In this book, Achim Rohde attempts “to show how cross-regional comparative perspectives and an interdisciplinary approach” help us in studying Iraq (p. 3). By “comparative,” he means reading the historiography of regimes elsewhere, while by “interdisciplinary,” he refers to moving beyond politics and economy in our interpretations, toward the inclusion of social and cultural issues. Using his knowledge of German sources, he shows that comparing Saddam Husayn to Hitler is misguided and that Iraqi Baʿthism was not Nazism. He rightly argues that although the two ideologies converged in regard to the centrality of the leader and the militarism of the regime, the “totalitarianism paradigm proves only partly useful in understanding the history of Iraq” (p. 159).
The book is based on Rohde's PhD dissertation and is divided into two parts. The first is more historical and political and traces the rise and fall of the Baʿth Party. Using Iraqi newspapers and many secondary sources, Rohde constructs the development of the party's authoritarian regime in the 1970s, then moves on to discuss the war with Iran and its implications. Finally, he looks at the political fragmentation that took place in the 1990s after the invasion of Kuwait, the Shiʿi uprising, and the harsh sanctions that were imposed on the country.
This part of the book rehashes what other secondary sources have emphasized for years: the disenfranchising of the Shiʿa, the weakening of the Baʿth Party in the 1990s, and the huge costs of militarism and war for the people of Iraq. Yet the lack of documents until now has prevented us from analyzing the regime's complexities (for full disclosure, I am completing a book on the Baʿth Party based on the documents of the Party's Regional Command). For instance, we now know from the archives that the Baʿth Party did not weaken in the 1990s: no committee was ever set up without a representative of the party secretariat, and membership increased by roughly 38 percent between 1991 and 1996. The perception of weakness, as Rohde rightly indicates when citing the reduction in the party's activities, was due to a general decline of state power given the destruction of war and the inability of the state apparatus to anticipate the uprising or crush it swiftly. Rohde emphasizes this fragmentation: “the Iraqi state of the 1990s was a fission product of the former Leviathan” (p. 71). But the reality was that the state and its security apparatus continued to function and even strengthen, and the sanctions played into the hands of the Baʿth by increasing the population's reliance on the regime's carefully constructed system of rewards.
What happened in the 1990s was more than simple fragmentation. Although resistance to the regime was increasing, the Baʿth Party succeeded in co-opting more people into its rewards structure. Rohde addresses the economic aspects of the war, but it is a pity that he does not use memoirs written by Iraqis who were involved in decision making for the economy and finance, such as Jawad Hashim's Mudhakkirat Wazir ʿIraqi maʿa al-Bakr wa-Saddam: Dhikrayat fi al-Siyasa al-ʿIraqiyya 1967–2000 (Beirut: al-Saqi Books, 2003) and Fakhri Qadduri's Hakadha ʿAriftu al-Bakr wa-Saddam: Rihlat 35 ʿAmman fi Hizb al-Baʿth (London: Dar al-Hikma, 2006).
Rohde correctly underlines the fact that the position of Saddam Husayn became even more central in the 1990s, due in part to the rapid expansion of the elaborate rewards system in the last decade of the regime. Medals were awarded to attract more people, because they were a key to eligibility for economic benefits. (On p. 69 Rohde confuses “Friends of the President” with the Saddamist Union. The former was created during the Iran–Iraq War and not in 1994, while the latter, headed by Husayn's elder son ʿUday, was established in the 1990s as an exclusive club of members chosen from the “Friends of the President,” when the number of “Friends” significantly increased.)
The second part of the book is stronger and more interesting. It deals with gender politics and the arts during the Baʿth period. Rohde brings many interesting elements to the overall understanding of this era, not least the thirty-one cartoons he reproduces from Iraqi newspapers that graphically illustrate some of the points he discusses. The section dealing with gender politics focuses on the activities of the General Federation of Iraqi Women and its head, Manal Yunis. The regime's ambivalence toward gender becomes apparent when comparing the 1970s to the 1990s. In the 1970s, the regime was secular and liberal, while twenty years later neotribalism and religiosity (at least publicly) dominated its policies. The 1990s signaled a notable deterioration in the position of women, and rising levels of unemployment created further pressure on their job opportunities. Rohde aptly describes the changes in Iraqi society resulting from the regime's tolerant policies toward honor killing and the pressure on women to produce children in order to counter Iran's demographic superiority.
In his section on arts and politics, Rohde addresses the issue of how the arts were absorbed into the expanding state. It is evident that when the Baʿth came to power in 1968, Iraq enjoyed a lively artistic life. During the economic boom of the 1970s—the result of the quadrupling of oil prices after 1973—the arts were massively funded by the state and fell under its control. By 1974, independent artistic associations were dissolved and integrated into Baʿthist-led organizations. Although authors (discussed by Rohde) such as Salam ʿAboud in his work Thaqafat al-ʿUnf fi al-ʿIraq (Culture of Violence in Iraq [Cologne, Germany: al-Kamel Publishers, 2002]) posit that artists under Saddam Husayn could only collaborate with the regime or go into physical or inner exile (p. 123), Rohde argues that many artists persevered in expressing themselves throughout the Baʿth era. His conclusion is that although many artists had to walk “a tightrope between selling one's soul and preserving artistic freedom,” ambiguities in a multitude of works “should be understood as reflections of a continuous struggle for cultural hegemony within the parameters set by the regime” (p. 156).
The second part of the book is undoubtedly an important contribution to research on Iraq during Saddam Husayn's regime and in the post-Baʿthist era. Unfortunately, Rohde's writing style is somewhat cumbersome, and one frequently feels that little effort was made to transform the PhD dissertation into an easily readable book.
