Within a peace and security context, essentialized gender roles have often been sustained by international law and policy.Footnote 1 While the differing impact of armed conflict on men and women is increasingly acknowledged,Footnote 2 constructions of ‘gender’ and gender-specific provisions within international humanitarian law have proved problematic.Footnote 3 Advances in women's human rights and other international instruments, principally Section E of the Beijing Platform for Action, which centres on women and armed conflict,Footnote 4 have gone some way towards developing the scope of existing provisions. Despite increased awareness of gender-based violence, however, significant challenges remain.
First, analyses of the gendered dynamics of conflict have largely focused on sexual violence and rape.Footnote 5 While women are often the primary target of sexual violence,Footnote 6 the wider social impact is intrinsically linked to both genders.Footnote 7 Significantly, in non-international armed conflicts, rape has often been committed in orchestrated campaigns of ethnic cleansing that seek to undermine familial structures.Footnote 8 For example, in Rwanda, the deliberate impregnation of Tutsi women by Hutus sought to undermine the social fabric of communities.Footnote 9 On the one hand, this open acknowledgement of gender-based violence suggests that gender is expressly recognized at a normative level. However, this normative recognition aligns gender directly with women and victimhood, which undermines women's agency as active participants and distorts discourses by failing to consider women's broader experience of armed conflict.Footnote 10 Indirectly, these narratives censor the diverse ways in which women participate in armed conflict as actors, combatants or peace-builders.Footnote 11 Furthermore, both sexual violence discourses and international legal provisions largely fail to consider men's experience of sexual violence in conflict, which sustains a ‘male-perpetrator and female-victim paradigm’Footnote 12 that is ultimately detrimental to both men and women.
Second, the prevalence of non-international armed conflict challenges the foundations of international humanitarian law.Footnote 13 Although this is a general dilemma, when considered in the light of gendered understandings of armed conflict, the challenges appear even more acute. Provisions are not sophisticated enough to respond to the complex intersection of gender, ethnicity and other aspects of identity, which may be all the more pertinent in non-international armed conflicts as nationality is not the dominant differentiation between parties. More recent developments in public international law, specifically UN Security Council Resolution 1325 on women, peace and securityFootnote 14 and UN Security Council Resolution (SC Res.) 1820 focusing on sexual violence in conflict,Footnote 15 contain empowerment as well as protection clauses, which may help to broaden recognition of women's multiple roles in conflict. The aim of this paper is to critically evaluate whether the process of gender mainstreaming using SC Res. 1325 and SC Res. 1820Footnote 16 helps to strengthen constructions of gender within international humanitarian law, giving due consideration to the exploitation of gender stereotypes in armed conflict.
Gender, armed conflict and international humanitarian law
Legal protections afforded to women in conflict situations have long been criticized as being divorced from the reality of women's experiences.Footnote 17 However, the aims of legal provisions echo more general tensions within equality discourses, which stem from the sameness versus difference debate. Liberal feminists have striven for equality on the basis of sameness, but this has not always proved radical enough to challenge gender inequality and denies acknowledgement of different social functions, including pregnancy and motherhood.Footnote 18 International humanitarian law attempts to balance both general (sameness-based) and special (difference-based) protection measures: women must be ‘treated humanely […] without any adverse distinction founded on sex’,Footnote 19 at the same time as being ‘ … treated with all the regard due to their sex’.Footnote 20
Inevitably, in attempting to acknowledge women's difference, many of the protective measures that address the status of women as civilians are based on biological factors. For example, under Article 8(a) of Additional Protocol I, maternity cases are prioritized in medical assistance to the wounded and sick, irrespective of whether military personnel or civilian.Footnote 21 Additionally, Article 14 of the Fourth Geneva Convention recognizes expectant mothers and mothers of children under seven as a specific category that may require special protection along with the wounded, sick, children under fifteen and the aged.Footnote 22 Indirectly these provisions essentialize women as mothers and care-givers, failing to broach broader issues of how gender-based social constructions often exacerbate social, economic and structural inequalities that heavily influence physical violence and conflict.Footnote 23
