously available interpretation, and on balance, it should reduce social tension, political friction, and armed conflict—all far less prevalent among peoples able to communicate easily and accurately with one another. Although translation will never completely bridge, let alone efface, different mental worlds, it may help lessen divergencies of norms and values and help disarm lethal differences of ideology.
Some of the most valuable aspects of the book are the tables (“indicator suites”) included at the end. They give statistics of the most diverse kind to enable some kind of comparison of cultural activities and other aspects of cultural policy. Many of the indicators give rise to interesting questions. For example: According to the graph on World Heritage sites, the biggest threat to this heritage is neither tourism nor mining, but in every region of the world “development related issues,” and, in four of the five regions analyzed, very significantly so (p. 299). Another interesting finding is that, while in most countries of the European Union, more people perceive it as bringing cultural diversity, there are the exceptions of Croatia, Greece, Turkey, and the United Kingdom, where more people view it as leading to a loss of their cultural identity (p. 367).
Finding appropriate indicators for “sustainability” was clearly a difficult task. Four graphs are given relating to officially protected agricultural products, the UNESCO Memory of the World project, threatened species, attitudes to coexistence of nature and human beings, and the “Happy Planet Index: Life Satisfaction, Health, and Ecological Behaviour” (pp. 322–323). And, after all that, we are warned that the preservation of heritage and traditions may also cause some dangers for societies by disincentivizing creativity and innovation (p. 325).
However, the tables have to be considered carefully. Some of them are hard to read, for example, the table on “democide” (p. 337) and on the exact use of “expatriates” and “foreign-born” (p. 354) are not immediately clear. The editors point out that the global distribution of the traditional German beer festival Oktoberfest and even in the virtual world, for example, Second Life, World of Warcraft, and MapleStory (pp. 314, 317) raises the question whether such distribution is supporting or destroying the tradition's original meaning. The indicators and comment on Internet addiction (p. 373) include a comparison of the prevalence of Internet addiction and show huge differences in addiction rates from 0.3% in the United States to 10.6% in Switzerland, but we are warned that the numbers are not easily comparable owing to challenges in data collection and biases in the definition of concepts.
Occasionally the sophisticated form of the table, such as “Global Collective Memories,” is simply baffling (p. 340). To know how the authors managed to get hold of some of the figures (“indicators”) that are used would be interesting: Some states clearly do not keep statistics on some of the items tabulated. Nor is it clear that those that do keep such statistics all assess on the same basis. Alas, it also means that the industrialized states, whose bureaucracies have gathered information for generations, are naturally overrepresented generally in this kind of tabulation. And even they have been rather late in looking into the evaluation of cultural practice. Nonetheless, the tables do provide some very interesting insights into the management of heritage in the early twenty-first century.
While the text has clearly been very carefully edited, the odd imperfection occurs. For example, according to its unique procedure among UN Agencies, states do not sign UNESCO Conventions (p. 305)—they are signed by the Director-General and the President of the General Conference, and states then ratify or accept them. There are also a few terms that will puzzle readers outside a particular discipline, such as “autochthony” (endemism) and “democide” (government murder), and, more rarely, some spectacularly ugly ones such as “disincentivizing” and “representativity.”
But these are quibbles. There can be no doubt that this volume is a major contribution to the study of some of the most crucial issues of development in the twenty-first century, and the editors have to be congratulated on achieving such a wide range of material from first-rate scholars around the world.
