Discerning Experts is a comparative study of multiple scientific assessments that is rich in context and description. The authors use a selection of interviews and thorough historical analysis woven within three case studies – acid rain in the US (Chapter 2), ozone depletion (Chapter 3) and sea-level rise from the melting west Antarctic ice sheet (Chapter 4) – to illuminate how and why scientific assessments emerged, how they work and what they actually achieve. Useful for an introduction into scientific assessments or for those involved already, it is easily accessible for readers (scholarly or not) and the narrative throughout is clear, engaging and, quite frankly, a joy to read. The authors achieve this by providing ample detail both contextually and in content, sandwiching the three empirical chapters between a passage that introduces the reader to a brief historical context pertaining to the need for expert judgement and advice, and discussions on the science–policy boundary that the assessments are intrinsically bound up in that becomes apparent within the three chapters. The broad conclusions are concise and agreeable, and characterize the scientific assessment that has dominated much of modern environmental science policy: that assessments are much more than summaries, that assessors define objectivity as neutrality in policy, that institutional arrangements influence epistemic outcomes, that an assessment economy is emerging, that separating science and policy is desirable for those involved, that scientific consensus is the aim, and that uncertainty dominates across all stages (from agenda to dissemination).
The book itself can be broadly situated along the line of inquiry that seeks to understand the relations between science, society and policy. A theme that is commonplace in the scholarship of science studies and the history of science. For historians of science, assessments are examples of modern science. They illustrate how multiple, national and seemingly disparate voices siphoned (or at least attempted to) into a singular, authoritative and international voice. From the politically restrained and slow-burn NAPAP in the USA (Chapter 2), to Robert Watson's vision of large-scale international assessments (Chapter 3), through to a reliance on models (Chapter 4), we see how, akin to a broader history of environmental sciences, disciplinary expertise and singular national voices are not suitable or desirable to deal with the multidimensional challenges of environmental change. The authors also reveal how assessments typically ‘err on the side of least drama’ (p. 77) multiple times throughout in attempts to underscore their legitimacy by appearing to be ‘objective’ and consensual. In doing so, they illuminate throughout how scientists try to erect strict boundaries between science and politics and reveal how the boundary is, however, porous. Throughout assessments, scientists attempt to separate themselves from the political by presenting a range of policy options without being policy-prescriptive. Science, then, should concern itself only with the epistemic and not the normative. However, the authors correctly note that science is inseparable from politics. Despite not advocating any particular policy positions and striving to appear objective, the scientists involved decide what range of options to present; what knowledge is worthwhile to include in the assessment; and how to manage participation, disagreements and uncertainty within the assessment – all of which may lead to irreversible outcomes as some potential pathways are closed down as others are opened up. This mirrors what Sheila Jasanoff in States of Knowledge (2004) terms co-production, wherein the epistemic and the normative are tightly intertwined in a mutually constructive relationship, hence individuals involved with assessments should actively engage with and remain reflexive towards the politics of their decisions rather than strive to separate themselves, remaining aware of how their decisions and actions over the course of an assessment shape outcomes and pathways. Glimmers of co-production surface as the authors reveal how assessments at once are a product of specific research agendas and also become central in setting them. Scientific assessments are key sites of knowledge production that contribute to the (re)making of the world through a systematic reordering and evaluation of knowledge. An explicit co-productionist account may have led to a more critical engagement with the role of assessments in the relations between modern science and society by revealing more deeply and analysing the entanglements between normative and epistemic choices during emergence, conflict resolution, standardization and classification. The authors also contend that international scientific assessments have become normalized and that environmental-science policy is constructed in what they call ‘the permanent assessment economy’ (p. 216). Thus, in a history of the environmental sciences where multiple origins and histories coexist, Discerning Experts provides an excellent entry point into uncovering one of the narratives. The co-production of environmental science and politics renders a history of science also a history of politics as assessments find themselves couched between the indeterminacy of both scientific and political worlds.
In relation to a British history of science, it is rather lacking – there is minor coverage of what was going on in Britain – but the book remains in tandem with histories of the environmental sciences broadly, which are usually US-centric or focused on the ‘global’. It is difficult to do Oppenheimer et al.'s work justice in a short review, but Discerning Experts is an important text and of high value for those interested in participating (or who have participated) in scientific assessments and (environmental) science and policy, historians of modern science, geographers of knowledge, STS scholars or anyone broadly interested in how international science and science policy actually work.