Responses to sexual violence also indicate how gender stereotypes have been sustained, particularly the perception of women as victims. A number of key provisions centre on the protection of women rather than prohibition of gender-based atrocities.Footnote 24 For example, within the ambit of the Fourth Geneva Convention, female civilians in an occupied territory, internees and refugees must be protected against any attack on their honour, including rape, enforced prostitution, or any form of indecent assault.Footnote 25
Based on moral integrity rather than physical harm or trauma, this provision perpetuates rape as being taboo. In societies where a culture of honour is ingrained, this perception is detrimental to many women. It is suggested that the prevalence of rape is particularly high where the social stigma is strongest,Footnote 26 and in an examination of acts of aggression in Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina a direct link is drawn between rape during peacetime and rape during conflict:
‘War rapes in the former Yugoslavia would not be such an effective weapon of torture and terror if it were not for concepts of honor, shame and sexuality that are attached to women's bodies in peacetime.’Footnote 27
Furthermore, while Article 76 of Additional Protocol I does not reiterate the same concept of honour, women are deemed an ‘object of special respect’.Footnote 28 As Gardam suggests, the nature of these provisions has little to do with women's experience of sexual violence, instead pertaining to a concept of honour that is socially constructed and sustained by dominant masculinities.Footnote 29 In the former Yugoslavia many rapes involved gang rape or sexual torture, and in some instances sexual assaults between family members were forced upon them.Footnote 30 Underlying these acts, targeted at women, is the exploitation of a misogynist masculinity stereotype.Footnote 31 It would be a misnomer to suggest that this exploitation does not have negative repercussions for men as well as women. For example, male on male rape is used to humiliate and emasculate enemy soldiers.Footnote 32
While the World Health Organization (WHO) recognizes that women are particularly susceptible to sexual violence, male rape may also be under-reported because of the stigma attached to sexual violence against men.Footnote 33 International humanitarian law does not address male rape directly; it focuses primarily on rape as an act against a woman's honour, and therefore as an act that can only be carried out by men against women. The concept of rape in international humanitarian law is based not on aggression, but instead underpinned by a conception of women as property and a spoil of war.Footnote 34
In non-international armed conflicts the intersection between sexual violence and gender with other aspects of identity is inherently complex. As recognized by the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), the application of international humanitarian law to intra-state conflict is particularly challenging.Footnote 35 Gardam suggests that Article 1(4) of Additional Protocol I effectively elevates self-determination wars to international status.Footnote 36 Although applying the jus in bello of international armed conflict to liberation wars is not the same as legitimizing them under jus ad bellum, Gardam cautions that within Article 44(3) of Additional Protocol I combatants are not required to carry arms openly at all times, thus placing women and children civilians at increased risk of being used as shields until the very point of attack.Footnote 37
At the same time, a shift away from a more stringent principle of distinction in self-determination and liberation conflicts could paradoxically serve to benefit unarmed women combatants during the post-conflict period. Although it is, strictly speaking, applicable only to international armed conflicts, the principle of distinction between combatant and non-combatant also has repercussions for non-international armed conflicts. At present, Disarmament, Demobilization and Reintegration (DDR) processes in the post-conflict period following non-international armed conflicts tend to overlook women members of armed groups, as they are less likely to carry arms. A typical DDR process may include HIV/AIDS testing, skills training and some monetary compensation in exchange for a weapon,Footnote 38 and recognition of women combatants, irrespective of whether they carry arms openly or not, may allow for their greater inclusion in DDR processes. While consideration of the post-conflict period may be beyond the scope of jus in bello and seemingly irrelevant, the transition lines between conflict and peace are even more tenuous in non-international armed conflicts and struggles for self-determination. More recent developments in public international law suggest that armed conflict and its significant impact on women, during and after armed conflicts, is increasingly recognized.
