In thinking through how to approach the remit of such an article—that is, to provide a review for CQ readers from an Australian perspective—there are a number of ways in which ethical issues of interest to healthcare professionals can be framed. A philosophical bioethicist might, justifiably, present the state of debate among Australian bioethicists on the abstract metaissues that can background ethical decisionmaking in healthcare.Footnote 1 A legal academic may be inclined to approach the task from the point of view of reflecting on precedents set in recent court deliberations around particular medical-legal cases or on recent laws entailing medical ethical ramifications that have been enacted within Australian legislatures, and their regulation. The present article touches on each of these domains, while taking a third path that is intimately informed by an interest in the conduct of ethical research as it applies in healthcare settings. To that end, this article is concerned with contextualizing and explaining the regulatory frameworks in Australia that healthcare professionals—including social researchers in healthcare—are expected to observe and uphold, and it includes a brief discussion of one highly publicized case study that continues to test the boundaries of those frameworks.
Research Involving Humans in Australia
To understand how the ethical frameworks that guide Australian health researchers are put into practice it is necessary, first, to understand a little about the broader Australian context. Australia developed as a series of geographically disparate and separately governed colonies, which became states and territories when a federation of colonies was achieved in 1901. Although the resultant Commonwealth of Australia is empowered to enact federal legislation through the Parliament of Australia, the six states and two self-governing territories retain their own legislative domains (state parliaments, territorial legislative assemblies).Footnote 2 As a result, legal and regulatory responses to ethics in healthcare take place within both federal and state frameworks. In addition, the public funding for healthcare,Footnote 3 and the bulk of publicly funded research into healthcare, devolves from federal sources. As a consequence, medical or healthcare researchers seeking public funding must abide by federal guidelines on the ethical treatment of humans in research while also meeting any requirements specific to the state, and the individual institution, in which they work.
The Australian National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) is the federal statutory body that oversees the allocation of federal funds for medical research via national competitive grants schemes, advises on public health to both medical professionals and the community, and has the specific responsibility to provide guidelines for ethical practice in medical research and in healthcare research. Some medical and social science health research is also funded through the Australian Research Council (ARC) and recipients of these grants are also required to abide by the ethical principles for human research as stated by the NHMRC. These two federal agencies are the main source of public funding for university-based or university-affiliated researchers. Although the NHMRC has published guidelines for ethical research in a number of fields, including research involving animals, for the purposes of this article discussion will be restricted to the main document that refers to the principles outlined for the conduct of ethical research involving humans.
As in other countries directly involved in World War II and its aftermath, the formulation of ethical principles in Australian medical research through the NHMRC is heavily indebted to principles enunciated in the Nuremberg Code (1949) and the Declaration of Helsinki (1964). The body specified under the NHMRC act (1992) that is charged with developing ethical guidelines is the Australian Health Ethics Committee (AHEC), which operates under the aegis of the NHMRC. The constitution of AHEC draws “on expertise in philosophy, the ethics of medical research, public health and social science research, clinical medical practice and nursing, disability, law, religion and health consumer issues,”Footnote 4 and membership of the committee is on the basis of a three-year tenure.
The National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research (2007)Footnote 5 is the most recent iteration of the ethical principles formulated by the AHEC, issued by the NHMRC and codeveloped with the ARC and the Australian Vice-Chancellors’ Committee (AVCC, now known as Universities Australia [UA]). The National Statement’s recommendations are based on four broad principles—research merit and integrity, justice, beneficence, and respect for human beings (section 1)—and two main themes: minimizing risk and ensuring adequate (informed) consent, including circumstances in which it may be waived (2.1–2.3). These principles and themes are then applied to the discussion of ethical considerations related to specific fields of human research (qualitative methods [3.1], databanks [3.2], therapies and clinical trials [3.3], human tissues [3.4], human genetics [3.5], and human stem cells [3.6]) and to specific participants (pregnant women and the human fetus [4.1]; children and young people [4.2]; people in dependent or unequal relationships [4.3]; people highly dependent on medical care [4.4]; people with cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness [4.5]; people involved in illegal activities [4.6]; research with Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders [4.7]; and people in other countries [4.8]). In the final section, the National Statement offers advice on appropriate governance and ethical review; sets out the responsibilities (5.1, 5.2)—and accountability (5.7)—of all parties involved in publicly funded research; and addresses conflicts of interest (5.4) and situations in which ethical review may be expedited (5.3), the monitoring of research (5.5), and the handling of complaints (5.6).
