Muslim movements of reform in sub-Saharan Africa have attracted considerable attention in recent years. Yet, despite a plethora of studies on aspects of Islamic ‘reform’, some regions of sub-Saharan Africa have remained under-researched. The Gold Coast (contemporary Ghana) as well as Haute Volta (contemporary Burkina Faso) are the most prominent examples. Ousman Murzik Kobo's Unveiling Modernity in Twentieth-Century West African Islamic Reforms is thus a welcome contribution to fill this gap. In a long-term historical perspective, he analyses the development of Muslim movements of reform in a region that has long resisted Islamization: Burkina Faso until the late nineteenth century, Ghana, in particular southern Ghana, until today. Kobo has organized his text into four thematic blocks, namely, history, early implantation, maturation, and the most recent development of Wahhabi-oriented movements of reform since the 1990s. Moving back and forth between Burkina Faso and Ghana, Kobo follows the historical trajectory of reformers vis-à-vis ‘modernity’ and shows how various ‘ahl al-sunna’ groups and scholars, often known as ‘Wahhabis’ locally, have tried to navigate colonial and postcolonial modernity.
Kobo starts out with late precolonial times and describes the general social and political context in which Muslims were living in the regions that were dominated by non-Muslim polities until the late nineteenth century. He identifies criteria of ‘Islamization’ and defines what constitutes a Muslim society (p. 54). While at first glance this effort at ‘defining’ Muslims may look rather formalistic, establishing such a reference point it is an important analytical step. ‘Wahhabi’-oriented reformers have regularly disputed the ‘Islamic’ character of local societies and accused Muslims of practicing ‘un-Islamic innovations’.
In his second thematic block, Kobo moves into the colonial period and analyses British and French policies towards Muslims in the region. It is important to note here that the rise of ‘Wahhabi’-oriented reform was preceded by the rise of two Sufi-oriented movements of reform, namely, the Kaolack/Senegal based Niass branch and the Nioro/Mali based Hamawiyya branch of the Tijaniyya. These Sufi movements of reform received some attention in the larger French West African colonial realm (pp. 97–111) due to their allegedly ‘subversive’ character. By contrast, in both Ghana and Burkina Faso, in general Muslims were not a major concern for French and British colonial administrations. Colonial administration attitudes towards Islam in these territories could rather be characterized by the term ‘benign respect’ (p. 74). It has to be noted, however, that Wahhabi critiques of both the Tijaniyya and local practices of Islam branded as ‘un-Islamic innovations’ mirrored the colonial critique of African customs, often depicted as ‘superstition’, making colonial administrations and Muslim reformers unusual partners in the project of modernization.
Kobo subsequently presents the early implantation of ‘Wahhabi’-oriented reformers in colonial Ghana and Burkina Faso. He focuses in particular on the way in which ‘Wahhabis’ entered villages and towns for the first time and records the popular reaction to these ‘strange fellows’ and their new and ‘sacrilegious’ ritual and behaviour (p. xv). This approach allows him to point out clearly what ‘reform’ actually meant in diverse local contexts. The first reformist organization in Burkina Faso in fact was the Union Culturelle Musulmane as established in 1953 by the Senegalese scholar Cheikh Touré. In 1962, this movement became the Communauté Musulmane (p. 124ff). The early 1960s were also marked by the return of the first graduates from Saudi Arabia such as al-Hajj Muhammad Malick Sana, Imam Sayoula Ouédraogo, and Abubakar Kanozoe, who were soon called Makka Moimba, the ‘Meccan scholars’ (p. 131). In Ghana, al-Hajj Yussif Salih Afa Ajura was the founder of the first ‘Wahhabi’-oriented movement of reform (p. 154ff). In the late 1950s, he established the first reformist school in Tamale, the ‘Madrasat Ambariyya’. Like his Burkinabe contemporaries, his critique was directed against the Tijaniyya as well as against local customs of Islam, in particular marriage and funeral ceremonies that were criticized as being un-Islamic. In 1959, the first Anglo-Arabic school was established in Kumasi, southern Ghana, by al-Hajj Adam Appiedu, whose reformist orientation had been informed by his studies at the markaz (centre) of Shaykh Adam al-Iluri in Lagos (p. 173).
Kobo then moves on to the period of ‘maturation’ and the emergence of ‘proper’ organizations of reform in the 1970s and the 1980s. In Burkina Faso, the most important organization in this period was the ‘Mouvement Sunnite’, founded in 1973 as a result of the first disputes among the ‘Meccan scholars’ and the Communauté Musulmane. Their disputes had led to violent clashes in 1973 over the control of mosques and leadership (p. 198). In Ghana, the ‘Wahhabi’-oriented movement of reform equally gained momentum in this period of time through the activities of al-Hajj Umar Ibrahim, Ghana's first graduate from the University of Medina in 1968 (p. 211), who set up the ‘Islamic research and Reformation Centre’ in Nima/Accra in 1970. Yet, by contrast with Burkina Faso, where the Mouvement Sunnite was a nation-wide organization, ‘Wahhabi’-oriented reform in Ghana consisted of a network of independent groups in the different parts of the country (p. 232). Their efforts to develop modern Islamic education contributed to the success of ‘Wahhabi’-oriented movements of reform in this period (p. 254ff). ‘Wahhabi’ schools were characterized by the chalkboard, the exercise book, class rooms, benches, a curriculum that included Western subjects, school uniforms, and attachment to the school rather than the teacher. ‘Wahhabi’ schools provided faster progress in Arabic and the memorization of the Qur'an than qur'anic schools (p. 265). The success of the new schools shows that ‘Wahhabism’ and the new schools established by ‘Wahhabi’ scholars indeed ‘served as a source of empowerment for new elites that emerged from colonial rule’ (p. 245).
Since the 1990s, ‘Wahhabi’-oriented movements of reform lost their ‘initial steam’ in both Ghana and Burkina Faso with the death of the first generation of charismatic leaders, internal disputes, and the rise of a second generation of Arabophone scholars. ‘Wahhabi’-oriented groups in Ghana and Burkina Faso have become less radical, particularly in their stance toward the Tijaniyya. Tijanis and ‘Wahhabis’ have entered into national dialogues that has led to a modus vivendi between the two camps. A paradigmatic case was al-Hajj Umar Ibrahim who was prepared to start a process of reconciliation with Tijani scholars in 1986. This move led to a split within the Ghanaian ‘Islamic Research and Reformation Centre’. The ‘Mouvement Sunnite’ in Burkina Faso equally disintegrated between 1988 and 1992 due to internal conflicts over leadership and orientation.
Ousman Murzik Kobo's analysis of ‘Wahhabi’-oriented movements of reform in Burkina Faso and Ghana is based on his thorough knowledge of local sources and numerous conversations with Muslim scholars of different orientations. His study provides precious insight into local dynamics of reform. The comparative nature of his study enables him to identify important structural patterns in the development of movements of reform in these countries but also to identify important differences. His text is a valuable contribution to the ‘phenomenology’ of Islamic reform in sub-Saharan Africa and a ‘must’ for all those interested in the history of Muslims in both Burkina Faso and Ghana.