Progressive judgements at the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR)Footnote 39 and the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY)Footnote 40 have impacted on the long-standing Geneva Conventions by enhancing provisions on gender-based violence. For example, the landmark Akayesu judgementFootnote 41 of the ICTR deemed rape to be a crime against humanity,Footnote 42 as well as recognizing it as a ‘form of aggression’.Footnote 43 The judgement also affirmed that rape could potentially be classified as an act of genocide,Footnote 44 where it constitutes an ‘act committed with intent to destroy in whole or part a national, ethnical, racial or religious group’.Footnote 45 Under Article 2(2)(d) of the ICTR's Statute, which refers to the deliberate ‘[imposition of] measures intended to prevent births within the group’,Footnote 46 rape is considered to be a weapon of war. Within the judgement, reference is made to the way in which rape is employed to undermine the social fabric of ethnic and racial groups:
In patriarchal societies, where membership of a group is determined by the identity of a father, an example of a measure intended to prevent births within a group is the case where, during rape, a woman of the said group is deliberately impregnated by a man of another group with the intent to have her give birth to a child who will consequently not belong to its mother's group.Footnote 47
Significantly, the Akayesu judgement situates rape as a crime causing serious bodily and mental harm, reorienting previous conceptions of rape as a moral crime against a woman's honour. Despite this important shift, the ICTR's approach to rape as a ‘weapon of war’ has been called into question by critics such as Buss, who note that recognition of rape as an act of genocide may create a high threshold or bar, against which all levels of sexual violence will be measured.Footnote 48 Certainly the prosecution of individual acts of rape has been lacking, and cases of male rape have also received limited scrutiny.Footnote 49 This could accordingly result in a lack of legal redress for individual acts of rape and sexual violence which are not part of a wider or systemic attack, leading Buss to suggest that there is both a ‘hyper-visibility and un-visibility of sexual violence’.Footnote 50
It is clear that legal provisions alone will not enforce the prosecution of sexual violence, but the language of law plays an important role in constructing understandings of gender-based violence in conflict. While the language of the Geneva Conventions appears outdated, the remit of their provisions on rape may have greater applicability to individual acts of rape. Equally, the legal definitions and decisions coming out of the ICTR may not be sophisticated enough to respond to all elements of sexual violence in conflict. However, the perception of rape as a weapon of war is nevertheless important, as it helps to establish rape as a crime of harm rather than of honour, an aspect that seems to be overlooked in Buss' analysis. Particularly in non-international armed conflicts, however, if rape is targeted at a specific group of women on the basis of ethnicity or another aspect of identity, the current focus on harm to the group may still result in rape having connotations of a crime against the honour of the group.
The full impact of this judgement at the international level may take some time to materialize, but provisions contained within the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC) suggest that a precedent has been set. For example, under Article 7(1)(g) of the Rome Statute, rape, sexual slavery, enforced prostitution, forced pregnancy, enforced sterilization, or any other form of sexual violence of comparable gravity is recognized as a crime against humanity.Footnote 51 Additionally, sexual mutilation,Footnote 52 which often accompanied rape in Rwanda, could be construed as falling within the remit of Article 6, given the resulting long-term health implications that could impede the ability to reproduce.Footnote 53
Judgements at the ICTY have adopted a similar stance towards the prosecution of rape. In Kunarac, sexual enslavement was classified as a crime against humanity or a war crime under Article 27 of the Fourth Geneva Convention,Footnote 54 with the further specification that rape occurs in all situations where consent is not given ‘freely’ or ‘voluntarily’, thus expanding the definition of rape given in Akayesu. Footnote 55 Despite these positive developments, there is no indication that existing provisions on rape in armed conflict will be improved. In the mid-nineties the ICRC declared that rape constituted a grave breach under the Fourth Convention's Article 147, though at the time Niarchos raised concern that this broader interpretation lacked weight without any explicit amendment to include rape as a grave breach.Footnote 56 Although there is now widespread recognition of sexual violence in conflict, existing gender-specific provisions remain inadequate.
Mainstreaming gender in international humanitarian law
Equality policy initiatives, particularly gender mainstreaming, offer scope for the integration of gender into international humanitarian law and policy. The principal aim of gender mainstreaming is to achieve gender equality by implementing gender as a central component at all levels within the UN system and beyond.Footnote 57 The process also evaluates the impact, on men and women, of all policies at all stages of design, implementation and monitoring. In contrast to other equality initiatives, premised on equal treatment and non-discrimination, gender mainstreaming is primarily designed to target equality of outcome rather than equality of opportunity. It is not immediately obvious why mainstreaming has been employed so readily in a peace and security context; however, the UN Decade for Women affirmed the relationship between equality, peace and development.Footnote 58
In addition, the Beijing Platform for Action consolidated the concept of gender mainstreaming and highlighted women's experience of armed conflict as a critical area of concern.Footnote 59 Both SC Res. 1325 and SC Res. 1820, relating to women, peace and security, have increasingly been used as gender mainstreaming tools and may help to develop key norms on women and armed conflict, thus enhancing understandings of gender in international humanitarian law.