Like similar instruments in other countries, over the past decade the National Statement has had to undergo revision to accommodate the ethical dilemmas raised as a result of breakthroughs in embryonic stem cell research (human tissue samples [3.4], human stem cells [3.6]). The other substantial recent addition has been a section specifically devoted to ethics in qualitative methods (3.1), which had been a glaring omission in earlier iterations of ethical principles for researchers, given the preponderance of qualitative research carried out in healthcare settings, particularly in social science–oriented research. The section on specific participants also includes a discussion of research with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples (4.7), which states that healthcare and medical researchers “must consult Values and Ethics: Guidelines for Ethical Conduct in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Research (NHMRC 2003).”Footnote 6 In addition to Values and Ethics,Footnote 7 two other publications—Keeping Research on Track: A Guide for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples about Health Research Ethics (NHMRC 2005)Footnote 8 and Guidelines for Ethical Research in Indigenous Studies (AIATSIS 2002; revised 2011)Footnote 9—are recommended reading for anyone undertaking research with Indigenous Australians, in recognition of the need to redress a long history of colonialist practices on the part of not only government agencies but also medical, healthcare, and social science researchers. We will return to this point toward the end of the article.
The National Statement is the primary instrument to guide researchers with regard to ethical research conduct with humans, and, as the involvement of the AVCC and now the AU implies, it is the primary document to which any university-based researcher must refer in proposing and conducting a research project. As intimated previously, it is also the primary instrument by which researchers in publicly funded hospitals must abide. In practice, that means that any project proposed must be assessed and approved for its compliance with the National Statement by the human research ethics committee (HREC) of the institution(s) involved, as well as by any specific interpretations of the National Statement that institution may have developed. For example, healthcare professionals in publicly funded teaching hospitals—who are employed by both the hospital and the university whose students they teach—who conduct research with humans as defined by the National Statement are answerable to the HREC of the hospital and the HREC of that university.
Let us return to the political structure of Australia for a moment. The National Statement provides guidelines for the conduct of federally funded research. Universities and public hospitalsFootnote 10 are federally funded, so the HRECs of those institutions are committed to acting in compliance with the National Statement. Each university and each hospital has its own HREC, constituted along much the same bases as the AHEC, that is, as a group of informed people of varied expertise (lay and/or professional). State governments and the HREC of their department of health, by and large, support and uphold the implementation of the National Statement. However, what this means in practice is that any researcher, particularly a university-based researcher conducting either trials or social research within a hospital (or across a number of hospitals), will have to comply with the requirements of each separate institutional HREC as directed by each state or territory health department. The involvement of any further bodies that receive public funds—government departments, research institutes, and so on—will entail being answerable to further institutional HRECs. Across Australia, there are more than 200 HRECsFootnote 11 responsible for implementing the National Statement in publicly funded institutions. These are primarily based in hospitals, health services, universities, not-for-profit organizations, and government departments. Another layer of complexity comes into play when we consider the nature of the National Statement itself, which offers guidelines that, unlike rules, are open to interpretation and flexible application by each HREC.
To give a practical example, a colleague’s doctoral research into the social effects of healthcare in relation to an inherited genetic conditionFootnote 12 sourced participants from clinics across three medical institutions. She was required to gain ethics approval from the HREC of each medical institution as well as satisfying the ethics requirements of her supervising university. Each of these institutions abides by the National Statement, and yet each had specific requirements, queries, and revisions as well as separate bureaucratic procedures.Footnote 13 This is far from being an unusual circumstance, particularly when qualitative (social) research into health is being conducted in environments more familiar (and more comfortable) with quantitative methods. The most recent iteration of the National Statement attempts to address this situation by recommending the minimization of duplication of ethical review (5.3), and there have been both federal- and state-based responses to streamlining multisite research by providing templates for use by HRECs.Footnote 14 However, with so many HRECs and, to date, an ad hoc system of training their rolling memberships in the finer points of the National Statement, it is not surprising that there is some lag between the formulation and the implementation of new recommendations.
The Framework in Practice
The development of the National Statement at the federal level attempts to standardize ethical decisionmaking—specifically in relation to research involving humans—across the states and territories. These guidelines may be widely agreed to, and approval in compliance with the guidelines may be required at the level of institutional HRECs, but how these guidelines are implemented in practice is open to interpretation. Nevertheless, as the National Statement makes clear, ethical guidelines for research practice are not the only means by which researchers are regulated.
This National Statement focuses on the ethical aspects of the design, review and conduct of human research. Research ethics is only part of an institution’s responsibilities for research governance. Compliance with legal obligations (statutory or otherwise) forms another part, which is not within the scope of the National Statement.
