Alex Vernon's book Hemingway's Second War consciously draws attention to Michael Reynolds's “landmark text,” titled Hemingway's First War (1987), not to be presumptuous, but to call attention to the “similar spirit” the two books share. Vernon refers to their respective “discussion[s] of [Hemingway's] experience, their attention to the creative process, and their analysis of a major Hemingway war novel independent of biographical information” (xviii). In these correlations and amalgamation lie Vernon's methodology for approaching Hemingway's involvement in the Spanish Civil War, which begins with his battle reports for the North American Newspaper Alliance (NANA), continues with his contribution to Joris Ivens's 1937 film The Spanish Earth and ends with For Whom the Bell Tolls (1940). The book begins with a description of a photograph, which leads, in due course, to a series of questions about the nature of the photographic medium and, by extension, to the act of bearing witness to atrocities. Susan Sontag has written about “the tension between the act of witness and the art of witness” (xv), as Vernon notes; her work, engaging with such difficult aesthetics – the “aesthetics of destruction,” as she writes elsewhere – forms another, if quiet, influence on Vernon's study. In the introduction, he interrogates the practice of written reportage and contrasts it with “camerawork,” therefore also including filmmaking as well as documentary photography, which “pushes toward art” while journalism “rarely does.” He further remarks on the “commingling of subjectivity and objectivity,” operating differently in these modes of observation: “camerawork,” all the while pushing “toward art,” also dissembles this very effort by pretending to be purely objective, a dispassionate view of the events at hand. Even “the hurried dispatch” (xvi) of written eyewitness accounts, however, has to stand charge against accusations of bias, the “I” or “eye” that can only ever report from a personal standpoint.
This is, then, one argument that Vernon's analysis addresses, a line of reasoning that runs throughout the book, attending to the correlations between “personal experience, historical accountability, imagination, and art” (xvii). Each part seeks to tackle allegations of lack or failure on Hemingway's part, the “doubtful authenticity,” “curious monotony,” gratuitous use of violence, “triumphant boastfulness” (49) of his NANA reports; the betrayal of the Republic in For Whom the Bell Tolls – at every turn, in each subsequent chapter, Vernon proceeds to unpack such charges. In “Style, Politics, and the NANA dispatches,” for example, he points out the complex relationship between writer and editor, the economic conditions in which newspapers operate, the tedium of war, thus trying to contextualize Hemingway's comments. Vernon's study of For Whom the Bell Tolls follows a similar course so as to evaluate the novel in light of its ability to articulate what nonfiction often represses: “A solo Robert Jordan, without a uniform, afforded Hemingway the liberty of a complex character unfettered by actual unit history and politics” (149). For the most part, Vernon succeeds in refuting criticisms that appear to be unaware of such complexities – his work on “Pilar and Maria” and his last chapter, “From Frederic Henry to Robert Jordan,” are especially convincing, not least because his detailed close reading and intertextual approach end up investigating how “gender trouble,” earth imagery and the sexual/colonial imagination interrelate with the rhetoric of war.
In a book that is otherwise so attentive to its surroundings, in terms of both scholarship and contemporary geopolitics, it is, nonetheless, strange that Vernon does not overtly refer to the Nazi doctrine of Blut und Boden, for one, despite mentioning the novel's references that at times align the Republican and Fascist movements. Another oddity applies to the insistence on disproving communist allegations – thereby challenging impressions that the NANA dispatches or The Spanish Earth are propaganda materials – as if to clear Hemingway and his associates from being Comintern pawns, their work advancing the project of an international Communist conspiracy. In these passages, exoneration attempts that are sustained throughout the book, Vernon does not so much make reference to the war that is to come – Hemingway's Last War – or to the defence requirements against HUAC-type blacklisting and naming strategies, but rather gives the impression that he himself has become a victim of Cold War paranoia.