Adopted in October 2000, SC Res. 1325 is the first Security Council resolution to focus specifically on women's experience of armed conflict. SC Res. 1325 aims to empower women at all levels of decision-making in conflict prevention, conflict resolution and peace-building, in addition to reducing gender-based violence. Rather than marginalizing women's experiences, it appears to bring gender-specific concerns within mainstream peace and security policy considerations. Substantively, the framework of SC Res. 1325 includes a preamble and eighteen clauses. First, the preamble recalls a number of Security Council resolutions that have addressed both the position of children and armed conflictFootnote 60 and the protection of civilians in armed conflict.Footnote 61 Significantly, the role of women in conflict prevention, resolution and peace-building is reaffirmed.Footnote 62 Gender mainstreaming is only specifically identified in relation to peacekeeping missions.Footnote 63
When referred to in practice SC Res. 1325 often appears to be considered as an independent framework, without clear recognition of how the resolution is interlinked with existing conventions. Although not creating any substantive rights as such, SC Res. 1325 does make reference to existing obligations under the Geneva Conventions of 1949Footnote 64 and the Additional Protocols of 1977;Footnote 65 the Refugee Convention of 1951Footnote 66 and the Protocol thereto of 1967;Footnote 67 Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW)Footnote 68 and the Optional Protocol thereto of 1999;Footnote 69 the Convention on the Rights of the Child 1989Footnote 70 and the two Optional Protocols thereto of 2000;Footnote 71 and relevant provisions of the ICC Statute.Footnote 72 An illustration of the relevance of substantive legal provisions can be seen in the protection of women and children as civilians, which is a key component of international humanitarian law.Footnote 73 In the resolution's Clause 10, relating to gender-specific protective measures, the Security Council:
calls on all parties to armed conflict to take special measures to protect women and girls from gender-based violence, particularly rape and other forms of sexual abuse, and all other forms of violence in situations of armed conflict.Footnote 74
This provision suggests that recognition of gender-specific harms forms an integral component of the gender mainstreaming process by enabling appropriate policy responses to be developed. For instance, levels of gender-based violence that occur before, during and after conflict could provide a gender-specific indicator, allowing an assessment of the success of the gender mainstreaming process in reducing these harms in practice. However, the framework of SC Res. 1325 does not provide any clear indication of how a gender mainstreaming process using, for example, gender-based violence indicators, should operate in a peace and security context. Given that the link between gender-based harms and the gender mainstreaming process is not made explicit, but is dependent on different actors' interpretations, gender-specific issues may be seen as inimical rather than central to the gender mainstreaming process.
Clause 10 of SC Res. 1325 recognizes the proliferation of gender-based atrocities in situations of conflict. As other human rights conventions, including CEDAW, do not directly address armed conflict, the resolution's remit enhances rights-based treaty provisions. Additionally, Clause 11 reinforces recognition of sexual violence and rape as crimes against humanity and war crimes, thereby further supporting protection measures under the Geneva Conventions, and it is clear that these connections need to be strengthened:
Emphasizes the responsibility of all States to put an end to impunity and to prosecute those responsible for genocide, crimes against humanity, and war crimes including those relating to sexual violence against women and girls, and in this regard stresses the need to exclude these crimes, where feasible from amnesty provisions.Footnote 75
While there is scope to advocate the increased protection of women and girls under Clause 8(a), which calls for all actors involved in peace negotiations and agreements to consider the ‘special needs of women and girls during repatriation and resettlement and for rehabilitation, reintegration and post-conflict reconstruction’,Footnote 76 the conceptualization of conflict that triggers SC Res. 1325 fails to provide a means of addressing interpersonal violence. Although SC Res. 1325 can go some way to address violations, it is questionable whether it is able to permeate the private dichotomy.Footnote 77 While this may not be its intended function, the resolution is not sophisticated enough to respond to structural and less overt forms of violence. As a result, a narrow construction of peace and security based on the negative peace paradigm, which centres on the cessation of direct violence, is maintained. Reinforcing the public sphere bias of international legal instruments, SC Res. 1325 does not engage with the way in which structural forms of violence often exacerbate gender inequalities.
