Although the equestrian order may look prosaic beside the splendours of the senate, it can throw up strange antitheses. The reductio ad absurdum was the ‘kindergarten’ eques, epitomised by a three-year old knight pictured on his tiny steed (517). But, however surprising, this fairly late development did not spell the end of equestrian rank. The polar opposite was the eques as strongman politician, an intermittent archetype which ran from Maecenas, military controller of Rome and Italy in Augustus’ absence, to the prefect and Emperor Macrinus, and included the formidable figures of Sejanus, Perennis and Plautianus. Diocletian's emergence from the ranks as a great reformer was almost a throwback to their day. Between these extremes were the thousands of equestrian army officers, whose elite ran the Empire's financial and civil service, and the thousands more equites whose careers (if any) were municipal or judicial.
Equites with the full tally of ‘militiae’, probably lasting some three years each, would usually have had substantially more army service than almost any senator. Yet it was senators who led the armies in battle. In a warlike nation which took its soldiering seriously, the contradiction was somewhat surprising. There were compensating mechanisms, in the continuing recruitment of militiae men into the Senate (R. Duncan-Jones, Power and Privilege in Roman Society (2016), 10, 114), where as senators they could command legions and even whole armies, and in the equestrian commanders of the few legions in Egypt and Mesopotamia. But these offsets were very limited, and the central paradox remained. It was only after unprecedented disaster in the mid third century c.e., with the loss of an Emperor, several armies and most of the eastern high command (described in the Res Gestae Divi Saporis), that senators were removed from lesser army commands. By a further peculiarity of the system as it stood in the mid Principate, if equestrian army service led anywhere, it was usually not to higher military command, but to major administrative posts, most often as part of Rome's powerful tax-machine.
It is a bold man who adds a compact history to the enormous scholarly literature on the equites. Arthur Stein's valuable Der römische Ritterstand (1927) dates from before the war. But a series of monumental works have appeared more recently: Nicolet on the equites in the Republic, Demougin on the early Empire, Pflaum's extended survey of the procuratorial service and its members and Devijver's encyclopedic treatment of the militiae (not to mention essential studies such as R. Saller's article on procurators, JRS 70 (1980), 44–63). However a shorter summation remains desirable. Davenport's discussion is both learned and wide-ranging, and is equipped with an up-to-date bibliography on the grand scale (to which C. Chillet, De l’Étrurie à Rome (2016), on Maecenas, can be added). As the first extended treatment of the equites in English (H. Hill's The Roman Middle Class in the Republican Period (1952) was limited to the Republic), the book will be widely consulted. That makes a few debatable points worth noticing.
That elusive figure, the wealthy citizen who was considered an eques without conferment of rank, did not survive scrutiny in either of the modern large-scale surveys (most recently S. Demougin, L'ordre équestre sous les Julio-Claudiens (1988), 195–7), making his frequent appearance here somewhat disconcerting. In a neglected letter, Seneca's friend Lucilius had become an ‘eques Romanus’ through industria, and by undergoing selection, not merely by being well-to-do (Ep. 44.2). And, as has been shown more than once, ‘EQ(ues) R(omanus)’ seen in hundreds of inscriptions was a form of ‘EQVO PVBLICO’ (usually later), not, as has sometimes been suggested, something inferior. For D., self-styled equestrian rank even continued into the Flavian period (224–5), despite the insistence on equestrian descent as a special aristocratic status spelled out in the Larinum decree as early as c.e.19. The recruiting crisis among the equites under Augustus described by Dio (56.2–9) must clearly refer to holders of a conferred rank. Problems also arise with the tribunus militum a populo, widespread in Italian inscriptions under Augustus. For Syme and Nicolet, the passage of Suetonius about substantive military tribunes chosen by popular vote was sufficient explanation (Aug. 46). But D'Arms unpersuasively downgraded this to a nominal rank (191).
One of the book's theses is maintaining close parallelism between equites and senators. Unlike some, D. follows Alföldy's adventurous view that senatorial posts generally carried salaries, like those of equestrian procurators. But that seems to conflict with the blueprint in the Dio/Maecenas speech, where senators are salaried if governors, in order to reimburse them for foreign service, whereas procurators receive salaries as a general compensation for being poorer than senators. There is no sign of salaries in the case of Gavius Clarus, an indigent senator who nevertheless saved enough to be quaestor and aedile, but depended for the expenses of the praetorship on an Imperial loan, which he repaid in due course (Fronto, ed. van den Hout, 127–8).
Despite the potency of the equestrian prefects, ‘senator’ meant ‘grand seigneur’ in a way that ‘eques’ never could. If a well-respected senator could no longer afford the princely lifestyle to which members of his class were accustomed, the Emperor might respond with a cash grant of staggering size. Appointing equestrians to special positions alongside senators reflected not so much parity between the two orders (as D. is inclined to suggest) as flexibility in one case, and inflexibility in the other. The senatorial career was embedded in powerful rules and protocols which the Emperor infringed at his peril, whereas procurators (like Domitius Marsianus, whose thoughtful advice from Marcus Aurelius we can still read) were his personal servants, and could effectively be sent wherever he chose. ‘For all practical purposes it did not matter whether an office-holder was an eques or a senator since they were all appointed by imperial favour’ (369). But this allows too little for the senatorial elections and proconsular ballots whose workings Pliny documents, even if the Emperor had powers of override. The typical lifestyles could be drastically different, with the result that ordinary equites, with no residence requirement unless jurors, and spared the expenses of a grand house in the capital, were far more likely to seek local glory by serving as magistrates or priests at home.
D.'s coverage of the main equestrian topics is assiduous and efficient. The later mutations of equestrian rank and its enlargement into something more powerful are closely examined in the final chapters. Perhaps more might have been said about the municipal activities of equites, and their recurrent role as curatores rei publicae. From the many careers in Italy and the West, we see that towns with an equestrian curator tended to be middle-ranking places, which stood below those where a senator was in charge, but above those in municipal hands (F. Jacques, Le privilège de liberté (1984), ch. 3). The activities of equites as jurors and businessmen might also have been discussed further, though detailed evidence is mostly lacking.
In general, the narrative is fluent, proficient and carefully documented over an enormous chronological span. As one example among many, D. is particularly good at tracing areas of ad hoc overlap between senatorial and equestrian authority, with his full lists in ch. 11 of senators acting for equites, and vice versa. His book marks an important advance. It has the very welcome bonus of a large dossier of photographs, showing both funerary monuments and statue-bases of equites. Many of the inscriptions are reproduced in full in the text as well as being translated.
