No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 April 2005
Salma Ismail defines Islamist politics as “the activities of organizations and movements that mobilize and agitate in the political sphere while deploying signs and symbols from Islamic traditions. It is also used to refer to political activism involving informal groupings that (re)construct repertoires and frames of reference from Islamic traditions” (p. 2). This is distinct from re-Islamization, or “the process whereby various domains of social life are invested with signs and symbols associated with Islamic cultural traditions.” Islamism encompasses both. In light of these terms, Ismail's rethinking is primarily concerned with asking how and why Islamist politics—and therefore Islamism—has moved away from direct confrontation with the state and toward mutual co-optation that leads to a greater re–Islamization of society. To answer these questions, she applies a critical-historical and anthropological approach to Islamist politics.
Before addressing her conclusions, it is necessary to elucidate further her points of departure. She adopts Talal Asad's view of Islam as a “discursive tradition” because it “underscores the dynamic processes of power and resistance involved in the production of practices and ideas authorized as Islamic” (p. 17). Consequently, she criticizes as inadequate the essentialist, static, text-based vision of Islam she finds in the works of John Esposito and J. O. Voll. Rather than emphasizing Islamic traditions, norms, signs, and symbols, she asserts that these are constantly reworked, redefined, and reconstructed. She argues that it is groups and individuals who are the historical actors, not the slogans or religions they invoke. This brings her to what constitutes politics in general, and Islamist politics in particular.
Ismail is critical of those who use a political economy approach suggesting that individuals and groups will always respond in the same way to top-down political and economic forces. On the national and neighborhood levels, politics is shaped by power relations and struggles for hegemony. As a result of these power struggles, Islamist politics has shifted its focus from God's governance to public morality—that is, re-Islamization. While Olivier Roy views this shift as a sign of the failure of Islamism, Ismail sees the shift as part of a dynamic political process and evidence of Islamism's continuing impact and significance. These arguments are spelled out in chapters 1 and 6 and supported in chapters 2–5.
Chapters 2–4 analyze the power struggles and political dynamism that have shaped the development of Islamist politics on the national and local level in Egypt, while chapter 5 provides points of comparison by looking at the same issues in Algeria and Tunisia. Chapter 2 shows how the conservative Islamist position grew in strength from the conflict between the state and the radical Islamists. Ismail analyzes the sermons, tracts, and newspaper articles of conservative ulama, which highlight their focus on cultural confrontation, religious ritual, and public morality rather than politics or economics. In this process it is not clear who is co-opting whom. Chapter 3 argues that, because “public morality has emerged as an area of convergence among the various groups” (p. 59), the power struggle has shifted away from Islamic government toward Islamic law. She then analyzes how different groups initiated or responded to some of the high-profile court cases of the early 1990s, such as the case against Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd and against immodest movie posters. In chapter 4, she explains the success of Islamist groups in terms of their implantation and rootedness in the microeconomies and societies found in the popular neighborhoods and old quarters of the cities. She relies on secondary anthropological and urban studies and reports in the Egyptian newspapers on the location and nature of Islamist uprisings, the government response, and the profile of those arrested in those responses. Chapter 5 traces the evolution of Islamist politics in Algeria and Tunisia, focusing on the power struggles on the national level but also on urban studies of the role of Islamists within neighborhood networks. Although Ismail cites two interviews conducted in Tunis, she relies overwhelmingly on secondary articles and monographs. Nevertheless, the chapter works well, providing insightful points of similarity and difference with developments in Egypt.
The chapters on Egypt reflect years of research; in fact, they have all been previously published. Moreover, it is clear that this material has not been updated or synthesized for this book. For example, in chapter 2 Ismail speaks of Shaykh Sha

arawi as still living, mentions his death in passing in chapter 3, and makes no reference to the more recent cause célèbre,

Amr Khaled. Nevertheless, the book brings together a collection of solid comparative and complementary studies of the evolution of Islamism in the 1990s—studies that remain very prescient. After reading Ismail's book, I feel that I understand better my Cairene neighbors and students at the American University of Cairo. Re-Islamization is a sign not of political failure but of personal empowerment for a disfranchised and disenchanted populace/public. As she points out, commanding right and forbidding evil “is a claim to power which requires no sanctioning from the state” (p. 79). Nevertheless, she also expresses remorse that Islamism has become an agent of control rather than of liberation and has supported rather than challenged oppressive regimes and exploitative economies.
Ismail does an excellent job of placing the evolution of Islamism within its anthropological, sociological, political, and historical contexts. However, the players and patterns she describes—ulama cooperating with the state to increase their authority and neighborhoods isolating themselves from the state to increase theirs—is certainly familiar, if not normative, in Islamic history. Thus, she highlights how the relationship between tradition and interpretation, Islam and re-Islamization, and Islam and Islamist politics requires constant rethinking.