First, the very nature of SC Res. 1325's reference in Clause 10 to ‘situations of armed conflict’ is ambiguous. Given that asymmetrical warfare is increasingly prevalent, state actors may be displaced by non-state actors as the chief protagonists of war. Reference to the Geneva Conventions and their Additional Protocols in Clause 9Footnote 78 suggests that the resolution is applicable to both international and non-international armed conflict. However, without further guidance as to exactly how non-state actors are defined, there is no guarantee that non-state actors will include private individuals other than those involved in armed militias and irregular armies. While the punishment of individuals for rape in armed conflict is not dependent on their membership of an armed group, as Buss highlights in her analysis of responses to rape at the ICTR, the prosecution of individuals for acts of rape or sexual violence already appears limited.Footnote 79 Moreover, instances of intra-personal violence often increase both during and after conflict,Footnote 80 which suggests a correlation between violence in conflict and peace, but SC Res. 1325 does not broach this dilemma.
Although SC Res. 1325 appears to strengthen norms on women, peace and security, the framework has regularly been criticized for failing to include benchmarks and targets.Footnote 81 Experiences to date suggest that, if used at all, SC Res. 1325 is employed by policy makers in relation to peacekeeping operations and DDR processes. This narrow application risks shortfalls in implementation by overlooking the resolution's provisions on access to decision-making and violence against women, which are equally important to the overall structure of SC Res. 1325.
Significantly, some civil society actors have cautioned that any further follow-up resolutions could detract from the framework of SC Res. 1325.Footnote 82 Despite these concerns, in June 2008 the Security Council debated and passed a new US-sponsored resolution on women, peace and security, SC Res. 1820, focused principally on sexual violence in armed conflict. In its preamble, it reaffirms the importance of ending impunity for all forms of violence against women and girl civilians both during and after armed conflicts, especially sexual violence, and in so doing aims to bridge the gap between international humanitarian law and international human rights law. This link is reinforced by recognition that the use of rape as a weapon of war and other sexual violence may continue beyond the cessation of armed conflict.
The framework of SC Res. 1820 strengthens understandings of sexual violence in armed conflict beyond the limited remit of existing gender-based provisions under the Geneva Conventions. For example, Clause 1 not only recognizes systematic use of sexual violence against civilian populations, but also pinpoints how it can ‘significantly exacerbate situations of armed conflict’ and stresses the importance of prevention.Footnote 83 In this respect, Clause 3 sets out a range of measures to enhance the protection of civilians, with particular reference to women and girls. These measures include military training on the prohibition of all forms of sexual violence, and disciplinary action against those security forces who commit acts of rape or sexual violence. The evacuation of women and children under imminent threat of sexual violence to safety is also stipulated, which demonstrates a shift towards preventative rather than reactionary measures, thus helping to expand norms on conflict prevention.
Prior to the adoption of SC Res. 1820, advocates of SC Res. 1325 criticized the substantive aims of the resolution for doing more harm than good:
[SC Res. 1820] provides watered down versions of the issues, and undermines what we have. For example: [Clause] 4 states that ‘sexual violence “can” constitute a war crime; a crime against humanity, or a constitutive act with respect to genocide.’ But sexual violence is already recognised as such in international law. The word ‘can’ undermines this.Footnote 84
Alternatively, by diversifying conceptions of sexual violence to include both individual and systemic attacks and thus overcoming limitations in both the Geneva Conventions and the ICTR judgements, the inclusion of the word ‘can’ may help to alleviate concerns that the threshold for the prosecution of sexual violence in conflict is set too high. While this semantic shift may appear minor, the introduction of a series of Security Council resolutions focused on sexual violence, including SC Res. 1820, may weaken rather than strengthen SC Res. 1325 by diluting the crystallization of important norms on women, peace and security, which are aimed at both empowering and protecting women.
