This book offers a multimethod, multivoiced picture of an ambitious national experiment in citizen deliberation. It offers insights into both the successes and the shortcomings of the Australian Citizens’ Parliament (ACP) held in Canberra for four days in February 2009.
One measure of the ambition of the effort is that it asked citizens to deliberate not only about issues but which issues to deliberate about. There was an agenda-setting stage both in online forums and regional meetings, as well as at the event itself. The question posed in all three stages was a broad one: “How can Australia’s political system be strengthened to serve us better?” (p. 50). Some questions to ask about this process and its design: Who deliberated? How did they do it? What did they conclude? What effect did it have?
The recruitment process was modeled on the British Columbia Citizens Assembly. A large number of letters were sent out to a random sample (in this case, an initial sample of about 10,000). About 2,700 indicated interest in being included, and from that number eventually 150 face-to-face participants were recruited. There were two draws, and then after substantial dropout, a further recruitment of 51 persons was required to get the 150 (p. 41). As in British Columbia, there is no information about attitudinal representativeness on the issues to be discussed. With so much replacement of dropouts, we do not know who was accepting and who was dropping out, how they felt about Australia’s political system, and what political viewpoints they had to start with.
The organizers in fact stipulated a definition of deliberative democracy whereby such concerns would not matter. “Deliberative democracy” is defined in the book as “a political practice in which demographically representative participants reason together under conditions that promote mutual respect and understanding to arrive at a broadly supported coherent voice which then influences policy development” (p. 31; emphasis added). In fact, the project fell short in fulfilling its demographic criteria (for substantial biases in age and education, see p. 41). But perhaps more important, the exclusive focus on demographic representativeness is undertheorized. Many deliberative democrats would say that a viable minipublic needs to be a credible microcosm of both the viewpoints and the interests of the broader public. Demographics are an indicator of interests. But in a project focused on the shortcomings of the political system, we do not know if those with strong opinions resisted the opportunity to drop out while many others simply lost interest: “Through informal discussions in Canberra it became apparent to most participants just how many of them had been replacements. They expressed surprise that anyone would choose not to take part or change their minds afterwards” (p. 43). Given the design and the limited data collected, the organizers are in no better position than the participants to answer this question of what motivated participation (or nonparticipation). Crucially, there is no knowing how the eventual 150 compared to the initial 10,000 in their substantive political viewpoints on the kinds of issues that were to be discussed.
Since there was a very high degree of self-selection among the CPs (citizen parliamentarians), however, and since we do not know their starting viewpoints, what is the normative case for paying attention to the viewpoints with which they ended up? The normative theory behind the design of this exercise would seem to require more of a response to this question than a simple stipulation at the beginning that only demographics are a concern. In fact, the organizers in their conclusion seem to change their position and offer the claim at the end of the book that “the ACP achieved a level of demographic and attitudinal diversity that proved essential to its success” (p. 297; emphasis added). It is not clear what data support this claim.
There are other design issues that many minipublic advocates would question. The participants were randomly reshuffled after every group discussion to be with new people. Instead of the small groups building on the discussions and their level of mutual trust, the organizers had, in effect, to start from scratch after every break. One could argue that this method increased exposure to diversity. But it also had a cost in the progress of the deliberations. In any case, it is a distinctive approach worth studying in the transcripts of the group discussions.
Another notable decision was the idea of measuring inequality in the discussions through the distribution of “speaking turns.” Equality is not defined in terms of the number of words or minutes but in terms of equality in the number of turns participants take speaking. But if some use their turns to speak at great length and others use their turns to speak only briefly, it is possible that an equal number of speaking turns could mask domination of the dialogue by the long-winded talkers. Another design issue is that the organizers allowed the experts to participate directly in the dialogues in the small groups. But the expert speaking turns were not counted in the calculations about inequality. We do not know how influential the experts were in the small groups. Crucially, whatever they said was only available to that group. Other designs have the experts only in plenary sessions where their statements can be challenged by other experts speaking before the assembled sample so that citizens do not adopt views through simple deference to unchallenged expert opinion. By placing them directly in the small groups, the design opens itself up to possible domination by experts whose views go unchallenged by rival experts representing different points of view.
Most importantly, what did the deliberators decide and why? We know surprisingly little about this. There were 13 top proposals, but they differed little at the end from those at the beginning: “There turned out to be relatively limited change between the original proposals and the final list—nine proposals were unchanged” (p. 211). And some that did change seem to be close variations. “Empowering citizens to participate in politics” seems to have become “empower citizens to participate in politics through education” and “empower citizens to participate in politics through youth community engagement” ( p. 207).
These proposals are stated with a high degree of generality, without specificity of trade-offs. We know little about why the participants came to the views that they did. Even though there are transcripts of the group discussions, very little use is made of them to shed light on the arguments supporting and opposing what was decided: “The proposed structural changes all involved more unified and centralized government. The liberal norm of subsidiarity which was urged by several expert presenters appears to have counted less among the CPs than efficiency and uniformity” (p. 212). What happened in the group discussions to support these conclusions? It is left mysterious. The same is true for the fall in support for “A Bill of Rights” (p. 213). The organizers speculate that it may have been something in the small groups. The question suggests that the small group discussions need to be analyzed further. If the point of deliberative democracy is to express the will of the people after they have really thought about the issues, then we need to know more than what proposals they supported and opposed. We need to know why.
The organizers note that the project had limited coverage and limited impact—except for the fact that proposals with high priority were presented to politicians. Nevertheless, the project gave expression to the aspirations for deliberative democracy in a country with a notable history of democratic reform. The tale is told from many different perspectives, sometimes in dialogue form, sometimes with narrative, and sometimes with data. The Australian Citizens’ Parliament and the Future of Deliberative Democracy makes a contribution to the field because it recounts, with frankness and clarity, what worked and what did not. For those engaged in these experiments, it is essential reading.
