Poet, republican, diplomat, and entrepreneur, Joel Barlow was a prominent figure in America's early Republic, known primarily for his poetry (two epics and several canonical poems) and, politically, for his support of the French Revolution while living abroad in France, his successful mission to Algiers (1795–97) to secure the release of US prisoners while negotiating treaties with the three Barbary states, his opposition to US Federalist policies, and finally his appointment by James Madison to obtain a treaty with Napoleonic France.
Richard Buel covers these and other significant events magisterially in his new biography that now supersedes James Woodress's A Yankee's Odyssey: The Life of Joel Barlow (1958) and will undoubtedly become the definitive account of Barlow's life. Accessing primary archives and discovering sources that no one has previously utilized, Buel provides a treasure trove of heretofore unknown information, especially regarding Barlow's commercial activities in Germany and in other European countries during the French Revolution. Like other of his Anglo-American contemporaries, Barlow used his republican credentials to help Revolutionary France by arranging for critical materials to be delivered by sea, and hence he saw the Revolution as a wonderful way to maximize his entrepreneurial endeavors. There was, however, nothing hypocritical or self-serving about any of this, since Barlow was a true believer in the possibilities of revolution and, as he had fought in the War of Independence, this particular paradigm colored the way he saw France in the 1790s.
Buel demonstrates how Barlow read America into France, causing him to be uncritically sanguine about the Terror (1793–94), rationalizing events in a series of explanations that became commonplaces in the post-Revolutionary world. Barlow, however, became an apologist for the Terror and continued to celebrate the Revolution subsequently and covertly, for instance, in The Columbiad, his 1807 epic dealing with the progress of Enlightenment/republican ideology and its imminent global triumph. Buel misses these contextual allusions in Barlow's literary works, but he adds new information about Barlow's personal life, cogently suggesting (from letters in a coded baby talk) a sexual relationship in France, a ménage à trois that included Robert Fulton (the future developer of the first successful commercial steamboat) and Barlow's wife Ruth, and a brief homoerotic fling with Fulton.
Always a controversial figure, when he returned to the United States in 1805 Barlow was warmly received by Jeffersonian republicans and scorned and ridiculed by the Federalists. In addition his atheism became an issue of demonization, although he cultivated the fiction, as Buel demonstrates, that he was not, in fact, anti-Christian. By the time he was convinced by Madison to be the US plenipotentiary to France, he was growing old, but agreed reluctantly to deal with the Napoleonic government in order to achieve compensation for American ships and cargo that had been confiscated by the French in the long European war that had begun in 1793. Buel's account of how the French government deliberately stalled and misled Barlow, hoping that the United States would enter the war against Great Britain until a desperate Napoleon summoned him for a meeting in Lithuania, resulting in Barlow's death by pneumonia and his anonymous burial in a Catholic graveyard in Poland, is replete with new and poignant details.
The luminous strengths of this biography are the new facts and sources that Buel elucidates as well as their contextualization within the historical period that Barlow lived. The weakness is the matter-of-fact summary of his literary endeavors. Readers can, however, go elsewhere for a more comprehensive analysis of the latter, and Buel's oeuvre will become the definitive biography of an American who embodied the ideological tensions of his time and whose influential presence from the American Revolution through the first decades of the new Republic is currently being rethought. In this context, Buel's biography constitutes a metaphoric disinterment and resurrection of a Barlow whose full life and story have remained buried for over two hundred years.