SC Res. 1325 is often perceived as a landmark precisely because it aims to support the transition of women from victims to actors. For example, its Clause 1, focused on the subject of decision-making, ‘Urges Member States to ensure increased representation of women at all decision-making levels in national, regional and international institutions and mechanisms for the prevention, management, and resolution of conflict’.Footnote 85 On the surface, these provisions may appear ‘tokenistic’, but given the initial resistance to SC Res. 1325 by States Parties, the inclusion of empowerment clauses is significant. To a certain extent, the language of SC Res. 1325 attempts to displace the exploitation of gender stereotypes and helps to develop norms on women's participation in conflict prevention, conflict resolution and peace-building processes.
There is growing recognition that women play a number of roles in conflict, particularly within irregular armies and militia groups during non-international armed conflicts. For example, Coulter considers the role of armed women fighters as members of the armed forces in Sierra Leone, who are often perceived as abnormal transgressors stepping beyond the acceptable boundaries of feminine behaviour.Footnote 86 Even within irregular armies women are frequently exposed to more egalitarian political roles. A good illustration here is the experience of women guerrillas in El Salvador who were provided with means of contraception, thus gaining autonomy over their own reproductive capacity and sexuality.Footnote 87 Other commentators observe the way in which spaces open up for women's organizing and activism during the post-conflict period.Footnote 88 While women's participation in informal peace processes is often encouraged,Footnote 89 it is particularly difficult for women to gain access to formal decision-making processes. For example, in Iraq many women's organizations have been forced underground by threats of violence and intimidation.Footnote 90 These examples illustrate the importance of women's agency and represent an important departure from the ‘women as victims’ paradigm. This is not to suggest that the prevention of sexual violence in conflict should not be a major priority, but the adoption of further Security Council resolutions that sustain focus on sexual violence may invariably stall the development of laws and policies which recognize women's multiple roles in conflict.
Conclusion
Underpinning the Geneva Conventions is a ‘male as perpetrator, female as victim paradigm’ that serves to exploit gender stereotypes in conflict. Although gender-specific provisions are contained within international humanitarian law, the exploitation of women as victims has been sustained, if not reinforced in practice. ‘Vaguely termed’ language, which focuses on concepts such as honour and dignity, means that the ‘sexual nature of the crime [of rape] is indeterminable’.Footnote 91 Judgements at the ICTR and ICTY have gone some way to reorient conceptions of rape as a crime against a woman's honour to rape as a crime causing serious bodily and mental harm. Nevertheless, perceptions of gender in armed conflict continue to be aligned with women and victimhood, and concerns have been raised that individual acts of rape against men and women will be overlooked in situations where rape is utilized as a ‘weapon of war’.
Recent resolutions stemming from the Security Council, such as SC Res. 1325, have attempted to empower as well as protect women. While SC Res. 1325 has increasingly been used to mainstream gender in security sector reform, current approaches to gender mainstreaming appear to echo liberal feminist approaches to gender equality. Integrationist gender mainstreaming policies are to be credited for considering women's experiences, but ultimately an approach that ‘adds women and stirs’ fails to challenge how existing legal provisions, combined with gender-blind international institutions, have disempowered women and exacerbated the exploitation of gender stereotypes. In the case of SC Res. 1325, stronger links need to be established with substantive legal provisions, including the Geneva Conventions and respective Protocols, the CEDAW and the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court.
Additional Security Council resolutions on women, peace and security, among them SC Res. 1820, do help to expand norms on conflict prevention – including the evacuation of women and girls susceptible to sexual violence – an element that may appear beyond the scope of international humanitarian law. Nevertheless, the complexity of non-international armed conflicts, which engage multiple non-state actors and militia groups, means that the scope of international humanitarian law needs to evolve or risk faltering. However, provisions contained in SC Res. 1820 also fail to move away from the ‘woman as victims’ paradigm and thus reinforce many of those same conceptual constraints present in international humanitarian law. Furthermore, SC Res. 1820 risks diluting SC Res. 1325's attempts to empower women in conflict prevention, resolution and peace-building processes.
It is clear that the relationship between gender and international humanitarian law is problematic. Without any amendment to the Geneva Conventions, the adoption of alternative legal instruments that broach gender in a more sophisticated way and support existing international humanitarian law provisions becomes increasingly important. As evidenced by the shortcomings of SC Res. 1325 and SC Res. 1820, the language of Security Council resolutions, though well-intentioned, is limited in how it can aid constructions of gender in armed conflict. Constructions of gender within international humanitarian law are thus constrained without any radical form of redress.
