In Dance and Drama in French Baroque Opera, Rebecca Harris-Warrick explores the significance of dance and divertissement in French opera from 1672 to 1735. She argues against past assumptions that divertissements of song and dance are insignificant and what happens within them rarely matters, and asserts that “the divertissements offer the most sumptuous moments in Lully's operas, where the pacing of the music expands, the orchestra is given fuller voice, and the dancers are in motion” (23). She points out that Lully's opera, the Académie Royale de Musique, established the first permanent, professional dance troupe, and that its dancing masters developed a system of choreography that resulted in hundreds of dances originating from this stage. To illustrate the varied roles that dance takes on and to illuminate matters of staging, the author cites a wide range of documentation: libretti, scores, theoretical treatises, iconographic evidence, and eyewitness accounts of performances.
Part I deals with the era of Lully, from the time he took over control of the Académie Royale de Musique in 1672 until his death in 1687. The author analyzes three tragédies en musique that Lully composed to libretti by Philippe Quinault, and she attempts to reconstruct the conventions that they established for operatic divertissements. Dance music, she argues, is most often closely related, temporally and thematically, to solo vocal or choral music, with which it maintains a dramatic connection. Dancers, then, usually serve as body doubles for singers, with the dancers supplying the movement and the singers supplying the voices. Moreover, in most divertissement structures, singing alternates with dancing so that the audience's attention has a single focus—although one exception to this rule is toward the end of choruses, by which time the text has been heard by the audience multiple times and the dancers may move while the chorus sings. In sum, “dance is presented not as an interruption or as a parenthesis within the action, but as part of a natural continuum that incorporates multiple modes of expression” (69).
After the first two chapters survey the basic principles of baroque dance and examine the composition of Lully's dance troupe at the Académie Royale de Musique, Chapters 3 and 4 examine issues of staging and of musical characterization. Group dancing by males dominated during this time, and female dancers were introduced to the stage only in 1681. In the choral numbers, dance normally took place when the chorus was silent, and neither chorus members nor principal singers participated in the dance. In Chapters 5 and 6, the author turns to Lully's lighter works, where “dance functions differently from the tragédies” (3). Such works as Psyché (1671, 1678) and Acis et Galatée (1686) included comic or grotesque elements in which the connections between music and dance were more varied. Dance participated in the unfolding of the dramatic action by presenting ideas or themes relating to the lyrics of songs and choruses; or in some cases, the mental state of a character in the opera could be depicted through dance and mime.
Part II encompasses the period following Lully's death and the first operas of Rameau (beginning 1733), in which the Arcadian realms of earlier tragédies were replaced by contemporary locations. As the author explains in Chapter 7, after the Italian actors were dismissed from Paris in 1697, French opera absorbed characters and themes from the Théâtre Italien. The second part of the book is thus organized around the Three Muses, who vie for prominence during this transitional period in French opera history. Chapters 8, 9, and 10 cover works presided over by Thalia (Comedy), who allowed Italian comedy onto the stage of the Académie Royale de Musique. In Chapters 11 and 12, her sister Melpomene (Music) reasserted the dominance of the tragédie en musique. In Chapters 13 and 14, the influence of Terpsichore (Dance) is revealed in the growing company of dancers, the increased amount of dance in the divertissements, the emergence of star dancers, and a growing interest in pantomime. Group dancing dominated at first, but gradually the soloist (for example, Balon and Pécour) came into prominence. Once women were permitted to dance on the operatic stage in 1681, performers such as Prévost, Camargo, and Sallé gradually rose in importance. By the mid-eighteenth century, the solo dancer had achieved superstar status. Several of their dances at the Opéra survive among the forty-seven existing choreographies in Beauchamp–Feuillet notation.
With her authoritative command over numerous and varied musical, literary, and iconographic sources, Rebecca Harris-Warrick provides penetrating insight into the significance and diversity of dance in French baroque opera. Her study affirms the argument that the great French musicologist Henry Prunières made over a century ago in his L'opéra italien en France avant Lully (1913): “This fusion of ballet de cour and opera in a new genre explains, to a large extent, the curious structure of the tragédie en musique of Lully, where the intermèdes and dances are not superfluous divertissements, but are truly part of the action” (283; translation mine).