Some human research is subject to specific statutory regulation, at Commonwealth and State and Territory levels. The National Statement identifies some specific Commonwealth legislation that refers to the National Statement. The National Statement does not identify State and Territory laws that may be relevant to human research, such as those relating to use of information held by state or territory authorities, use of human tissues, guardianship, and illegal and unprofessional conduct.Footnote 15
The specific Commonwealth legislation referred to is the Research Involving Human Embryos Act 2002, and researchers intending to undertake research in this field are not only guided by ethical considerations that restrict what they may research using public funds but also circumscribed by both federal and state law from conducting research that is illegal, even when using private funding—for example, reproductive cloning.
As this excerpt also makes clear, there is further federal (and state) legislation that affects the categories of participants who are discussed within the National Statement (children and young people, women pregnant with human embryos, those in unequal relationships, those dependent on medical care, etc.). As noted at the opening of this article, as a result, legal and regulatory responses to ethics in healthcare take place within both federal and state frameworks, and states may enact legislation independently of the Commonwealth.
Territories, on the other hand, remain subject to the power of the Commonwealth to overrule any laws passed in their legislative assemblies. In relation to ethics in healthcare, the most famous example of the Commonwealth’s ability to exercise this capacity is the short-lived attempt by Exit International founder and activist, Dr. Philip Nitschke, to legalize voluntary euthanasia in the Northern Territory. In the nine months it was in place, under the Rights of the Terminally Ill Act (1995), Dr. Nitschke succeeded in assisting in the legal suicide of several terminally ill people before the Commonwealth intervened and overturned the act.
This capacity to overrule and override the Northern Territory’s legislative assembly is also illustrated by an ethically challenging example in relation to the guidelines provided in the National Statement. In the same year that the most recent iteration of the National Statement was released, 2007, the (then Liberal Coalition conservative) Commonwealth government implemented the Northern Territory National Emergency Response, commonly known as “the Intervention.” The Intervention was a coordinated response to a Northern Territory government report, Little Children Are Sacred,Footnote 16 which was commissioned to investigate concerns about claims of child sexual abuse within remote Indigenous communities in the Northern Territory. In practice, the Intervention took the form of extraordinary measures by the Commonwealth to exert control over Indigenous communities in remote areas in ways that would not have been possible within any state. The response from within Aboriginal and Torres Strait communities and from other interested parties has ranged from qualified support to outright rejection. Qualified support has generally occurred in the form of supporting any improvement of the social and economic disadvantage experienced by Indigenous people, particularly in remote communities, which is undeniably radically disproportionate to that experienced by any other group within, or by the majority of, the Australian population. Rejection of these measures has been based on the, again undeniably, discriminatory methodsFootnote 17 used to enact the Intervention and the heavy-handed and patronizing manner of aspects of its implementation, particularly the Income Management Regime.
Leaving aside the political debates as to whether or not the Intervention and its continued existence under subsequent (Labor) governments is justifiable, the focus here is on the fact that many of the practices involved in implementation of the Intervention involved healthcare professionals and allied healthcare workers. There is a glaring inconsistency between the clear ethical guidelines formulated and approved by the federal agency intimately concerned with ethics in healthcare, which offers specific directives on the particular care to be taken in working and researching with Indigenous Australians, and the policies in action in which health professionals were intimately involved.
The contradiction is all the more apparent because of the federal government’s ability to take control in a way that would be neither tolerated nor possible in any of the six states. Further, at the same time, it is a federal responsibility to direct the formulation of guidelines for ethical practices in healthcare. On the one hand, healthcare researchers working with Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders under the Intervention were being advised by the federal government’s nominated agency to take all care and consideration in conducting research with Indigenous participants, while, on the other hand, at a structural level, those participants were not receiving the same level of ethical consideration, as evidenced by the blanket approach taken to all persons of a given group, regardless of any other factors. Looking at the overarching principles driving the National Statement, the Intervention itself fails miserably as a practice on the grounds of, at least, justice and respect for human beings.
What this brief and contentious example of the complex and contradictory nature of providing healthcare and conducting healthcare research in practice provides is an affirmation of a wider approach to ethical principles, practice, and decisionmaking that is in fact inherent in the National Statement. And the conclusions of this example extend beyond the particular circumstances of the Australian setting. Ethics as a set of points that must be ticked off to satisfy one or more HRECs, in abstracted isolation from wider socioeconomic and political concerns, is not an adequate approach either to healthcare in general or to the conduct of research in a healthcare setting. Ethics, as the National Statement implies, even if it has yet to be uniformly practiced, is a matter of imbibing and regularly returning to ethical principles as healthcare and healthcare research is implemented—in other words, striving for reflective practice.
