In the current disciplinary taxonomy of Latin American studies, economic history is less central than it once was, so extending an inquiry into business history and then into Carlos Dávila's area of expertise, entrepreneurial history, may be to wander too far into novelty for many readers. In his introductory essay, however, Dávila argues that, rather than constituting a peripheral field, the business and entrepreneurial history of Latin America is simply young. This second edition of this work, published as part of Ediciones Uniandes’ 60th anniversary series, is a substantially revised and expanded version of a book published in 1986. This revised volume is an attempt both to update his original regional study and to fold that topic into a larger, general consideration of the field and its development. The newer sections, which include disciplinary discussions unlikely to appeal to a broad scholarly audience, do not mesh that well with the older parts of the book.
The book has three sections. The first, which is entirely new, reviews the literature on business history in Colombia and across Latin America. In the first chapter of the section, Dávila explains the growth of the field and its relation to economic history. He surveys the various contributing disciplines, notes the crucial role of foreign scholars in this development, and considers both the broader political and academic factors that impeded and then facilitated business history, particularly the Cold War perspective that to study entrepreneurs and business was to celebrate capitalism. The second chapter of this section presents a method for studying business history, a discussion geared more toward those considering this as a teaching field or those involved in business programmes; this emphasis is related to Dávila's position as the director of a programme on business history in the Facultad de Administración of the Universidad de los Andes.
In the second section, comprised of four chapters and also updated for this edition, Dávila turns to the historiography of industrialisation in the region of Antioquia, one of Colombia's great economic successes. The first chapter reviews the relevant literature and features several useful tables listing authors, their country of origin, their intellectual orientation, and type of publication. The following chapter delves into older scholarly explanations for why Antioquia became the centre of Colombian industry. Much of the literature explaining this success was produced by scholars from the United States. It is fascinating to review the arguments offered to explain this success, if only because some are such anachronisms. Dávila hones in on the theories of Everett Hagan, who, after three months in Colombia and with scanty empirical evidence, proposed that industrialisation in Antioquia was in part a product of a regional population motivated by ‘status withdrawal’. Dávila systematically refutes these arguments based on a synthesis of arguments and evidence from published studies, though it is not clear if Hagan's arguments still have any influence or followers. Dávila then considers the work of Charles Savage, who conducted extensive fieldwork in Medellín factories, arguing that his publications are undervalued, and William Paul McGreevy, an economic historian whose work, which provoked respectful rebuttals and spurred further research in Colombia, is still obligatory reading.
The following chapter is a straightforward survey of the literature on Antioquia's economic history. This story, of mining, trade and the rise of coffee, has been told in many other studies, though Dávila's presentation of the issues through a historiographical review is instructive. He ends this section asserting that entrepreneurs played a crucial role in the industrial development of Antioquia in the early twentieth century and then, in conclusion, pivots to the subject of entrepreneurs from other regions of Colombia, the focus of the final section of the book.
This last section, comprised of three chapters that also include new material, has broad appeal and makes for an enjoyable read. Drawing from the history of greater Bogotá and the Cauca Valley, Dávila uses published studies and family histories to present profiles of important entrepreneurs in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. He begins with the tale of the larger-than-life character José María Pepe Sierra, a man reputedly richer than the government. This is followed by accounts of the business careers of other notable, if less colourful, figures. The profiles make it clear that there was no set path to such success, no fixed starting point or political affiliation held in common by these men. Some rose to prominence and acquired great wealth through international trade and travelled extensively, while others remained deeply regional and committed to traditional landowning. One of the more interesting sections considers the business career of Alfonso López Pumarejo, the two-time president best known for leading the ‘Revolución en Marcha’. In recasting his life story with an emphasis on his early business training, Dávila offers a novel approach to his biography. The chapters are enjoyable, though there is little synthesis on entrepreneurialism and no systematic linkage to the work's earlier discussions. Sierra, for example, was from Antioquia, and some reflection on the degree to which his story refutes or confirms theories on regional development would have lent greater cohesiveness to the book. Dávila offers a number of observations on relations between these figures and the state, but only in a limited context, and he provides no overall conclusion.
