In Commerce by a Frozen Sea, Ann M. Carlos and Frank D. Lewis focus attention on commercial relations among North American Native people who responded to the variety of impacts of the eighteenth-century European fur trade in America. This book valuably situates the authors’ well-established research, some already appearing in important articles, within the larger literature of the fur trade. Using a formalist approach to draw meaning from archives of the Hudson's Bay Company (HBC), the authors sharpen debate on issues that range from native trading behavior, Indian response to the European market, the “tragedy” of commons resource exhaustion across cultures, and the reach of not only Europe's Great Transformation commercially, but reverberations of its consumer revolution even in distant North American forests. Their study area is the vast trading hinterlands of the HBC from James and Hudson Bay, and the people—mostly Cree, Assiniboine, and Chipewyan—who began visiting and trading at the company's posts in the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries. The authors’ quantitative analysis of annual accounts maintained at posts, especially those of Albany, York, and Churchill, indeed complements work on that “long” century's labor, commercial and economic history both in America and Europe. The first two chapters introduce the emerging London fur market, the organizational structure and post life in the HBC itself, and the complicating impact of French competition at Bayside posts. To help make sense of the impact of home markets, rising and falling demand, and competition in America, the authors develop a valuable price index to establish the overall terms of trade over time and, therefore, the changing relative distribution of gains to natives or Europeans in their exchanges with each other. They then move into the heart of their inquiry in Chapter 3, “Indians as Consumers,” which considerably elaborates upon native consumerism not only in respect to price, but also in terms of the quality and variety of European wares they demanded. Chapter 4 examines the native role in resource exhaustion as traders responded positively to rising prices, while Chapter 5, on “Industrious Indians,” situates their behavior and reorganization of labor in the context of their new choices and opportunities to purchase European luxury goods. Their last chapters examine limits on property rights and ineffective brakes on resource exhaustion in the native world, and attempts to compare standards of living between European laborers and native trappers of the eighteenth century.
There is great significance in the authors’ findings: a positive shift in effort to respond to higher prices, for instance, helps resolve an important matter in fur trade studies. The authors add greater complexity to the issue of inelastic demand exhibited by Cree and Assiniboine who traded at the Bay by paying closer attention to longer time series of fur returns, standards of trade, and trade goods assortments. Luxuries, it seems, mattered in that respect. Native fur hunters not only responded positively to higher prices, but switched from one furbearer, beaver, to another, marten, when their territories were exhausted; and, higher prices likely spurred greater industry among native hunters who chose to obtain more key luxuries such as cloth and tobacco. In a way, that authors’ work throws a challenge to other scholars in fur trade and native studies to find ways to apply such observations. More nuanced understandings of Cree kin-based strategies and world view—as suggested in Brenda Macdougall's work on wahkootowin (One of the Family: Metis Culture in Nineteenth-Century Northwestern Saskatchewan. Vancouver, BC: University of British Columbia Press 2010)—can inform and be informed by these authors’ insights on native “industry.” Indeed, it is likely within the obligations and incentives arising within Cree and other First Nations’ kin relations, themselves grounded in very different conceptions of land, where the authors’ findings will have great relevance. One can only hope, too, that more systematic work will be followed up now on the HBC qualitative record base to further explore native consumerism. Intensive qualitative analysis along the lines pursued by Victor Lytwyn (Muskekowuck Athinuwick: Original People of the Great Swampy Land. Winnipeg, Manitoba: University of Manitoba Press, 2002), compiling and tracing names of lowland Cree and Ojibwa in the company's daily journal entries could possibly be a means of testing the authors’ observations on smaller populations inhabiting more constrained trading hinterlands. The greatest value of the work, however, is the seamless perspective it maintains between Europe and America and the linkages it forms between European markets and Indian productive labor. Fur trade studies since the 1970s have made great contributions to ethnic and native history. As valuable as this research has been, academic interest in ethnic locale and prescribed regions in North America has arguably diverted attention from other key matters. Early fur trade scholars such as Harold Innis never lost sight of the staples, investments, and terms of trade between Europe and America in the fur trade. Now, with globalization and integrated markets so relevant to scholars of many disciplines, Commerce by a Frozen Sea is timely, indeed, providing an optic on an early economic activity beyond borders and the intercultural exchange that early overseas trade initiated.
